A New Year’s Day story in April? Sure, why not? It’s UCA and anything goes when David, Kaela, Allen and Seid get together. In addition to this story of self-reflection, Allen presents a new recurring challenge to the other hosts…

Story submitted by TheRe_Writes. Read along here.

It’s time for David to get some of what he dishes out. Kaela, Seid and Papreeka take a story written for a writing challenge and put it to their own form of scrutiny, while also providing some helpful PSAs along the way.

Story submitted by David King.

Allen has something important to share with our listeners about a change in the show’s format.

An unsettling anecdote about a pirated broadcast, interspersed with Pokemon questions from David, Kaela and Abysmii? Yep, it’s another episode of Undercooked Analysis.

Story submitted by Secoura.

A demonic document awaits David, Kaela an Allen as Cleric pitches them a story about reflecting poorly on one’s life in a truck stop bathroom (or is it a really crappy apartment bathroom?).

Check out the Horror Historians Pilot here.

Story submitted by ClericofMadness Read along here.

David, Kaela, Allen, Abysmii and special guest Naruli are about to spend another hour in the ball pit as they talk about Nicolas Cage fighting animatronics and cinematic attempts to ape the FNaF formula.

This could easily be a very dark story based on the subject matter, and yet David, Kaela, Allen and Papreeka seem to be rolling in a fair bit of levity to keep them going. Will they be able to push through, or will they keep making reference to next week’s Choice Dregs (available only on Patreon!)?

Content Warning: story depicts violence against an infant.

Story submitted by Cainmak.

There’s an awful lot of pudding left over from the challenge, and Allen, David and Kaela are going to have chosen their personal favorite flavors from among them to showcase. As it turns out, a lot of our entrants really enjoy pudding-related prompts.

We finally serve you the winners of our Creepy Cooking Staff Writing Challenge! Allen, David and Kaela have tasted nine dishes based on previously-concocted prompts from the CCS recipe book, but only three can appease the staff!

3rd place - “I Named Him Eddy” by Kylie Keen
2nd place - “Bumble Buddies” by Eli Edgerton-Jones
1st place - “The Road Trip” by Beth Morton

David and Allen are on the case of an unsolved mystery, crafted by Kaela! Of course, with an episode that’s this special, the boys intend to keep it raw… and also invent a skeleton cannon in the process. What do you think happened to Sweet Carrie Jo?

Story submitted by Kaela King.