On the spooky 127th episode of Big Orange Couch: The 90s Nickelodeon Podcast, Andrew, Joey, and Chris debate The Tale of the Unfinished Painting vs. The Tale of the Mystical Mirror. Joey defends Unfinished Painting, Chris argues for the Mystical Mirror, while Andrew judges. Topics include: story, main characters, scariness, execution and the Midnight Society segments. Plus, pants v. shorts, not being able to tell if a character is someones brother or boyfriend and so much more!