Truth and Scare

Truth and Scare

By Truth and ScareComedyTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

Truth and Scare episodes

  • Little Nightmares: The Perfect Killer Game

    Hello, Creepy Kids! Welcome to our first bonus episode of many! In this first installment of Little Nightmares, Cyndi and Niko play a fun little game of roulette to find out just what makes the Perfect Serial Killer. The winner is... shocking, to say the least. This new series will be full of topics and games that don't quite fit the main show, so feel free to send suggestions to [email protected] and you'll probably hear it on the show!


    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our monthly bonus episodes! 


    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare! 


    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr)

    43 min
  • 8 - So Many Hills and Demon Therapy

    Welcome to our latest foray into terrible, horrible darkness! Lovely. In this episode, Niko kicks things off with lesser known killer Dorothy Puente AKA "The Giggling Granny". The next time gran offers you a slice of pie, keep your guard up... Then Cyndi educates us with a history lesson on demonic exorcisms and a super light and fun (read: mentally scarring) story of a young boy's possession. This one is a doozy folks, so make sure you have your popcorn and candy!

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our bonus episodes!

    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare!

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram)

    1 hr
  • 7 - A "General" Conspiracy and His Wet Hand

    Long time, no see! Welcome to our scariest episode yet. This time Cyndi starts us off with the story of Timothy King and the never caught Babysitter Killer. Up front warning: this one's hella sad. Niko doesn't lighten the mood though, because he (unfortunately) opens our mind up to The Rake. The frightening creature that's probably in your bedroom by now. Have fun!

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our monthly bonus episodes!

    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare!

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram)

    56 min
  • 6 - The Elephant Butte in The Room and The Worst Vacation

    Are you guys ready for a KILLER episode? Get it? In this week's Truth and Scare, Niko starts us off with one of the nastiest killer... that was never charged for murder? Gross. And then Cyndi takes us on a deep dive into alien abduction, and even talks about her OWN UFO SIGHTING! It's a crazy one, so you'd better get ready...

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our monthly bonus episodes!

    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook @truthandscare!

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram)

    Elevator Music from bensound.com: https://www.bensound.com/index.php?route=product/search&search=elevator%20music

    1 hr 8 min
  • 5 - Your Least Favorite Wheelbarrow and The Worst Penpal

    Hello again, spooky friends! Make sure you're ready, because this is the most intense episode yet! Cyndi starts us off with a look at the crimes of Joel David Rifkin and some thoughtful discussion on the victimization of sex workers: told you it was intense. Then Niko turns our nausea into dry heaves with a field trip to the Watcher House... where there are always prying eyes. Friendly reminder, we're on Apple Podcasts now! So even if you don't use Apple to listen, it's a BIG help to the show if you go give us a rate and/or review. And, as always, thanks for listening!

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our monthly bonus episodes!

    Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Reddit @truthandscare!

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Carmen Lachman (@snowsmokeychan on instagram)

    1 hr 9 min
  • Your Least Favorite Wheelbarrow and The Worst Penpal

    Hello again, spooky friends! Make sure you're ready, because this is the most intense episode yet! Cyndi starts us off with a look at the crimes of Joel David Rifkin and some thoughtful discussion on the victimization of sex workers: told you it was intense. Then Niko turns our nausea into dry heaves with a field trip to the Watcher House... where there are always prying eyes. Friendly reminder, we're on Apple Podcasts now! So even if you don't use Apple to listen, it's a BIG help to the show if you go give us a rate and/or review. And, as always, thanks for listening!

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our monthly bonus episodes!

     Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Reddit @truthandscare!  

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) 

    7 min
  • 4 - The Perfect Name and A Good Luck Corpse

    Welcome back to our spooky abode, and get ready for a wild one! In this week's episode hosts Niko and Cyndi go over the intense story of black widow killer Stacey Castor before taking a road trip to Mexico to talk about La Pascualita; apparently the luckiest corpse for weddings... and a different kind of black widow makes an appearance. As always, thanks for listening!Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our monthly bonus episodes!Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Reddit @truthandscare! Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) Cover Art: Alyssa Farjardo (@shinyxcharm on Instagram)

    49 min
  • 3 - A Literal Giant and A Hotel For Lungers

    Hello again, spooky friends! And welcome to Episode 3 of Truth and Scare; True Crime and Paranormal podcast! In this episode, hosts Cyndi and Niko discuss the most textbook of all textbook serial killers, Ed Kemper, before checking in to the Stanley Hotel- famous inspiration for Stephen King's "The Shining". This one's a wild ride, folks, so make sure you have your popcorn and soda before pressing play! 

    Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our monthly bonus episodes! 

     Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Reddit @truthandscare! 

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) 

    58 min
  • 2 - Courthouse Houdini and Sadly, Not a Dog

    Welcome back, creepy peeps, to Truth and Scare; True Crime and Paranormal podcast! In this episode, Hosts Niko and Cyndi discuss the tragic and insanely wild murder of Stephanie Crowe, before diving into some VERY uncomfortable urban legends. If you take anything away from this episode, it should be to always ask for a lawyer, and never turn the lights on.

     Got any spooky stories? Send all your scary experiences (paranormal OR true crime) to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener Story" for the chance to be featured in our monthly bonus episodes!

     Find us on Instagram, Twitter, and Reddit @truthandscare! 

    Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@shutupsarah on fiverr) 

    58 min
  • 1 - An Unfortunate Paraglider and The Grossest Apple

    Welcome, everyone, to the very first episode of Truth and Scare! In this pilot episode, hosts Cyndi and Niko explore the tragic murder of Samantha Runnion and the incredible things her mother has accomplished since. Then they get down to the spooky-ooky and talk about the bone-chilling urban legend of the Black Eyed Kids- who apparently have some strange eating habits. Join them as they release their fears and find comfort in (very funny) company!

     Have scary stories to share? Send them to us at [email protected] with the subject "Scaring is Caring" or "Listener's Stories" for a chance to featured in our monthly bonus episode!

     Find us @truthandscare on Instagram, Twitter, and Reddit!

     Theme Music: Sarah O'Heeron (@Shutupsarah on fiverr) 


    57 min

About Truth and Scare

From the publisher's feed

Everyone's afraid of something. In this podcast, Cyndi Cunningham and Niko MacCaughey share their own fears with the world so they don't have to suffer alone. Now you can be afraid, too!