The Murder Police Podcast

Send us a text

What happens when hope turns into heartbreak, and the search for answers stretches into years? Join us as we bring you the harrowing story of Little Timmy Sterner through the intimate and heart-wrenching accounts of his father, Tim, and his father's girlfriend, Ashley Wethington. From the depths of grief to the highs of cherished memories, this episode peels back the layers of a family's pain and their relentless quest for closure. You’ll hear of Timmy's joyful childhood, his special bond with his grandfather, and his love for football, juxtaposed with the darker times when he lost his way and ended up in prison.

Feel the raw emotion as Timmy's father shares the daily agony of his son's disappearance, reflecting on the struggles of maintaining a connection during incarceration and the heartache of re-entry into society. Ashley’s poignant perspective adds another layer, capturing the collective despair and the ripple effects of Timmy's absence on their family. This episode is not just a recounting of a tragic case but a heartfelt plea to the community for information, underscoring the power of collective support in seeking justice. Tune in and be part of this urgent call for answers, as we unite in the desperate hope for resolution.

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.

See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

Season Ten Premiere!

Welcome back to The Murder Police Podcast! As we bid farewell to Season Nine, we are thrilled to dive into Season Ten with renewed vigor and a fresh studio setup. 

In this episode, Wendy and David reflect on the journey so far and provide a sneak peek into the gripping cases that will be explored this season.

Our hosts take a moment to reminisce about the impactful episodes of Season Nine, including the enlightening discussions on police polygraphs with Eddie Pearson and the role of a prosecutor with Louanna Red Corn. They also revisit the heart-wrenching case of Letha Rutherford, whose tragic story was meticulously covered in a six-part series.

As we transition into Season Ten, Wendy and David introduce the haunting case of Timmy Sterner, a young man who went missing shortly after being released from incarceration. Through interviews with Timmy’s family and friends, this season aims to uncover the truth behind his mysterious disappearance and bring justice to his grieving loved ones.

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.

See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

What happens when a community's hope clashes with the haunting void left by an unresolved tragedy? Experience the chilling narrative of "Who Killed Letha?" as we welcome Clifford Taylor to share his heartfelt memories and personal connection to the Taylor family. Clifford presents an intimate portrayal of Letha's life, from her childhood nurtured by parents with an indomitable work ethic to her tragic disappearance. He recounts their touching final encounter, where Letha revealed her plans for a fresh start by assisting the police and returning to school, painting a poignant picture of a life cut short too soon.

Journey with us through the emotional labyrinth of the search for Letha Taylor, highlighted by Clifford's vivid recollections of the family's unity and the profound absence left by Letha's father, Hoghead. This episode uncovers the intense community efforts to find Letha, the disturbing whispers and rumors, and the grim discovery at the location where she was last seen. Clifford shares the complexities of conflicting stories and the persistent yearning for justice, encapsulating the heartache and relentless pursuit for truth in a case that continues to weigh heavily on all who knew Letha. Tune in to this gripping episode and join us in the quest to uncover the truth and seek justice for Letha Rutherford.

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.

See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

What if the key to solving a decades-old murder mystery was hidden in plain sight? Join us as we unravel the haunting and intricate story of Letha, a young girl whose sudden disappearance and tragic death have left a community in shock and despair. This episode recounts the frantic search efforts by her family and friends, the chilling discovery of her body under a pile of tin and wood behind her house, and the disturbing evidence that suggests she may have been moved posthumously. We confront the unsettling questions around the initial, seemingly thorough, search and the mysterious circumstances of her reappearance months later.

In this emotionally charged episode, we delve into the suspicious events surrounding Letha's disappearance, including eerie visits to a house infamous for chicken fighting, and the discovery of bloody sheets and a missing knife. We reflect on the relentless pursuit of justice by her aunt Mary, who has spent decades seeking answers amidst community fears and missed investigative opportunities. As we piece together firsthand accounts and minor details, we hold onto the hope that new leads might finally bring the closure Letha’s family has longed for over thirty years. Tune in for a powerful exploration of justice, loss, and the enduring quest for truth.

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.

See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

In the latest episode of the Murder Police Podcast, we delve into the heart-wrenching story of Letha, a young woman whose life was cut tragically short. This episode stands out not only for its compelling narrative but also for the emotional depth provided by our special guests, Miss Beverly and Patches, who were Letha’s aunt and cousin, respectively.

From the outset, listeners are cautioned about the graphic nature of the content, which includes violent assaults and murder. This warning sets the tone for an episode that is as raw as it is revealing. Miss Beverly and Patches take us back to their childhood, sharing fond memories of Letha, who was more like a daughter to Miss Beverly and a sister to Patches. These recollections paint a vivid picture of a vibrant young girl who loved playing in the creek, catching crawdads, and spending time with her family.

As Letha grew older, the dynamics within her family changed dramatically. Her father's sudden death from a heart attack left her feeling lost and anxious. This sense of instability was exacerbated when her mother remarried and moved away, leaving Letha and her brother to fend for themselves. The episode poignantly captures Letha’s struggle to find her footing in a world that seemed increasingly uncertain.

One of the most gripping moments comes when Miss Beverly recounts the last time she saw Letha. She describes how Letha seemed unusually anxious and sad, a stark contrast to the lively girl she once knew. This sense of foreboding only deepens when Patches reveals that Letha had confided in her about being afraid of certain people who frequented her home. Despite these warning signs, no one could have predicted the tragic turn of events that would soon unfold.

The investigation into Letha’s disappearance is meticulously detailed, highlighting the exhaustive efforts made by her family and the police to find her. From missing posters to search parties, the community rallied together, but it wasn’t until months later that the grim reality of Letha’s fate was confirmed. This search for answers and the subsequent discovery of her body is a sobering reminder of the fragility of life and the devastating impact of violence.

Throughout the episode, the host, Wendy Lyons, handles the narrative with sensitivity and respect, ensuring that Letha’s story is told with the dignity it deserves. They also provide valuable insights into the broader implications of such tragedies, emphasizing the importance of community support and the relentless pursuit of justice.

For true crime enthusiasts, this episode is a must-listen. It offers a compelling blend of personal anecdotes, investigative details, and emotional depth that will leave listeners both moved and informed. Tune in to the Murder Police Podcast to hear the full story and honor the memory of Letha, a young woman whose life and legacy continue to resonate.

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.

See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

Imagine the haunting echo of a mystery unsolved for over three decades; the poignant story of Letha, a girl who vanished without a trace, and the relentless quest for answers. This episode unveils the intimate memories of Shannon Crawley, Letha's best friend, who recounts the vibrancy of their youth and the harrowing turn of events that led to Letha's disappearance. Step through a portal to the rural life of the 1980s, where the innocence of teenage exploration intertwines with the grief of a family tragedy, painting a vivid backdrop for the profound loss that followed.

The heart of our conversation lies within the walls of what was once a bustling general store turned modest home, a cornerstone of community and simple living. Here, Shannon takes us on a nostalgic tour of their cherished hangouts and shared experiences, from the Jessamine Joree to the impact of Letha's older brother stepping into the patriarchal void. The tapestry of rural living, steeped in both warmth and sorrow, sets the stage for the unsettling void left by Letha's disappearance, igniting a search fraught with frustration and despair as friends and family grappled with the unknown.

As the narrative unfolds, we traverse the difficult path of the investigation – from the discovery of Letha's remains to the piercing questions that haunt Shannon and all who knew Letha. Through a raw and emotional recounting, we confront the chilling possibility of foul play and the enduring ache for closure that lingers like a shadow. This episode is not just a tale of a young life cut tragically short but a living testament to the enduring bond of friendship and the unyielding hope for justice. Join us as we honor Letha's memory and amplify the call for answers that have escaped her loved ones for far too long.

Watch this episode on The Murder Police Podcast YouTube channel!
https://youtu.be/imtm33HHRWU

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.

See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

The echoes of a haunting family mystery reverberate through the years, touching lives across generations. When 20-year-old Hannah Hafley, niece of the late Letha Rutherford, joins us, she brings a fervent plea for long-overdue justice in a case that has remained unsolved for over thirty years. As we sit down with Hannah, her determination is palpable; despite never having met her aunt, she shares the profound impact Letha's unsolved murder has had on her family, especially the anguish it has caused her father and grandmother. Through a moving recount of her personal mission to reignite interest in the investigation, Hannah embodies the tenacity and dedication it takes to confront such an enduring tragedy.

Throughout our emotional conversation, Hannah's courage is at the forefront as she calls upon the community to break their silence and aid in piecing together the puzzle of her aunt's untimely death. It's a story that pulls at the heartstrings, not only showcasing the depth of family bonds but also highlighting the relentless spirit of youth in pursuit of truth. Listeners are invited to journey with us as we navigate the poignant memories, navigate the renewed efforts in finding Letha's killer, and witness the unyielding hope for closure that ignites the path towards justice. Hannah's voice, representing a new generation seeking answers, resonates with the clarity and determination necessary to keep Letha's story alive and to finally find the peace that has eluded her family for far too long.

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.

See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

Have you ever pondered the tireless work that goes into solving a homicide case? Join me, David, as I sit with Lexington detectives Travis Holt and Brandon Gibbs to delve into the chilling story of Letha Rutherford, an 18-year-old whose disappearance morphed into a haunting pursuit for justice. We discuss the intricate dance between instinct and evidence as these seasoned detectives recount the evolution of their careers and the life-altering influence of mentorship in their relentless search for answers. Their narratives promise not only a profound look at the inner machinations of crime-solving but also a tribute to the victims and the undying spirit of those who serve to bring closure.

In the labyrinth of unsolved mysteries, hope flickers anew with the introduction of a dynamic website dedicated to cold cases, emphasizing the crucial role community involvement plays in unearthing long-buried truths. Every listener becomes a potential key to unlocking secrets as we explore how even the smallest tip can shatter years of silence. This episode isn't just a recount of past events; it's a clarion call to action for anyone who believes in the power of collective effort and digital connectivity to aid detectives like Travis and Brandon in their quest to ensure no case, no matter how cold, is ever truly forgotten.

If you have any information about Letha's unsolved murder, call the Lexington Police Department in Lexington Kentucky at 859-258-3600, or, submit a real-time tip at https://www.lexingtonky.gov/case-1991-94536.

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.

See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

What happens when the threads of a loved one's life suddenly go cold? We grapple with this harrowing reality as we unravel the case of Rhonda Day's unexplained disappearance, a narrative that is as confounding as it is heartbreaking. With Rhonda's car found abandoned and critical evidence preservation steps missed, the anguish experienced by her family is palpable. Our discussion reveals the exhaustive efforts made to locate vital video footage that could illuminate Rhonda's last known movements, emphasizing the potential of technology in this painstaking quest. Each turn in the search brings more questions than answers, spotlighting the unique complexities of adult missing person cases and the resilient determination of a family in the face of uncertainty.

This episode paints an intimate portrait of Rhonda Faye, from her distinctive blonde hair and green eyes to the sunshine tattoo that could help bring her home. The absence of her phone, iPad, car keys, and most tellingly, her purse, casts a shadow of mystery over the investigation. As we share the desperate measures taken by her family and their push for community involvement, we extend a heartfelt invitation to our listeners—any information could tip the scales towards resolution. We close with a direct line to the Louisville Metro Police Department, a beacon of hope for those eager to assist. Through this emotional dialogue, we not only seek to elevate Rhonda's story but also to ignite a flame of hope that might lead to her safe return.

Previously covered by Vanished Pod: https://www.thevanishedpodcast.com/episodes/2020/3/9/episode-215-rhonda-day

and by Cason Hudson on YouTube: Where is Rhonda Day? Missing in Louisville, Ky.

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.

See what you have been missing on YouTube!

Send us a text

Join us in this intriguing investigation into the disappearance of Rhonda Day in 2018. Uncover the mysterious circumstances surrounding her vanishing and follow the clues to discover the truth behind where Rhonda is. Watch now to unravel the enigma of the missing Rhonda Day. Don't forget to like, share, and subscribe for more true crime content!

When a loved one vanishes without a trace, the world seems to hold its breath. Our podcast this week breathes life into the tale of Rhonda Day, guided by the intimate recollections of Destiny and Melissa, her heartbroken family members. Together, we craft a living portrait of Rhonda, a soul characterized by her generosity and fierce love for her grandmother. Stories of her youthful curiosity blend with those of her adult kindness, like the time she tenderly cared for a post-surgery relative or painted rocks with the community, all signposts of a life dedicated to others. Amidst the laughter and tears, we channel the essence of a woman whose absence has left an indelible void, hoping that these shared memories might spark a clue to her whereabouts.

Transitioning through the emotional landscape of Rhonda's narrative, we also celebrate her humorous and animal-loving spirit. Her playful pranks echo in our conversation as much as her compassionate work with the elderly and her escape into the world of books. But it's not just tales we trade; we grapple with the hard truths of her disappearance, considering how her trusting nature and struggle with substance use could have intersected with her fate. Rhonda's story is more than a mystery; it's a call to awareness, a reminder of the vulnerability we all share. Destiny and Melissa join us in this space of reflection, a sanctuary of remembrance for a life that continues to touch ours even in absence.

Previously covered by Vanished Pod: https://www.thevanishedpodcast.com/episodes/2020/3/9/episode-215-rhonda-day

and by Cason Hudson on YouTube: Where is Rhonda Day? Missing in Louisville, Ky.

Shop for Murder Police Podcast swag by clicking HERE today! 10% of ALL swag and merch proceeds are donated to the DNA Doe Project.

See what you have been missing on YouTube!