This episode investigates the perplexing disappearance of Nicole Sherese Cearo, a young, pregnant woman who vanished from Seattle, Washington, on March 30, 2009. It outlines Nicole's challenging upbringing and the troubling circumstances surrounding her last known movements, which included a history of domestic violence with her boyfriend, Roosevelt Montgomery Jr. The text details the police investigation, highlighting critical setbacks such as delayed reporting and the loss of potential forensic evidence from a stolen truck linked to Montgomery. Despite Montgomery's suspicious behavior and alleged confessions, the case remains unsolved due to a lack of concrete evidence, leaving Nicole's family without answers and underscoring the difficulties in missing persons cases involving vulnerable individuals and domestic violence.