In a classic horror movie twist, Anthony passes hosting duties to Seth, and Anthony tries his hand at figuring out the fake story. This week, Seth gives the summary to 3 seriously off-the-wall mystery/horror films from yesteryear, one of which he completely made up. And for the record, this episode is NOT sponsored by Shudder.

Film 1: Veronica is the only vegetarian in a meat-crazy town. When all the meat runs out, all eyes look to Veronica as the main suspect. The solution? Sacrificing Veronica.

Film 2: A New York detective realizes there is a serial killer in his midst. The strange part is the killer's voice sounds like beloved cartoon character Donald Duck.

Film 3: A high school cheerleader, Tammy, starts dating a football player. Her jealous boyfriend hunts him down and feed him to lions. A mad scientist recovers his brain and places it into a robotic T-Rex.

Plus, the guys guess which unusually famous actor is in 3 bonus actually real scary motion pictures.

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on YouTube.

Follow Culter35 on IG.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Did you read the title?! This week, Anthony and friends discuss 3 distinct stories regarding people finding a mysterious set of stairs in the woods that were probably best left unexplored.

Story 1: A man finds an ever-growing set of stairs in the middle of the woods, but attempts to ignore them, but the trail around him has disappeared. He then spots a strange man who ignores him. He then finds a trove of random shoes scattered around. When he finally finds his way out, he reports his findings to a park ranger. The park ranger informs him that another person previously encountered the stairs, but the only thing he left behind were a set of shoes.

Story 2: A woman goes on a class trip into some woods. She takes a rest and soon realizes she's completely alone. When she tries to find her group, she encounters a set of stairs. When she steps onto them, she's engulfed by complete silence and is met with a demon-like woman. She runs away, but gets pushed by the being and is left with scars.

Story 3: A man and his grandfather go hunting the woods. Somehow the man gets separated from his grandpa and spots a giant set of stairs. He's able to call him, but the call gets lost. He begins going up the stairs and hears his grandfather scream when he reaches the top. When he gets down, he sees his grandfather covered in blood on his feet.

Plus, the guys play a multiple-choice game where they guess which one of the bizarre creatures listed was made up by Culter35.

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on YouTube.

Follow Culter35 on IG.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

This week, the Heinleins and Anthony talk through 3 stories about Ed and Lorraine Warrens, infamous paranormal investigators who were the inspirations behind the Conjuring films and heavily involved. Anthony reads 3 cases of paranormal activity that the Warrens investigated, one of which was made up.

Case 1: A woman tells the Warrens that her children have been being attacked by malevolent forces after one of her children dabbled in witchcraft.

Case 2: A couple tells the Warrens they bought their son a toy truck that mysteriously moves around at night. They also notice that their son has strange markings all over his body.

Case 3: A limousine arrives to take Ed and Lorraine to a military academy. When they arrive, a government official tells them about strange occurrences at his home.

Plus, Anthony takes an online and makes it into a game of Mad Libs and there's a MAJOR twist when the reveal arrives.

Create your own soundtrack, with Raycon. Right now, get 15% off at BUYRAYCON.com/true

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on YouTube

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

If you've never experienced sleep paralysis, consider yourself lucky! This week, Anthony and crew discuss 3 terrifying stories that may make it harder for you to sleep tonight. The only catch is that one of the stories is totally made up. Can you guess which one is the lie?

Story 1: A man is awoken to a scraping noise. He spots a creature scratching at the walls. The creature slowly approaches him, but the man is frozen. The creature grabs the man by his arm and throws him, causing him to finally wake up.

Story 2: A woman with a headache tries to nap. She wakes up to footsteps behind her. She feels a warm body pressing up against her. She tries to turn or wake herself up, but she is frozen. The entity whispers to her and lingers for a bit too long.

Story 3: A man wakes up in the middle of night and realizes he can't move. He spots a large shadowy figure approaching him from the door. The figure assures him as he slowly reaches the man, placing his hand on the man and giving him chills.

Plus, we're bringing back "What's that SCP?", where the guests try to figure out the lore behind the title "A Gift From Dad."

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on YouTube.

Follow Culter35 on IG.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Half dog, half man, the Dogman, it's really that simple. This week, Culter35 and crew discuss the long-standing myth of the cryptid known as the dogman. You'll hear 3 stories, one of which was totally made up. Can you guess which one?

Story 1: A family moves into a new house and the father installs cameras around the property. When the man and his son go to check on the cameras, they find one smashed on the ground. They collect the memory cards of all the cameras to investigate, but while out in the woods, they spot the dogman creature. The creature grabs the son by the neck, so the family attacks the dogman causing him to drop the child.

Story 2: A man is driving and encounters 2 menacing creatures. He hits one of the dogmen and speeds off, crashing his car. He's able to narrowly escape and treat his injuries at the hospital, where he recounts the full story.

Story 3: A family hears strange noises in the middle of the night. When the grandfather investigates, he sees several dogmen surrounding the home. They start attacking, so they begin shooting at the creatures and is able to make them retreat. The family protects the house until the sun comes up.

Plus, the guys play "Go Figure," where Anthony gives the first half of a super generic ghost story and everyone fills in the rest.

Get 10% Off by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35!

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on YouTube

Follow Culter35 on IG 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Have you ever had Deja vu? Well, this is kind of like that, but times ten. Anthony brings you and his guests 3 stories of people predicting the future in their dreams and having it come true.

Story 1: A woman gets into a car accident. Days later, she keeps getting urges to speak to a particular friend whenever she's mentioned. Some time passes, and she gets news that this friend died in a car accident.

Story 2: A woman continually dreams about this mystery man, and senses that this could be her future husband. When she moves to a completely different state, she runs into a man who she identifies from her dream. After dating for a while, she confesses her dreams when he reveals that he too had dreamt of her too.

Story 3: A woman dreams that she is pregnant, though there are complications. When she eventually gets tested, she discovers that she is indeed pregnant and her daughter has a rare condition.

Get 10% off your first month by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35!

Plus, Ryan calls his sister who often has precognitions to guess which story is fake without having heard any of them, and the guys play another round of "Plotline or Conspiracy Theory?"

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on YouTube

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

No, these aren't kids who got into a fight, these are mysterious children who ask for help with vacant pitch-black voids where there eyes should be. If you help them out, you are forever cursed with bad luck.

Story 1: A man goes for a swim in a nearby lake. He hears a child asking for help and spots a little girl. When he gets to her, she asks to be helped across the lake, but he sees her eyes are pitch-black. He refuses, then she asks to go home with him. He refuses and swims away, but the child follows after him in the lake.

Story 2: A couple walk back to their car from a midnight showing. A kid tugs on the man's shirt and asks for spare change. When the man refuses, he asks again repeatedly. The couple gets in the car and locks the door and sees the child has black eyes. The man speeds off and sees the child chasing after the car and screaming.

Story 3: A man walks back home from his night shift. On his walk, he sees 2 children holding hands and crossing the street over and over. They finally reach the man and ask to use his phone at home. When he gets a creepy feeling, he decides to walk away, and the children set off to find another victim.

Plus, the guys play "Guess Who?" a game based off the popular board game, but a mythical creature edition. And Anthony talks about his run-in with the Slenderman lore.

Get 20% off + free shipping with the code TRUEMYTHS at manscaped.com!

Get 10% off your first month by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35!

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on YouTube

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Bigfoot, Yeti, Sasquatch, whatever you call it, there's been lore about the elusive beast for decades. This week, Culter35 and crew dissect 3 stories of Bigfoot encounters, one of which is totally made up.

Story 1: A man wants to bring his girlfriend along with him and his friends to his birthday camping trip. He finally convinces her to go, even though she's never been camping before. After a fun night, everyone is asleep except for the girlfriend. She starts hearing some strange sounds from outside the tent. She wakes everyone else up and they suddenly hear a loud bang followed by a strange smell. All of a sudden, the tent is attacked and the creature runs off.

Story 2: Two large families are hanging out at a large property. A couple of the kids break off and run around with the family dog. All of a sudden, they start to smell a foul odor, so bad it causes one of them to vomit. They go to investigate and find a large creature running off and climbing an impossibly steep hill. They freak out and tell their parents, but no one believes them.

Story 3: A man visits a ranch where the owner claims that a lot of strange things goes on there. While out hunting, he follows a trail of broken trees, huge hand and footprints, but it goes cold. At night, they go searching again along the same trial, but this time, they hear a loud noise surrounding them. They run to their car and turn on the headlights, there are 2 Bigfoot approaching them.

Plus, the guys play a Bigfoot-themed game of "Mad Libs."

Get 10% Off by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35!

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on YouTube

Follow Culter35 on IG 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Are you a fan of the circus or does your fear of clowns keep you away? This week, Anthony brings 3 stories involving clowns that probably won't make you laugh.

Story 1: A freshman in college is looking to make friends, so she takes a dance class. After leaving class one night, she runs into a large man wearing a killer clown mask. She runs away into a random building and waits for campus police. When they arrive, they find no trace of man.

Story 2: A man is sick at home when he hears some strange noise. When he goes to the kitchen, he finds a clown cooking food and she begins screaming at him. When the police arrive,

Story 3: A woman starts a new job, where she meets some bike enthusiasts. She looks online to find an affordable bike and finds one nearby. When she goes to pick up the bike, a clown runs up to her window, and she speeds out of there.

Plus, everyone plays a few rousing rounds of "Would You Rather?"

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on YouTube

Follow Culter35 on IG 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Is it the Happiest or the Creepiest Place on Earth? This week, Anthony brings you 3 stories of spooky encounters that have happened at Disney Theme Parks, though the guys had trouble deciding which park specifically, one of which that Anthony dreamed up. And if Ryan and Seth get this right, they will get a free trip to Disney! Disneyland or Disneyworld? We're still not sure.

Story 1: A new employee is the last in his shift when he runs into a lost little girl. After looking around for her parents, the girl is nowhere to be found. And this is just one of many creepy encounters for this poor "Cast Member."

Story 2: A custodian is cleaning up the bathrooms late at night when he hears a mysterious noise. When he goes to investigate, he sees that some items have been shifted around. After some shock, he hears a voice whisper to him, causing to end his shift early.

Story 3: A couple approaches Splash Mountain near the park closing and they get the ride all to themselves. Midway through, the ride gets stuck. When the couple finally get to the end of the ride, they seem disturbed. When they look at the ride photo, there is a unknown third passenger sitting next to them.

Plus, the guys play "True or False: Disney Edition," where Culter35 lists some unsettling rumors regarding Disney like real bones being used in the Pirates ride, the Main Street ghost, and more!

Get 10% Off by visiting BetterHelp.com/culter35!

Want to submit a truth or a lie? Send in your submission to [email protected]!

Follow Culter35 on YouTube

Follow Culter35 on IG

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices