On the 191st episode of Big Orange Couch: The 90s Nickelodeon Podcast, we debate "The Tale of the Guardian's Curse" (Andrew), versus "The Tale of the Silent Servant" (Max), while Joey judges. Topics include: story, characters, scariness, monster, and the Midnight Society segments. Also, Taking it to the Max, a listener letter, ratings and name the episode. Plus, Brett Wilson's reviews, Max's movie theater habits, Presidential Cabinet winners, and so much more!