Judaism for the Thinking Person

The Commandment of Shevut: How Do We Handle its Inherent Subjectivity?


Listen Later

In Deuteronomy, we are commanded to keep Shabbat as restfulness.  Many are unaware that this does not just involve practicing the Shabbat observances and restrictions --Biblical and Rabbinic-- but the highly unusual special-to-itself halakhic category of "Shevut," usually translated as proactively keeping "the spirit of Shabbat."  The category of observing "the spirit of Shabbat" is inherently subjective, and it can vary from person to person.  For one person, reading a newspaper on Shabbat is a violation of the spirit of Shabbat, while for another it enhances the spirit of Shabbat.  Going someplace for Shabbat dinner or lunch might enhance the spirit for one, but for another take away from the Shabbat spirit of the sanctuary of home.  The issue has come to the fore with the electric car.  Since an EV has no fire within in, and electricity meets none of the halakhic prohibitions, its use on Shabbat largely comes down the category of shevut.  This has produces two approved Responsa of the Conservative Movement, which are largely hostile to one another.  In one, anybody considering the use of an EV on Shabbat should be considered in violation of the law, and shevut should not be considered subjective, but actually somehow defined by a small group of rabbinic authorities others in perpetuity!  (It's like saying, How dare you read your psychology textbook on Shabbat!  That's homework!  Even though you are allowed to read on Shabbat and you love psychology.)  The other group decries this attempt to take over and monopolize our one subjective category.  I explore the issues.  

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Judaism for the Thinking PersonBy Rabbi Nadav Caine

  • 4.4
  • 4.4
  • 4.4
  • 4.4
  • 4.4

4.4

31 ratings


More shows like Judaism for the Thinking Person

View all
Snap Judgment by Snap Judgment and PRX

Snap Judgment

11,642 Listeners

The Rabbi Sacks Legacy by Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks

The Rabbi Sacks Legacy

555 Listeners

The Tikvah Podcast by Tikvah

The Tikvah Podcast

655 Listeners

For Heaven's Sake by Shalom Hartman Institute, Ark Media

For Heaven's Sake

461 Listeners

Ask Haviv Anything by Haviv Rettig Gur

Ask Haviv Anything

924 Listeners