Send us a text

A split jury verdict that defied expectations. Three men dead. A defendant who confessed but later died by suicide in prison. The Lexington Triple Homicide conclusion reveals the devastating consequences when drug culture, family violence, and opportunity collide.

The detective's theory makes disturbing sense – victims who crashed hard after a "420 party" would have been unconscious when the shooter entered, explaining why neither woke when the other was killed. "People who do cocaine take the edge off with things that shut them down. It's how a lot of people actually die—they take speedballs," explains the James York from The 13th Floor Podcast, piecing together the timeline of this tragedy.

What unfolds in the courtroom proves equally compelling. The Department of Public Advocacy mounted an extraordinary defense, scrutinizing every piece of evidence through rarely-seen chain of custody hearings. Despite overwhelming ballistic evidence connecting all three murders to the same .38 caliber revolver found with Ricky, the jury delivered a stunning split decision – guilty of killing two victims but not his stepfather.

This case forces us to confront difficult questions about justice, extreme emotional disturbance as a legal defense, and the devastating ripple effects of violence. When Ricky later took his own life in prison, the tragedy claimed yet another victim, leaving his mother to grieve both her husband and son. His child would grow up without answers, and multiple families would be forever changed.

The weight of serving on a capital murder jury, the psychology behind split verdicts, and the lasting trauma on investigators and families alike – this episode explores it all while honoring the victims whose lives were cut tragically short. Listen now to understand what really happened in this haunting Kentucky case where everyone involved lost something precious.

 
Did you know that the episode you are about to listen to is available on YouTube as a full multicamera experience? Search for The Murder Police Podcast channel on YouTube, subscribe and see what you have been missing. 

https://www.youtube.com/c/TheMurderPolicePodcast 

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.

See what you have been missing on YouTube!