P-Car Talk Podcast

The Floor Keeps Rising


Listen Later

Thank You to the Kimchi Crew

Before we get into it, a genuine thank you to everyone who listens, supports the show, and keeps this community alive. You know who you are. We do this because we love it, and you make it worth doing. Now let's get into it.

Detroit IMSA: BOP'd Into Irrelevance

The Porsche GT3R at Detroit was so heavily Balance of Performance'd that it was barely a factor, and the prototype entries qualified so far back in such a short enduro format that catching up was a near-impossible ask before the green flag even dropped. But let's be honest with ourselves here: IMSA was on GM's side from the jump. The race is in Detroit, GM's backyard, and anyone paying attention could feel the gravitational pull toward keeping the home team looking good. This isn't new. The frustration with series organizers placating to manufacturers based on geography or politics is real, and it's a recurring stain on what should be a pure competition. When the racing result feels predetermined by the city it's held in, that's a problem worth calling out.

The 911 Market Is Not Coming Back Down

We touched the surface of this last episode when we talked about Mezger-engine GT3s drying up and the 993 price surge, but it's time to go deeper because the numbers are getting genuinely hard to rationalize. 997 Carrera S's: a green manual with 35k miles is asking $108k. Midnight blue, 55k miles, manual, asking $90k. For a Carrera S. Let that sit. 996 Turbos, which we've covered before, are now seeing 95k-mile manual cars asking $90k. The market logic here is that against the backdrop of new Porsche prices, these feel like deals to people entering the hobby. And look, we get it, but that doesn't make the numbers any less wild.

The broader picture is this: if you are chasing a manual 911 of any generation, any configuration, the era of stumbling into a good deal is over. Base 991.1s with 50 to 80k miles are moving at $65k to $80k. Base Carrera, not an S, not a GTS. And before anyone says you can still find a reasonable 996 base 911 for $35k to $40k with 90k miles -- we'd push back hard on that. That is not a bargain. That is a lot of money for a car that will demand attention and investment. The "affordable 911" narrative needs to be retired.

Here's the thing we want to be transparent about: there is zero financial incentive for us to tell you to go buy a car. We don't get a cut. But if you want a manual 911 and you're sitting on the fence, today is genuinely the better bet than tomorrow, because every data point we're seeing says the floor keeps rising regardless of generation. This is not a bubble in the traditional sense. These are driver's cars with a finite supply of desirable manual configurations in a world that stopped producing them. Why do you think this keeps going up? We'd love to hear from the community on that.

What makes this genuinely upsetting, not just analytically frustrating, is that the price appreciation is pricing out exactly the people who should be owning these cars. The passionate ones. The ones who would drive them, maintain them right, and actually care. Instead they end up with people for whom it's a flex or a garage sculpture. That's a gut punch for anyone who's been in this community long enough to remember when that wasn't the case.

JC9 Carrera GT: A Solution Looking for a Problem

The JC9 is essentially a reimagined Carrera GT body with visual cues borrowed from the 917. On paper that sounds compelling, but sitting with it longer brings up some real questions. The Carrera GT doesn't need to be fixed. It is one of the most celebrated analog driver's cars ever made. Slapping a new body on the concept and marketing it to ultra-wealthy buyers who want something exclusive feels like the automotive equivalent of a solution looking for a problem. KISS. Keep it simple. The military drilled that into some of us for good reason, and it applies here. The original formula was right. The more the car world chases bespoke reinventions of icons for nine-figure clientele, the further it drifts from what made those icons matter in the first place. Thoughts on this one? We have mixed feelings and we're not hiding it.

Indecent 911 Hatchback Wagon: Cool Idea or Vaporware?

The renders coming out of Indecent for a custom 911 hatchback/wagon are genuinely striking. They look cool. Full stop. But the question that always follows something like this is whether this is another "put your money where your mouth is" moment, where the concept gets traction on the internet and then quietly disappears when build deposits don't materialize. The 911 community has seen this cycle before. People love the idea of something unconventional until they have to actually commit to it. Is there a real market for a coachbuilt 911 wagon? Maybe. Is the execution going to live up to renders that were made to generate buzz? That's always the harder question. What do you think -- cool and you'd want one, or a stunt?

Outro

That's a wrap on this one. Catch us at pcartalk.com for upcoming events, support the show over at Patreon.com/pcartalk, and find us on social at @pcartalk. As always -- Kimchi Crew: Steve, Leslie, Chris, Ken, Aaron, Matthew, Sean, and Nik.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

P-Car Talk PodcastBy Pcar Talk

  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7
  • 4.7

4.7

159 ratings


More shows like P-Car Talk Podcast

View all
CarCast by Bleav, Carcast

CarCast

2,418 Listeners

The Smoking Tire by Zack Klapman, Matt Farah

The Smoking Tire

2,716 Listeners

Everyday Driver Car Debate by Everyday Driver

Everyday Driver Car Debate

2,043 Listeners

Spike's Car Radio by Spike Feresten

Spike's Car Radio

1,187 Listeners

Behind The Glass by Seen Through Glass

Behind The Glass

246 Listeners

TFL Car Chat by www.allTFL.com

TFL Car Chat

325 Listeners

The Intercooler by Dan Prosser and Andrew Frankel

The Intercooler

146 Listeners

9WERKS Radio : The Porsche and Car Podcast by Andy Brookes, Lee Sibley, Max Newman

9WERKS Radio : The Porsche and Car Podcast

50 Listeners

Porsche Club Insider by Porsche Club of America

Porsche Club Insider

122 Listeners

The InEVitable by MotorTrend

The InEVitable

126 Listeners

THIS CAR POD! with Doug DeMuro & Friends! by Doug DeMuro

THIS CAR POD! with Doug DeMuro & Friends!

375 Listeners

The Carmudgeon Show by Hagerty Media

The Carmudgeon Show

333 Listeners

Eleven After Nine | A Porsche Culture Podcast by Derek

Eleven After Nine | A Porsche Culture Podcast

92 Listeners

The Car Podcast with Chris Harris & Friends by Chris Harris

The Car Podcast with Chris Harris & Friends

131 Listeners

The evo podcast by evo

The evo podcast

14 Listeners