The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go completely off the rails on WFAN!

The guys start with the latest on Aaron Judge’s injury imaging and Yankees return timeline, then somehow spiral into a hilarious debate about KFC, Taco Bell, fake beef, explosive diarrhea, pina coladas, mudslides, and banana daiquiris.

Anthony Gallo walked into The Carton Show studio and immediately became Craig Carton’s latest target! Craig absolutely ROASTS Gallo over his tight soccer jersey, sparking a hilarious debate with Chris McMonigle over his wardrobe.

But the chaos doesn’t stop there. Craig tells an incredible story about playing pickup basketball with a member of Boyz II Men dressed head-to-toe like Michael Jordan, C-Mac reveals the bizarre movie connected to the night his first child was conceived, and everyone is stunned to learn Craig has NEVER heard of Stephen King’s It.

Craig Carton has had enough! After watching the 2026 MLB All-Star Game, Craig goes OFF on American sports fans for constantly complaining about everything — too much pitching, not enough offense, boring games, bad entertainment and more.

Chris McMonigle pushes back as the guys debate whether the All-Star Game exposed a bigger problem with modern baseball — or with the fans watching it. Plus, Craig and C-Mac react to Boyz II Men’s rough performance and discuss encouraging comments from Giants coach John Harbaugh about letting Jaxson Dart use his legs.

Big Mac and Craig Carton dissect the revamped Home Run Derby format and the rowdy crowd atmosphere in Philadelphia. They transition to local football, debating whether Jaxson Dart is the franchise savior for the Giants and if Geno Smith can lead the Jets past their "crap magnet" reputation. The segment also includes lighthearted banter regarding Aruba vacation stories and an intern challenge involving cinnamon candy.

01:53 - Home Run Derby Debate

06:20 - All Star Event Rankings

11:22 - Jets Football Expectations

15:46 - Jaxson Dart Mentality

19:30 - Podcast With Lil Wayne

26:10 - Stanton Hall Of Fame

30:50 - AFC East Predictions

35:21 - Analyzing Lamar Jackson

40:35 - Giants Win Totals

48:10 - Elite Quarterback Tiers

57:05 - Intern Trivia Challenge

01:03:00 - Red Hots Challenge

37:45 - Lesbian Cricket Triangle

44:20 - Aruba Shark Story

01:02:10 - Spain Beats France

08:00 - Geno Smith Cleared

Carton and Big Mac clash over the entertainment value of the Home Run Derby before diving into the future of New York's football franchises. They discuss the contrasting off-seasons of Jaxson Dart and Geno Smith, leading Carton to issue a controversial prediction about divisional success.

01:30 - Home Run Derby Debate

04:45 - All-Star Event Quality

09:24 - Ben Rice Derby Struggles

12:40 - Geno Smith Off-Field Issues

16:28 - Jaxson Dart Offseason Focus

20:04 - Giants Training Camp Expectations

23:33 - New York Football Culture

31:28 - Bold AFC East Prediction

35:23 - Comparing NFL Quarterback Futures

38:55 - Big Mac Giant Loyalty

Craig and Big Mac debate whether Giancarlo Stanton is a lock for the Hall of Fame despite his recurring injury history with the Yankees. They also discuss the hype surrounding Jackson Dart as a potential savior for the Giants and rank the elite tier of NFL quarterbacks.

02:00 - Live Charity Podcast Announcement

10:19 - Giancarlo Stanton Hall of Fame

16:30 - Giants and Jackson Dart

29:55 - Ranking Elite NFL Quarterbacks

33:01 - Home Run Derby Recap

40:16 - Lamar Jackson Passing Debate

50:15 - Best Cheesesteaks and Food

Craig Carton puts Joe the Intern through a gauntlet of sports trivia and a spicy Red Hots challenge to earn a higher internship grade. He and Chris McMonigle delve into a debate over Eli Manning’s Hall of Fame credentials and the New York Giants' historically low win totals. They also analyze the upcoming NFL schedule and share personal vacation stories.

01:50 - Testing Joe The Intern

08:14 - NY Jets Hall Of Famers

15:30 - Eli Manning Hall Debate

23:53 - Vikings Versus Giants Predictions

38:14 - Intern Red Hots Challenge

49:15 - Giants 2024 Schedule Breakdown

55:27 - Big Mac's StainAway Invention

01:02:40 - Jets And Giants History

Craigie and Big Mac debate the logistics of a high-profile love triangle in Australian women's cricket before diving into the controversial practice of holding beach chairs in Aruba. They also entertain colorful callers, including a former model with five marriage proposals and a Giants fan looking for a favor. The segment concludes with a breakdown of recent World Cup results and the varying levels of optimism for the Jets and Giants this season.

01:45 - Lesbian Cricket Love Triangle

05:30 - Aruba Beach Chair Etiquette

13:15 - Peggy O's Modeling Past

22:05 - Radio Staff Vacation Feud

28:35 - World Cup Soccer Upset

34:10 - Football Season Optimism

Chris McMonigle evaluates the news that Geno Smith will not face battery charges following a recent investigation and reflects on the quarterback's off-field issues. He also discusses the New York Giants' coaching stability compared to the Tom Coughlin era and shares optimism for Jaxson Dart before looking ahead to the MLB trade deadline.

01:00 - MLB All-Star and Giants Talk

08:05 - Geno Smith Legal Update

13:10 - MLB Trade Deadline Outlook

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are at it again over C-Mac’s upcoming vacation plans! After a caller tries to defend C-Mac, Craig doubles down on why taking two weeks off is apparently “outlandish” — while C-Mac fires back that he’s earned every single vacation day.