The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Chris McMonigle is not holding back on the Yankees and Brian Cashman's performance at the trade deadline, ripping the GM for only adding Luis Garcia Jr. and Heliot Ramos while AL East rivals like the Red Sox and Rays both beefed up at catcher, New York's biggest need. C-Mac sounds off on what he considers to be Cashman's worst deadline ever, how the Yankees will configure their roster now that Ramos and Garcia are in the fold, and try to make sense of how the Yanks did not add a catcher. News also broke during recording that the Yankees are calling up top prospect George Lombard Jr. and sending down Anthony Volpe and Jasson Dominguez. Plus, reactions to a crushing loss against the Cardinals, the bullpen implosion, and Garcia's instant impact.

EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS

9:48 - Chris goes off on what he calls Brian Cashman's worst trade deadline, perhaps ever. He expresses utter disbelief that the team didn't acquire a starting-caliber catcher or an extra relief pitcher.

20:59 - BREAKING NEWS: George Lombard Promoted! Reacting live to a report from Jack Curry, McMonigle breaks the news that prospect George Lombard is being called up to the majors immediately.

31:51 - Official word comes down that Anthony Volpe and Jasson Dominguez are being optioned to Triple-A. Chris analyzes what this means for the infield and theorizes that Lombard will take over as the everyday shortstop.

41:22 - Was the front office's passive trade deadline dictated by Aaron Judge's injury status?. McMonigle theorizes that the Yankees' lack of aggression signifies they just want to survive until October, rather than overextend themselves for a World Series push now.

54:14 - Chris hands out a "D-" grade for the Yankees' trade deadline moves. Despite his deep frustration, he reminds fans that the season isn't over and the team is still positioned for a playoff run.

Craig and Big Mac analyze the Yankees' trade deadline decisions before welcoming General Manager Brian Cashman to the show. They discuss the choice not to overpay for a catcher and the reasoning behind promoting prospect George Lombard to the starting shortstop role. Cashman also provides vital updates on the injury status of Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton.

(00:01:50) Yankee Fan Frustrations

(00:06:31) Cashman's Trade Philosophy

(00:12:34) Steinbrenner's Absentee Ownership

(00:25:43) MLB Record Analysis

(00:29:55) Aaron Judge's Legacy

(00:50:40) Vincent Pastore Memories

(01:15:12) Brian Cashman Interview

Craig and Big Mac dissect the New York Yankees' inactive trade deadline and the subsequent bullpen collapse against the St. Louis Cardinals. They criticize the decision of team executives to conduct business from Tampa rather than New York City. The conversation also covers Aaron Judge's future legacy and a major shake-up for the Sunday Night Football broadcast team.

(00:01:20) Yankees Trade Deadline Criticism

(00:06:15) Cashman's Failure To Pivot

(00:11:15) Executives Staying In Tampa

(00:18:45) NFL Studio Crew Changes

(00:25:15) Brewers Best In Baseball

(00:29:45) Aaron Judge Legacy Debate

(00:34:15) Rucco And Sims Calls

(00:41:20) Rutschman Trade Values

Craig and the team analyze the New York Yankees' decision to call up George Lombard Jr. while sending down Anthony Volpe. They debate Jasson Domínguez's defensive instincts and if Aaron Judge's legacy would diminish if the team wins a title during his injury absence. The conversation shifts to a bizarre theory about Babe Ruth and a critique of Joe Schoen's reputation.

(00:01:20) George Lombard Jr. Joins Yankees

(00:05:50) Volpe And Dominguez Career Outlooks

(00:14:04) Aaron Judge's World Series Legacy

(00:18:22) Babe Ruth Conspiracy Theories

(00:22:30) Historic Household Income Debate

(00:29:56) Yankees Potential Roster Logjam

(00:34:06) Joe Schoen and Pat Leonard

They analyze Brian Cashman's tenure with the Yankees and debate whether consistent winning seasons justify his job security despite a lack of recent titles. The discussion covers potential Francisco Lindor trade inquiries and how Aaron Judge's absence affects the team's mental performance. Craig also details a bizarre situation where a critic in Ireland is attempting to block his induction into the New Rochelle High School Hall of Fame.

(00:02:04) Cashman's Yankee Legacy

(00:07:47) Mets Hiring Cashman Rumors

(00:12:32) Big Mac Weight Loss Progress

(00:19:15) Hunter Dobbins' Lying Scandal

(00:23:38) Fake Sports Career Stories

(00:29:24) Yankees Athleticism Without Judge

(00:36:03) Francisco Lindor Trade Talk

(00:46:30) Press Box Etiquette Debate

(00:57:00) Craig's New Rochelle Hall Drama

Craig and Big Mac interview Yankees General Manager Brian Cashman to analyze the team's strategy following the trade deadline. They discuss why the organization did not acquire a new catcher or reliever, the promotion of George Lombard Jr., and the decision to demote Anthony Volpe. The segment also covers crucial health updates regarding Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton.

(00:01:20) Diddy Party Discussion

(00:04:55) Cashman Legacy Argument

(00:10:46) Boston COVID Misery

(00:14:00) Remembering Vincent Pastore

(00:19:24) Brian Cashman Interview

(00:30:35) George Lombard Jr. Promotion

(00:44:44) Anthony Volpe Demotion

(00:49:43) Yankees Trade Targets