Originally released on Patreon in August of 2023.

How do I even begin to describe this episode? Today, we're exploring the age old question: What happens when your college roommate's dad gets out of prison, needs a place to stay, moves in to your dorm room, and starts a cult in your living room? 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

He was charming, successful, attentive... and seemed almost too good to be true. And for a lot of women across the country, that’s exactly what he was.

What started as an online romance quickly turned into whirlwind relationships filled with luxury hotels, expensive dinners, big promises, and a man who always seemed to swoop in at just the right moment. But behind the tailored suits, military uniforms, and impressive résumés was something far darker.

As cracks began to form, women started asking the same question: Who is this man, really? What they uncovered was a shocking pattern of deception, stolen identities, and financial devastation—often carried out when his victims were at their most vulnerable.

In this episode, we follow the trail of lies, the red flags that were easy to miss in real time, and the women who eventually connected the dots. It’s a story about trust, manipulation, and how one “perfect man” managed to vanish again and again—until he couldn’t anymore.

Sources:

The Perfect Man Who Wasn't

Minn. man sentenced in Texas for aggravated identity fraud | AP News

Derek Alldred’s St. Paul hotel swindle reveals long history of deception – Twin Cities

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

When a mangled car is found slammed into an industrial building in a Cleveland suburb, it leaves two young men dead and their 17-year-old friend, Mackenzie Shirilla, as the only survivor. As investigators dig in, they uncover chilling speed data, strange social media posts, a history of threats, and a hospital interview where Mackenzie literally tries to speak in code, all of which leave investigators wondering - was this a one-car-accident? Or had Mackenzie done this on purpose...

Sources:

Cite as State v. Shirilla, 2024-Ohio-4674.

Obituary, Visitation & Funeral Information | Davion Flanagan

Killer Cases Season 4 Episode 12: Murder on Wheels

Sponsors:

Hello Fresh! Go to HelloFresh.com/creepers10fm now to Get 10 Free Meals + a Free breakfast for Life!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

This week, we’re headed to Dublin, where a silent teenage girl appears out of nowhere on the steps of the GPO. She was shivering, terrified, and seemingly too traumatized to even say her own name. As police scramble to figure out who she is, they uncover drawings that hint at something horrific… and a trail that stretches far beyond Ireland.

What starts as a heartbreaking mystery about a possible trafficking victim turns into the twisted, globe-trotting story of Samantha Azzopardi: a woman who slips in and out of identities like costumes, leaving devastated families, terrified teenagers, and baffled authorities in her wake. How does someone build an entire life out of lies, and what does she really get out of it? We’re digging into the many lives of “Con Girl” and the very real damage left behind.

Sources:

Samantha Azzopardi: Australia's notorious con artist sentenced for child theft

The Many Faces of Samantha Azzopardi | by Nikki Young | Medium

How global fraudster Samantha Azzopardi duped Melbourne families

Samantha Azzopardi - Wikipedia

Compelling story of the GPO girl – a master of manipulation and mind games

Mystery Australian woman flying home after leaving Irish hospital

Podcast: Casefile 

The many, many lives and bizarre crimes of ‘Con Girl’ Samantha Azzopardi

How global fraudster Samantha Azzopardi duped Melbourne families

A global conwoman’s wild lies and the victims she’s left behind

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

When 40-year-old Rosalio Gutierrez Jr. didn’t send his usual good-morning text, his girlfriend, Sadie, felt that little prickle of worry that’s impossible to ignore. By the time she reached his Kenosha apartment the next day, that worry had turned into something much darker. The patio door was open. Something red was splattered near the entrance. And inside… well, nothing could have prepared her for what she saw through the blinds.

Rosalio was nowhere to be found, although the living room told a story no one ever wants to walk into.

As detectives begin unraveling what happened inside that apartment, they are quickly pulled into a messy triangle involving a jealous ex, months of stalking behavior, hidden cell phones, late-night spying, and a van that suddenly smells suspiciously like bleach. When police discover a tiny speck of blood that changes everything, the investigation explodes in a whole new direction.

But for all the evidence, one thing is still missing: Rosalio.

Sponsors:

Acorns
Head to acorns.com/CREEPERS and sign up now and Acorns will boost your new account with a $5 bonus investment.

Happy Mammoth
Head to happymammoth.com to try Prebiotic Collagen Protein and Hormone Harmony risk-free AND get 15% off your entire first order with code CREEPERS at checkout.

Quince
Find your fall staples at Quince. Go to Quince.com/creepers for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada, too.

Sources:

Sadie Beacham 911 Call

FreeZachariahAnderson

Rosalio Gutierrez Jr. - Kenosha.com

Zachariah Anderson: Timeline of murder case as father faces trial for killing Rosalio Gutierrez | The Independent

Mistrial transcript 1

Mistrial transcript 2

Transcript Jury Trial Day 2 02.28.2023.pdf

Transcript Jury Trial Day 03.02.2023.pdf

Obsessed Ex-Boyfriend Murder Trial: Prosecution Closing Argument | Court TV Video

A ‘jealous’ ex-boyfriend, bloody home and missing body: What we know about the Zachariah Anderson murder case

Zachariah Anderson guilty, Rosalio Gutierrez homicide | FOX6 Milwaukee

Killer Cases - S4 E10 - The Boyfriend

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Investigators begin to unravel Nathan’s story: his strange calm, his inconsistencies, and a drift path that doesn’t add up. Civil battles follow: an insurance fight over Chicken Pox, and a slayer-statute case that could strip him of his inheritance. Years later, a federal indictment connects his grandfather’s shooting to his mother’s disappearance at sea. With no body, no murder weapon, and a family at war, what, if anything, can be proven beyond a reasonable doubt?

Sources:

Why Nathan Carman, suspected in his mother's murder, remains 'both a victim and a villain' - ABC News

The Chilling Case of Nathan Carman's Deadly Fishing Trip

Book: Blood in the Water by Casey Sherman

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

This episode as well as Part 2 are available ad free at all levels on the Patreon for the first week of release!

A cargo ship spots a lone life raft 115 nautical miles south of Martha’s Vineyard. Inside is 22-year-old Nathan Carman. He's alert, steady on his feet, and claiming he’s survived seven days at sea after his fishing boat, Chicken Pox, sank. His mother, Linda, was on the boat with him and is now missing. As investigators press for answers, red flags pile up: no mayday call, an oddly pristine survivor, and a family history that reads like Dynasty meets Shakespeare, complete with a murdered patriarch, a sprawling fortune, and bitter rivalries. Is Nathan just misunderstood… or the common thread in two catastrophes?

Sources:

Why Nathan Carman, suspected in his mother's murder, remains 'both a victim and a villain' - ABC News

The Chilling Case of Nathan Carman's Deadly Fishing Trip

Book: Blood in the Water by Casey Sherman

Sponsors:

Acorns Early Get your first month on us when you head to acornsearly.com/CREEPERS or download the Acorns Early app.

Blissy Because you’re a listener, Blissy is offering 60-nights risk-free PLUS an additional 30% off when you shop at Blissy.com/CREEPERSPOD. TYour skin and hair will thank you!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Destiny is back to guest host this episode and she brings with her the murder of Georgia teacher and beauty queen, Tara Grinstead. Her disappearance would become one of the most baffling mysteries in Georgia history — and the truth, when it finally surfaced, was darker than anyone imagined.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

When police arrived at the Gonzales family home in Sydney, Australia, they were met with a gruesome scene: three family members brutally murdered, and their only surviving relative, 20-year-old Sef Gonzales, sobbing hysterically in the driveway. At least, that’s what it looked like.

It didn’t take long for detectives to realize something was off. The supposed break-in appeared staged, Sef’s story didn’t line up, and those dramatic tears? Completely dry. What followed was one of the most shocking and twisted murder investigations in Australian history, a story of lies, greed, and a son so desperate for approval and money that he would destroy everything in his path.

This week, we’re diving into the horrifying case of Sef Gonzales and the murders of his family, a chilling reminder that sometimes the monster isn’t lurking outside your home… he’s living inside it.

Sources:

Inside the Sef Gonzales Murder Trial | Crime Investigation Australia Revisited

When a family’s murder is more than it seems

Sef Gonzales - Wikipedia

Sef Gonzales | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers

Sins of the son

Sponsors:

Aqua tru - go to AquaTru.com right now and get 20% off your purifier with promo code CREEPERS.

Better Help Get started today and get 10% off your first month at BetterHelp.com/CREEPERS.

Blissy is offering 60 nights risk-free plus an additional 30% off at Blissy.com/CREEPERSPOD.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Bardstown, Kentucky was once called the most beautiful small town in America. Bourbon country. And then the murders began. 5 murders in four years in the same small town, and there were no answers to any of them... until recently.

Sponsors:

AquaTru Head to ⁠⁠AquaTru.com⁠⁠ now and get 20% off your purifier using promocode CREEPERS. AquaTru even comes with a 30-day best-tasting water guarantee or your money back.

Quince Go to ⁠⁠quince.com/creepers⁠⁠ for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns!

Happy Mammoth Right now, you can try Prebiotic Collagen Protein and Hormone Harmony risk-free AND get 15% off your entire first order with code CREEPERS at checkout.

Sources:

Youtube Channel: True Crime with Amanda Warner

Podcast: Bardstown

Documentary: The Disappearance of Crystal Rogers on Oxygen

⁠DAY-BY-DAY BREAKDOWN | The trial of Brooks Houck and Joseph Lawson⁠

⁠Trial Blog | Defense rests in Crystal Rogers trial after attempts to discredit state witnesses⁠

⁠LIVE BLOG: Seven testimonies given to attempt to discredit Houck’s timeline⁠

⁠Commonwealth rests its case in trial of Brooks Houck, Joseph Lawson⁠

⁠Crystal Rogers updates | Cadaver dog was 'very interested' in Houck grandmother's car, witness says: BLOG⁠

⁠LIVE BLOG: Cybersecurity expert testifies about Lawson phone records the night Crystal Rogers disappeared⁠

⁠Steve Lawson stands trial in Warren County for Crystal Rogers case⁠

⁠Who is Steve Lawson? | First man to face trial in Crystal Rogers case | whas11.com⁠

⁠'Bombshell' testimony, deleted calls: Takeaways from Day 2 of Steve Lawson's trial in Crystal Rogers case⁠

⁠Steve Lawson had minor involvement in Crystal Rogers case, but didn't help in murder, attorney says | In-depth | wdrb.com⁠

⁠Steve Lawson first to stand trial in Crystal Rogers case | updates⁠

⁠Steve Lawson trial in Crystal Rogers case continues into Day 2: BLOG | ⁠⁠whas11.com⁠

⁠In Memory of Jason Ellis⁠

⁠Brooks Houck police interview - 2015 | Crystal Rogers case⁠

⁠Brooks Houck on Nancy Grace⁠

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices