In a twist on the format, this week, Anthony gets in on the action. Bob McLaughlin, who is the father to popular YouTubers Jillian and Addie, sent in 3 absolutely insane childhood stories, one of which is not true. No one on the episode, including Culter35, know which story is the lie. The stories include paranormal encounters and running into super shady characters. Can you guess which one Bob made up?

Plus, in another Bob-inspired mini-games called "Bob's Jobs," where Bob also submitted various unusual jobs that he may or may not have done.

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Elves are usually associated with Santa and Christmas, but I don't think these stories will fill you with the same holiday glee. This week, the guys discuss 3 elf sighting stories that are less festive and more terrifying. These evil elves aren't bringing Christmas gifts as much as horror and pain. One of the 3 stories is a lie, can you guess which one?

Plus, despite everyone's complaints, Anthony and crew play a round of "Guess Who" where the guests try to guess the correct mythical creature with just a few questions.

Don’t fall for subscription scams. Start cancelling today at Truebill.com/CULTER

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

We all love jolly ole Santa Claus, the chubby red-suited hero who brings us presents ever year on Christmas. Well, the guy we're talking about today ain't him. Krampus is an Eastern European legend that will haunt your holiday nightmares. This week, Culter and crew discuss 3 stories of run-ins with the giant horned demon-like creature, just in time for the holiday season. So which one of the three is NOT Krampus canon? Tune in to find out!

Take advantage of SimpliSafe’s Holiday deals and get 40% off your new home security system by visiting SIMPLISAFE.com/culter 

Get 10% off your first month by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLieYT

Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Also known as "The Weeping Woman" or "The Wailer", La Llorona is a Latin American folklore legend who allegedly drowned her children who can be summoned in the mirror. There are many stories of encounters with her, and you're about to hear 3 of them, plus a bonus story of a personal encounter. told by one of the guests.

Story 1: A girl plays by a river near sunset when she hears a woman crying. She approaches the crying woman wearing all white, so she runs away. She feels a cold hand on her shoulder, but safely makes it home, though the cold hand feeling lingers a little too long.

Story 2: A couple travels to Mexico to visit the man's parents. At night, the man gets cold so he goes to close the window when he hears loud wailing. It grows and louder, including barking and banging from the stray dog outside. Just as it gets as loud as possible, the noise completely stops. The next day, the dog is nowhere in sight, leaving only some stray hairs.

Story 3: A few girls are playing when one of the girls suddenly feels anxious, shortly followed by crying and wailing. The girls look out the window when the noise gets extremely loud. The grandmother bursts in with holy water and prayers, causing more paranormal activity.

Plus, the guests get bombarded with a game of "Guess Who" with a mythical creature.

Download Best Fiends FREE today on the App Store or Google Play!

Don’t fall for subscription scams. Start cancelling today at Truebill.com/CULTER

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

This week, Anthony and gang discuss 3 stories involving a crybaby bridge, which is some type of legend surrounding a bridge where a baby or child has died, often at the hands of their own mother, and has now cursed the bridge to be forever haunted. So which of the following 3 stories is less than true? Listen to find out!

Story 1: A murderous cult threw a baby off of a bridge around the time that it was being constructed. One woman contends that while she and her friend were crossing the bridge, their car cuts out and comes to a complete stop. They hear a woman cackling, getting louder and louder. They finally get the car to start and speed off, spotting a mysterious woman staring at them.

Story 2: A woman has a child out of wedlock, causing her father to kill the baby's father. He also throws the baby off of the bridge. A few friends go to the now-closed bridge and spot a deformed baby crawling around.

Story 3: Around the time of the Civil War, runaway women were cornered on the bridge. Instead of dooming their children to a life of slavery, they instead throw them over the bridge. Many decades later, a group of friends go over to the bridge at night to investigate, but don't find anything for a while. Just as they are leaving, they hear a baby crying and a splash in the water.

Plus, the guys play a new game called "Never Have I Ever, Spooky Edition" where the guys reveal times they've been scared in various situations.

Don’t fall for subscription scams. Start cancelling today at Truebill.com/CULTER

Get 10% off your first month by visiting our sponsor at BetterHelp.com/culter35

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

On a very special episode, Culter reads three creepy stories that were submitted by YOU, including one that supplies the lie of the episode. Listen to the supernatural experiences of other TMOL fans and find out which one among you is a liar!

Story 1 from Abbie Meyer: A group of friends are playing on a playground when they decide to venture to the creepy rusty door leading into the school that has always intrigued them. When they enter, they see a doll on the floor being approached by a mysterious shadowy figure, causing the girls to all run out in freight. Shortly after, the school was suspiciously shut down forever.

Story 2 from Lightweight Games: A family moves into a new house that causes . One day, the boy's iPad dies, so he goes upstairs to get the charger. When they get there, everything goes black until a large figure comes into focus, making him think there's an intruder in the home. When the rest of the family investigates, they don't find anyone.

Story 3 from Will Heiner: 2 brothers go to the movies when they find they're the only ones in the theatre. They both get a creepy feeling like someone is watching them, but there's no one else around. He finally he hears a whisper in his ear, prompting the brothers to leave as fast as possible. Before they leave, one brother goes to the bathroom and hears scratching and the same whisper. When he leaves, his brother says no one else entered the bathroom the entire time.

Plus, the guys play a game of Mad Lib with a yet another fan submission, where the guests replace some key details with their own. Mad Lib story submitted by Harold777.

Don’t fall for subscription scams. Start cancelling today at Truebill.com/CULTER

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Welcome back! This week, Anthony reads the final 3 of 6 Skinwalker Ranch stories to truly challenge the guests to choose the lie out of more stories than ever before.

And to hear part 1, check out las week's episode here!: https://bit.ly/TMOLEp28

Story 4: Tom, the owner of the ranch, check on their cattle and find that a calf was completely mutilated, but no blood anywhere. A few nights later, their dogs are barking at nothing, so Tom goes to investigate and sees two strange glowing orbs inside the tree and a strange creature. He shoots the creature and goes to capture the creature, but there's only an imprint in the snow.

Story 5: Tom hears a bell from the forest and goes to investigate along with someone from a research team. They don't see anything, but continue hearing the mysterious sound so eventually they head back home. The next day, he goes out to the forest and sees a 10-foot wide clearing of trees.

Story 6: Two research scientists see a yellow light in the distance and see that it is growing. They realize it's a tunnel and a giant creature crawls out of the tunnel into our world, and the creature is able to evade their high-tech cameras and equipment. When the scientists to go to the area where the light was, there is no evidence of the being except for a strange musty smell in the air.

Plus, in honor of trigger-happy Tom Gorman, the guys play a game called "What has Tom Gorman NOT shot?"

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Get 10% off your first month by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35

Take advantage of SimpliSafe’s early Black Friday deals and get 50% off your new home security system by visiting SIMPLISAFE.com/culter 

Follow Culter35 on YouTube

Follow Culter35 on IG

 Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening or by using this link: http://bit.ly/TrueMythsOneLiePodcast

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

In the first of 2 parts, Anthony and guests hear 6 stories surrounding the infamous Skinwalker Ranch, a large plot of land in Utah where tons of paranormal events have occurred, even piquing the interest of the U.S. government.

Story 1: A man is tending to his cattle when he spots a wolf, but upon closer inspection, they realize it's about 3 times the size of a normal wolf. The wolf attacks one of his cattle, prompting the man to shoot the wolf multiple times, barely fazing it. It finally runs away and the family gives chase, but the tracks magically disappear.

Story 2: A city boy visits his family's farm to toughen him up. They bring him out on a nighttime walk when they encounter a mysterious light and begin chasing it, thinking it's a car. But the lights move more like a spaceship.

Story 3: A couple are sitting outside and notice their cattle is freaking out. They then spot a strange blue orb approaching them and hovers in front of them, filling them with an immense amount of dread. The man unleashes his dogs towards the orb and it leads the dogs into the woods, but the dogs never return.

Stick around next week to hear the final 3 stories!

Plus, the guys play "Guess the Acronym," paranormal edition.

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on YouTube

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

This week, guest host Tom Heinlein presents 3 insane stories from his days as a delivery driver, two of which really happened to him and one is completely made up. Listen as the guests (including host Culter35) try to separate fact from fiction.

Story 1: Tom spots robbers snatch a register from a Subway sandwich shop and ride off in a bike. Tom is approached by an investigator to hear what happened. Later it's revealed that the robbers were caught by following the loose change spilling from the register.

Story 2: Bernie, a weird regular of Tom's, answers the door with tattered and blood-stained clothes. He urges Tom to see what he's got in his basement. Tom politely declines and leaves. He's since delivered to Bernie several times after, but the basement mystery still remains.

Story 3: A bed-ridden man orders food, so Tom delivers the food into his room. He makes a few requests, leading up to him asking Tom to clean out his bedpan. So does Tom do it? Yes, of course he does.

Plus, the guys play a game of fast food-themed "Would You Rather?" to crown the ultimate fast food chain once and for all!

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Get 10% off your first month by visiting at BetterHelp.com/culter35

Follow Culter35 on YouTube

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Since we're in spooky season, it's only appropriate that this week, Anthony brings you 3 scary legends surrounding October 31st, better known as Halloween. One legend was made up (or just started today?) by Culter 35, can you put aside your fears to figure out which one it is?

Story 1: A husband and wife are vacationing when they spot a Halloween party. The woman wants to go, the man does not and an argument ensues. When they return to the hotel room, the man snaps and brutally murders his wife, all the while maniacally laughing. The police arrive and the man slits his own throat, still laughing until his death. Legend has it, if you stay in this same room, you will still hear his laughter.

Story 2: A group of convicts are being transferred to a local asylum. The bus crashes and the convicts escape. They're able to catch all but two, but find a trail of half-eaten bunnies leading to a nearby bridge and a creepy note. The 2nd escaped convict has yet to be found. Legend has it that if you find yourself on this bridge, you will be skinned and murdered by The Bunny Man.

Story 3: A young boy is playing near some power lines, when he's accidentally electrified and mutilated, yet survives. He begins secluding himself and eventually lives out his life in the tunnels. Legend has it that if you drive through one of these tunnels, you might get a glimpse of the Green Man, and it might be your last day on earth.

Plus, the guests play "Tricked or Treat" where Anthony describes various murder scenes and everyone must guest which killer or creature is the culprit, and the guests play for candy and Krabby Patties.

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Visit SIMPLISAFE.com/culter to get 20% off your entire new system and your first month of monitoring service FREE, when you enroll in Interactive Monitoring!

Follow Culter35 on YouTube

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices