Truth and Scare

Truth and Scare

By Truth and ScareComedyTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

Truth and Scare episodes

  • 25 - THE END... ?

    Well, here we are... the SEASON FINALE. This episode takes a different structure than we usually use and has no ads or PSAs in it. Just You, Cyndi, and Niko chatting away. Niko and Cyndi collaborate for the finale on the legend of Slender Man and the famous stabbing that it inspired... BIG heads up, we will be taking a two week break! Next week has a bonus episode and the week afterwards there will be no content! After that we jump into season two, which we're all VERY excited about. Some changes are being made, but the core of the show is staying dumb and messy (just like the hosts). See you on the other side! And, as always, stay spooky y'all!


    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our bonus episodes!     


    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare!       


    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram)

    1 hr 15 min
  • Where is Ashley Morin?

    If you have any information that could aid in the search for Ashley, please reach out to the Crime Stoppers by using the information below.

    Saskatchewan Crime Stoppers Email: http://shorturl.at/pHKMX

    Saskatchewan Crime Stoppers Phone Line: 1-800-222-8477

    35 min
  • 24 - Falling Sickness and SHHH They're Listening

    Hello Spooky Children! This is the LAST episode before the season finale!!! And the audio on Niko's Side is... less than ideal. Sorry! But the stories are still good! Niko opens up with the story of Elizabeth Bathory, The Blood Countess (Spoiler Alert: that's not true. The real story is much worse). Cyndi closes out with a look into the suspicious Denver International Airport. We think the 30 foot satanic horse is classy, don't you?

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our bonus episodes!    

    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare!      

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram)

    1 hr 14 min
  • 23 - Making Connections and Quantum Fruit Loops

    QUICK! Name something chartreuse colored! Welcome back to Truth and Scare, jeepers and creepers. Only TWO EPISODES left until we say goodbye to season 1. In this episode, Cyndi covers the... absolutely horrifying Alphabet Murders of Rochester, NY, and even finds a connection to our own episode 21. Seriously haunting stuff in this one. Niko's up next with a deep dive into Mandela effect. What is it? What Causes it? Does Niko use it as an excuse to give Cyndi a trivia quiz? Listen to find out! 

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our bonus episodes!    

    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare!     

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram)

    1 hr 16 min
  • 22 - The Return of Drain Cleaner and Awkward Barking

    If you were gonna commit a murder, how many of your coworkers would you tell? Hello again, spooky subjects, and get ready for what is admittedly a very heavy episode. But also a very interesting one! Niko's up first this week with the Hi-Fi murders, which he tells us are in Oklahoma because he is stupid. Truthfully they're in Utah, so do your best to ignore him. But Cyndi brings it back with the very shocking story of Anneliese Michel, a young girl who went through over 60 separate exorcisms in just 10 months. All jokes aside, have tissues ready for that one. Stay spooky, y'all!

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our bonus episodes!   

    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare!    

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram)

    1 hr 15 min
  • 21 - A Very Scary Cousin and So Many Windows

    AHH! There are only THREE EPISODES LEFT until the end of seasons one folks, so let's make em COUNT! This episode is definitely a wild one, where Cyndi opens with the absolutely horrifying case of the Hillside Stranglers. This is actually going to fold over into episode 23, so make sure you catch that one too! Niko also covers a CLASSIC story; the Winchester Mystery House in San Jose, CA. Turns out, there are a lot of ghosts involved. If you like what you hear, don't forget to rate us on Apple Podcasts! And as always, stay spooky y'all!

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our bonus episodes!  

    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare!   

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram)

    1 hr 26 min
  • 20 - Axe-ing Tough Questions and The Scary Kind of Crying

    If you live by a river, you're screwed apparently. Hey spooky subjects! We're back again, and this episode is a juicy one. Niko's up first with the Viscilla Axe Murders, one of the grizzliest cases in american history. Turns out axes are a pretty popular weapon in Iowa... Cyndi's next to bat with a look into the various legends of Ladies in White around the world, leading up to the big daddy of ghost mommies; La Llorona. This one might be the scariest story Cyndi's ever covered, and it definitely got under Niko's skin. Think you're braver than him? You're probably right!

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our bonus episodes! 

    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare!  

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram)

    56 min
  • 19 - An Ethics Meltdown and Absolutely Zero Answers

    WE'RE BACK!!! Sorry to yell, but we're pretty excited after taking a week off. So let's jump into some spooky stuff! Cyndi opens up this episode with no murder, but instead a detailed look at the Stanford Prison Experiment. Spoiler alert; it's almost as bad as the murders she's done. Niko then takes us on a (strangely educational) journey through the spiritualist movement to look at the history of the Ouija board. Or, at least, he tries really hard. Hope you enjoy this one as much as we did and, as always, stay spooky y'all! Ok byeeeeee!

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our bonus episodes!

    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare!  

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram)

    1 hr 16 min
  • 18 - The Bad Kind of Vampire and Poof! Where'd it go!?

    DON'T. UNDERESTIMATE. A CURSE. Welcome back friends, and get ready because this episode is a ROLLER COASTER. Niko's up first with the story of Peter Kurten, better known as The Vampire of Dusseldorf. An old school serial killer with potentially the worst history we've had yet. Don't worry though, it's at least got a good ending. Cyndi definitely lightens the mood when she follows it up with the story of Kuldhara- an entire city in India that just... vanished. This is a good one, folks, just make sure you've got your lights turned on! And, as always, stay spooky!

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our monthly bonus episodes! 

    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare! 

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram)

    59 min
  • 17 - Killer Spiderman and A Long Bloody Arm

    Don't ever knock on the third stall. Trust us on this one. This week Cyndi tells us about the long and complicated past of Jack Unterweger, who reported on the very crimes he committed. Think Peter Parker but awful. Niko racks the anxiety up even higher with the Japanese legend of Hanako-San, a little ghost girl that hides in bathrooms and will literally drag you to hell. This one is quite a ride, so you'd better get started. Good luck!

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our bonus episodes!

    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare! 

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram) Elevator Music: Bensounds.com

    1 hr 3 min

About Truth and Scare

From the publisher's feed

Everyone's afraid of something. In this podcast, Cyndi Cunningham and Niko MacCaughey share their own fears with the world so they don't have to suffer alone. Now you can be afraid, too!