we often take resistance as a right—even a duty.
And yet: the moment you claim that right, you awaken something unpredictable. Fighting injustice may restore dignity—but it can also unleash darkness:
terror, betrayal, even ecstasy.
In this series, we speak with those who resisted—and those the world tried to silence. Saints and revolutionaries, mystics and militants. Their words are sharp. Their choices: balanced on a knife’s edge.
You may not agree with them. But if you’ve ever clenched your fists in the face of injustice—then this is “your” conversation, too.
Last week, we interviewed Maximilien Robespierre, the architect of the Terror - a time of great struggle and uncertainty following the French Revolution. Under his rule, thousands were executed for not living up to his standards of virtue. His was a maximalist interpretation of when resistance was allowed to use violence. He would say: until virtue reigns supreme and humanity has been born anew.
Our first guest, Gandhi, took the other end of the spectrum. He said that violence was never okay, as it would unforgivably taint the soul of the one wielding it, which would only lead to injustice continuing to occur.
Our remaining rostrum of guests all fall somewhere on the spectrum created by these two opposites. So today, we’ll be talking to Rosa Luxemburg, a socialist resistance fighter who certainly was no fan of violence, but who didn’t completely rule it out, either.
0:00 Intro
2:51 Life description
4:24 Is violence ever justified in the pursuit of justice?
5:41 Freedom is always the freedom of the one who thinks differently
7:01 Resistance against Authoritarianism
8:01 Spontaneity
8:50 World War I
9:50 How prison shaped Rosa Luxemburg
12:54 The Spartacist Uprising
13:56 Violence may sometimes be necessary, but never virtuous
14:57 Love is central to revolution
16:02 Advice for would-be revolutionaries