Mary Day was just 13 years old when she vanished from her family’s home in Seaside, California, in 1981. But what should have been an urgent missing persons case… never was. No police report. No search. No desperate pleas from a grieving family. Instead, it was as if Mary had been erased.

Two decades later, her younger sister Sherrie, haunted by the silence, finally reported Mary missing—kicking off an investigation that led to dark family secrets, chilling discoveries, and a case that seemed to point in only one direction: murder. Detectives were certain they were looking for Mary’s body. And when cadaver dogs alerted to a backyard where the family once lived, it seemed like confirmation of their worst fears.

But then, in a twist that no one saw coming, Mary reappeared. Alive.

Or was she?

In this episode, we unravel the baffling case of Mary Day—where nothing is as it seems, and even DNA evidence leaves more questions than answers. Was Mary really a runaway, lost to the streets for decades? Or did something far more sinister happen in that house in 1981?

🔗 Follow & Subscribe to never miss an episode!

📌 Support the show and get bonus content! www.patreon.com/truecrimecreepers

📷 Follow us on social media for case photos and updates @creeperspod

Sponsors:

HelloFresh

Get up to 10 FREE meals and a free high protein item for life at HelloFresh.com/creepers10FM

Acorns

Head to acorns.com/creepers or download the Acorns app to get started

Quince

Go to Quince.com/creepers for 365-day returns, plus free shipping on your order!

Mint Mobile

Shop plans at MINTMOBILE.COM/CREEPERS

Sources:

Mary Day's mother to police: "Life is full of regrets"

Detectives thought teen Mary Day was murdered. So who was the woman claiming to be her decades later?

The mysterious disappearance of Mary Day

Episode 48 House 

The Curious Case of Mary Day

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

When Nadia Ford’s mother goes missing in Russia, she embarks on a relentless search for answers - one that leads her to a chilling truth and an international fugitive. Viktoria Nasyrova wasn’t just a con artist. She was a master manipulator with a trail of victims spanning two continents. We've got a murder mystery in Russia, a poisoning scheme involving cheesecake in New York, and a daughter that will stop at nothing to find the truth. Buckle up for a story of deception, obsession, and one woman’s incredible fight for justice.

Sponsors:

HelloFresh

Get up to 10 FREE meals and a free high protein item for life at HelloFresh.com/creepers10FM

Acorns

Head to acorns.com/creepers or download the Acorns app to get started

Quince

Go to Quince.com/creepers for 365-day returns, plus free shipping on your order!

Mint Mobile

Shop plans at MINTMOBILE.COM/CREEPERS

Sources:

A woman is poisoned with a piece of cheesecake. Her lookalike is convicted of attempted murder.

The Case of the Poison Cheesecake - CBS News

Retracing a daughter's search for justice in Russia - CBS News

Red Notice for Murder: The hunt for Russian fugitive Viktoria Nasyrova - CBS News

BROOKLYN WOMAN SENTENCED TO 21 YEARS IN PRISON FOR ATTEMPTED MURDER IN CHEESECAKE POISONING OF LOOK-ALIKE - OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY QUEENS COUNTY

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Dr. Mark Sawusch seemed to have it all—he was a brilliant eye surgeon, a multimillionaire, and had his Malibu dream home. But beneath the surface, his life was unraveling. Struggling with severe mental health issues, Mark’s world took a dark turn when he fell under the influence of two strangers who promised to "help" him but instead spun his life into a bizarre tale.

Sponsors:

HelloFresh

Get up to 10 FREE meals and a free high protein item for life at HelloFresh.com/creepers10FM

Acorns

Head to acorns.com/creepers or download the Acorns app to get started

Quince

Go to Quince.com/creepers for 365-day returns, plus free shipping on your order!

Mint Mobile

Shop plans at MINTMOBILE.COM/CREEPERS

Sources:

He stole millions from a mentally ill Malibu doctor. Now he'll spend nearly 16 years in prison

The actor, the hairstylist and the eye surgeon: Drugs and death in a Malibu beach house

The Tragedy of Dr. Mark Sawusch | Circling The News

How Anthony Flores and Anna Moore Scammed Dr. Mark Sawusch

20228 Pacific Coast Hwy, Malibu, CA 90265 | MLS #24-411695 | Zillow?

Wrong man paying child support to Amber Frey

Pair posed as Malibu doctor's caregivers, dosed him with psychedelics and stole millions, feds say

An actor, her boyfriend and a multimillion-dollar fraud that ended in prison and death

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Welcome to a very special episode of True Crime Creepers! We are joined by Andrea Dunlop, host of the podcast Nobody Should Believe Me, and Investigative Detective, Mike Weber, to discuss Munchausen by Proxy. Their book, The Mother Next Door, goes on sale 2/4/25.

Sponsors:

Quince Go to quince.com/creepers for free shipping and 365-day returns!

Alloy Health Go to Myalloy.com to start your consult with a menopause trained expert today! Use Promo Code CREEPERS to get $20 off your first order!!

Acorns Head to acorns.com/creepers or download the Acorns app to start saving and investing for your future today!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Welcome, true-crime lovers, to New Year, New Binge 2025 Edition! What you’ll find included is your guide to an exciting lineup of podcasts that will make 2025 your best year for listening yet. New Years is a time for resolutions, and mine is simple: to share with you the most captivating, chilling, and downright binge-worthy true-crime podcasts. Whether you’re looking to uncover unsolved mysteries or dive into deep investigative storytelling, I’ve got you covered.

Be sure to follow all of the podcasts you enjoyed so you never miss a new episode. Podcasts are listed below in the order in which you will be introduced to them:

Episode 2:

Coffee and Cases Podcast https://linktr.ee/coffeeandcases

Heart Starts Pounding  https://www.heartstartspounding.com/

Mortal Musings Podcast  https://linktr.ee/mortalmusingspodcast

True Crime Creepers https://linktr.ee/TrueCrimeCreepers

Private Dicks Podcast https://linktr.ee/privatedicks

Twisted Travel and True Crime  https://linktr.ee/twistedtraveltruecrimepodcast 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

We are so excited to introduce you to SLAYCATION, a gripping and darkly comedic podcast that delves into the chilling world of murders that take place on vacation. Hosted by a true crime enthusiast, her comedy writer husband, and a seasoned TV producer, we hope that you enjoy this introduction and be sure to follow Slaycation wherever you get your podcasts!

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Welcome, true-crime lovers, to New Year, New Binge 2025 Edition! What you’ll find included is your guide to an exciting lineup of podcasts that will make 2025 your best year for listening yet. New Years is a time for resolutions, and mine is simple: to share with you the most captivating, chilling, and downright binge-worthy true-crime podcasts. Whether you’re looking to uncover unsolved mysteries or dive into deep investigative storytelling, I’ve got you covered.

Be sure to follow all of the podcasts you enjoyed so you never miss a new episode. Podcasts are listed below in the order in which you will be introduced to them:

Episode 1:

Reverie True Crime  https://linktr.ee/paigeelmore 

Fresh Hell Podcast  https://freshhellpodcast.com/

Malice  https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/malice-a-true-crime-podcast/id1471251398

Women & Crime  https://www.womenandcrimepodcast.com

True Crimecast  https://linktr.ee/truecrimecast

The Dark Oak Podcast  thedarkoak.com

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

In January 2011, 27-year-old Ellen Greenberg was found dead in her apartment by her fiancé, Sam. The door was locked from the inside with a swing bar latch, so at first glance, it seemed like a tragic suicide. But when the medical examiner discovered 20 stab wounds—yes, 20—to her chest, head, and the back of her neck, they ruled it a homicide. The police, however, disagreed. Despite the unending and unanswered questions, they stuck to their guns and called it a suicide. But what really happened to Ellen?

Sponsors:

Quince Go to quince.com/creepers for free shipping and 365-day returns!

Alloy Health Go to Myalloy.com to start your consult with a menopause trained expert today! Use Promo Code CREEPERS to get $20 off your first order!!

Pretty Litter Go to prettylitter.com/Creepers to save 20% on your first order and get a free cat toy!!

Acorns Head to acorns.com/creepers or download the Acorns app to start saving and investing for your future today!

Sources:

Suicide Or Murder? Philadelphia Teacher’s Baffling Death Still Leaves Her Family Searching For Answers

A civil suit reveals new details in the case of Ellen Greenberg, whose death by 20 stab wounds was ruled suicide

She had 20 knife wounds and at least 11 bruises. Authorities said she killed herself

Ellen Greenberg case bombshell: Her body was moved, family attorney says - pennlive.com

Initial Medical Examiner Report, January 2011

Suicide or homicide? Parents’ anguished search for answers lasts years after daughter dies of 20 stab wounds - pennlive.com

Medical Examiner Autopsy Report

Medical Examiner Investigative Report, April 2011

Modern analysis of Ellen Greenberg’s death finds her 20 stab wounds were likely from ‘assailant’ - pennlive.com

Ellen Greenberg died by ‘suicide’ with 20 stab wounds. Her parents are out to prove that’s impossible | Lamb McErlane PC

Ellen Greenberg - Crime Timeline

Ellen Greenberg's body was found with 20 knife wounds. Authorities ruled it suicide

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The cat and mouse game between Chief Frizzo and Kelly Cochran continues. The Cochran’s web of lies, deceit, and violence only grew darker as investigators uncover a chilling pact made on the Cochran’s wedding day and discover exactly what happened the day Chris Regan was murdered. But was Chris their only victim? 

Sponsors

Quince Go to quince.com/creepers for free shipping and 365-day returns!

Hello Fresh Get 10 FREE meals at Hellofresh.com/creepers!! Applied across 7 boxes, new subscribers only, varies by plan.

Alloy Health Go to Myalloy.com to start your consult with a menopause trained expert today! Use Promo Code CREEPERS to get $20 off your first order!!

Pretty Litter Go to prettylitter.com/Creepers to save 20% on your first order and get a free cat toy!!

Silver Linings Handbook - subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts!

Acorns Head to acorns.com/creepers or download the Acorns app to start saving and investing for your future today!

Sources:

20/20 S45 E34 “Where Monsters Hide” 

“Where Monsters Hide” by M. William Phelps

Local private investigation firm to be featured on national true crime TV program

Psychopathic traits modulate brain responses to drug cues in incarcerated offenders - PMC

Psychopaths’ brains wired to seek rewards, no matter the consequences | Vanderbilt University

Psychopaths' brains wired to seek rewards, no matter the consequences | ScienceDaily

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Laura Frizzo was Michigan’s Upper Peninsual’s UP’s first female police chief. One evening, just as she was heading home, a distressed woman arrived at the station, convinced her friend, Chris Regan, was missing. Chris was reliable, detail-oriented, and days away from starting his dream job in North Carolina. His sudden disappearance made no sense—unless someone wanted him gone.

As Chief Frizzo began unraveling the mystery, all roads seemed to lead to a married couple, Kelly and Jason Cochran. Their house, their secrets, and even their journals hinted at something darker. But was it enough to prove what really happened to Chris? And what exactly were they hiding?

Want more of us? Join our Patreon!

Sponsors

Quince Go to quince.com/creepers for free shipping and 365-day returns!

Hello Fresh Get 10 FREE meals at Hellofresh.com/creepers!! Applied across 7 boxes, new subscribers only, varies by plan.

Alloy Health Go to Myalloy.com to start your consult with a menopause trained expert today! Use Promo Code CREEPERS to get $20 off your first order!!

Pretty Litter Go to prettylitter.com/Creepers to save 20% on your first order and get a free cat toy!!

Silver Linings Handbook  - subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts!

Acorns Head to acorns.com/creepers or download the Acorns app to start saving and investing for your future today!

Sources:

20/20 S45 E34 “Where Monsters Hide” 

“Where Monsters Hide” by M. William Phelps

Local private investigation firm to be featured on national true crime TV program

Psychopathic traits modulate brain responses to drug cues in incarcerated offenders - PMC

Psychopaths’ brains wired to seek rewards, no matter the consequences | Vanderbilt University

Psychopaths' brains wired to seek rewards, no matter the consequences | ScienceDaily

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices