Is Annabelle the most haunted doll in the world—or the most hyped? In this episode of the GITN Podcast, Phil and Travis dive headfirst into the bizarre and infamous legend of Annabelle: a Raggedy Ann doll that supposedly moves on its own, writes creepy notes, and even choked a grown man in his sleep.

We separate fact from fiction, exploring the real-life origins of the Annabelle case, the role of Ed and Lorraine Warren, and whether this creepy icon of the Conjuring universe deserves its terrifying reputation.

Was it a genuine case of possession? A misunderstood haunting? Or just a cleverly packaged paranormal PR stunt?

From sleep paralysis stories to car-crashing curses, this episode unpacks all the messy, conflicting details—and doesn’t shy away from calling out the absurd parts, too.