Third Rail Judaism

Send us Fan Mail

Chosenness in Judaism: Superiority, Responsibility, and Divine Love (with Rabbi Elie Kaunfer)

Host Blake Cohen interviews Rabbi Elie Kaunfer of the Hadar Institute about the Jewish concept of chosenness and why it is often misconstrued as superiority. Kaunfer distinguishes rabbinic views—chosenness as being selected to enact and model Torah morality—from the Torah’s depiction of God choosing Israel and Abraham without stated merit, framed as an irrational love in Deuteronomy (“I chose you because I love you”). They discuss midrashim about other nations rejecting the Torah, a view that Israel needed Torah more, and questions about leaving the covenant, forgiveness after the Golden Calf, and why suffering and punishment accompany being “singled out,” including a Talmudic account where Rav Safra is silent. Kaunfer connects “kingdom of priests,” holiness as separateness, and “light unto the nations,” highlighting Torah laws like Shabbat and commerce ethics, and notes the Torah blessing’s phrasing ties chosenness to receiving Torah.

00:00 Welcome and Setup
01:56 Why Chosenness Sounds Superior
04:15 Rabbinic View Mission Model
08:10 Why Only Jews Got Torah
14:59 Can You Leave the Covenant
20:18 Desert Doubt and Amalek
25:52 Torah View Love and Election
34:28 Chosen Yet God of All
38:04 God Loves Other Nations
40:41 Chosen and Accountable
42:47 Suffering and Silence
48:11 Kingdom of Priests
55:44 Priests as Intermediaries
01:01:24 Teaching the Nations
01:05:28 Torah Wisdom in Practice
01:11:49 Ethics in Commerce
01:14:27 Chosenness Through Torah
01:16:15 Closing and Where to Learn

Support the show

https://www.patreon.com/c/ThirdRailJudaism

Send us Fan Mail

Is Antisemitism Divine? The Shape-Shifting Hatred of Jews and Judaism’s Metaphysical Claim

Host Blake Cohen introduces Third Rail Judaism and examines why Jews are hated, noting the term “antisemitism” was coined in 1879 and that Jew-hatred uniquely mutates into contradictory accusations across civilizations, including places with few or no Jews, and persists even after assimilation, as in Spain’s post-1391 blood purity laws. He links modern anti-Zionism to older tropes and corrects exaggerated beliefs about Jewish numbers and power. Cohen interviews writer Tzvi Kilov, who distinguishes antisemitism from broader “anti-Judaism,” argues Western civilization has a special antagonistic relationship with Jews, and suggests sociological theories explain only local incidents. Tzvi frames Jewish identity as covenantal, irreducible, and not choice-based, rooted in Sinai, law-centered doctrine, and a distinctive metaphysics, proposing antisemitism is a built-in feature of Jewish existence that ends only with messianic resolution; practical “fighting” is limited, and Jewish unity and practice are emphasized, with the Holocaust treated as an inexplicable aberration and post–Oct. 7 antisemitism described as paradoxically clarifying Jewish identity.

00:00 Why Jews Are Hated
00:26 Defining Antisemitism
01:09 Contradictions and Mutations
02:11 Limits of Social Theories
05:01 Assimilation and Spain
06:10 Anti Zionism Today
07:04 Power and Numbers Myths
08:24 Torah Prophecy Frame
09:11 Guest Introduction
10:50 Term Debate and Anti Judaism
15:29 Torah Origins Purim
18:50 Particularity and Idolatry
25:14 Europe Revolutions Keep Hate
29:16 Divine Theory Question
43:06 What Is a Jew
45:02 Sinai Epistemology
47:05 Law Over Doctrine
49:40 Sinai Metaphysics
51:27 Antisemitism Root Claim
53:42 Law Versus Universalism
01:01:11 Hanukkah Greek Clash
01:04:52 Ritual Details Offend
01:06:39 Irreducible Jewishness
01:10:09 Mission And Repair
01:14:46 Chosenness Compared
01:18:44 Family Identity Paradox
01:22:20 Golda Meir Quote
01:23:17 Covenant Beyond Belief
01:25:11 Two Lamps Midrash
01:27:28 Jewishness Over God Concept
01:29:55 Divine Antisemitism Questions
01:31:10 Metaphysical Tension and Messiah
01:35:59 Holocaust as Aberration
01:39:16 Post Apocalyptic Judaism
01:43:00 Fighting Antisemitism Doubts
01:48:11 ADL Debate and Holocaust Causality
01:57:56 How Worried Should We Be
02:00:28 Antisemitism as North Star
02:05:09 Closing Thanks

Support the show

https://www.patreon.com/c/ThirdRailJudaism

Send us Fan Mail

The Fine-Tuning Debate: Intelligent Design vs. Multiverse Theory

In this episode of Third Rail Judaism, host Blake Cohen delves into the intricacies of fine-tuning in the universe with Elie Feder and Aaron Zimmer from the Physics to God Podcast. The discussion covers why fine-tuning points to an intelligent cause or God, as well as the multiverse theory, which scientists consider an alternative explanation. The conversation touches on concepts like the cosmological constant, observer bias, and the measure problem, aiming to reconcile the implications of fine-tuning with both scientific and philosophical perspectives. This episode seeks to explore whether our finely-tuned universe indicates an intelligent designer or can be explained by an infinite array of universes, each with unique physical laws.

00:00 Introduction and Episode Overview
00:45 The Concept of Fine Tuning
00:56 The Mystery of Existence
01:44 Scientific Perspectives on Nothingness
04:52 Defining Fine Tuning
08:33 The Constants and Their Significance
11:17 The Role of Fine Tuning in Physics
21:37 The Multiverse Theory
22:06 Challenges and Counterarguments
29:58 Scientific Theories and Predictions
36:52 Observer Bias and Infinite Universes
37:29 The Measure Problem in the Multiverse Theory
39:17 Challenges and Criticisms of the Measure Problem
39:56 The Role of God in Scientific Theories
41:43 Philosophical Implications and the Nature of Science
44:01 Intelligent Design vs. Multiverse Theory
58:12 The Concept of Fine Tuning and Intelligent Cause
01:05:24 Preview of Next Season: Addressing Infinite Regress
01:10:49 Closing Remarks and Future Projects

Support the show

https://www.patreon.com/c/ThirdRailJudaism

Send us Fan Mail

https://www.patreon.com/cw/ThirdRailJudaism

physicstogod.com

Support the show

https://www.patreon.com/c/ThirdRailJudaism

Send us Fan Mail

[email protected]

https://www.youtube.com/@jsketch613

https://x.com/EliLebowicz

https://www.instagram.com/elicomedyagram/

https://www.elicomedy.com/

Support the show

https://www.patreon.com/c/ThirdRailJudaism

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

https://www.patreon.com/c/ThirdRailJudaism

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode we examine the relationship between Jacob and Esau and the incident in which Rebecca and Jacob conspire to trick Isaac into giving Esau's blessing to Isaac.

Support the show

https://www.patreon.com/c/ThirdRailJudaism

Send us Fan Mail

[email protected]

Support the show

https://www.patreon.com/c/ThirdRailJudaism

Send us Fan Mail

Exploring Homosexuality in Jewish Tradition: Historical Context and Contemporary Debates

In this episode of Third Rail Judaism, the discussion delves into the complex topic of homosexuality in Jewish tradition. The conversation begins with an examination of the prohibition against male-to-male sexual relations as stated in the Torah and its context. The hosts explore the differing attitudes towards lesbian relationships and the interpretations within the Talmud and other rabbinic texts. Attention is given to the historical and present-day perspectives on same-sex relationships within Jewish communities, highlighting the influence of Christian moral values on Jewish attitudes. The dialogue also touches upon the prevalence of reparative therapy, its controversial nature, and its impact on the mental health of individuals who have undergone such treatments. Finally, the conversation examines the broader topic of inclusivity within Jewish law and the need for a distinctly Jewish approach to understanding and addressing LGBTQ+ issues. The episode underscores the importance of halachic discourse and the potential for new interpretations that align with authentic Jewish values.

00:00 Introduction and Defining Terms
00:35 Torah Prohibitions on Homosexuality
02:02 Lesbian Relationships in Jewish Texts
03:37 Historical Context and Interpretations
04:56 Halakha and Moral Implications
06:12 Rabbinic Views and Legal Perspectives
12:17 Practical and Emotional Responses
22:40 Reparative Therapy and Its Controversies
33:54 Respecting Women in Relationships
34:32 Challenges in Mixed-Orientation Marriages
35:43 Historical Perspectives on Forced Marriages
36:13 Halachic Discussions on Homosexuality
37:14 Kabbalistic Views on Sexuality
41:10 Comparing Attitudes Towards Different Sins
42:54 Christian Influence on Jewish Sexual Morality
54:54 Sephardic vs. Ashkenazi Approaches
59:44 Personal Reflections and Halachic Studies
01:04:13 The Need for Authentic Jewish Perspectives

Support the show

https://www.patreon.com/c/ThirdRailJudaism

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

https://www.patreon.com/c/ThirdRailJudaism