We Might Be Dead!

In December of 1990, 21-year-old Richard Hitchcock was last seen leaving the Riverfront Lounge on Water Street in Allegan, Michigan. He had been intoxicated, asked to leave, returned, and was escorted out again.

Witnesses place him scaling two fences and jumping into the Kalamazoo River, while others believe he was beaten to death outside the bar.

One thing remains true all these years later- Richie's family will never stop their quest for him to rest in peace.

Tune in to this week's cold case Friday to see what Tara is able to pull through spirit, and to learn what evidence Richie's family discovered as recently as 2025.

Season three is here!!!! In our first episode, Tara and McKenzie break down their summer highlights reel and chat about everything from inspirational spa locations to the classes they took during their trip to Lily Dale (peep- Astrology and Cold Case Investigations), and the importance of physical movement and grounding in 3D, 4D, 5D existence.

They're also asking for YOUR STORIES! If you have a spirit encounter tale to share, OR if you've been a client of Tara's and had a crazy/validating/funny experience, send it to [email protected]. Your story may be featured on We Might Be Dead!!! (Features may be anonymous if you prefer- just say so in your email!).

25-year-old newly-wed husband George Allen Smith IV went missing off of MS Brilliance of the Seas just days after marrying the love of his life. A drunken evening, disturbing bloodstain, and varying accounts of the night are all that remain. But was this murder, or just a catastrophic accident? Listen to this week's Cold Case and see what Tara picks up from George in spirit. Heads-up: listen all the way to the end to hear a candid conversation between McKenzie and Tara comparing another psychic's take on this devastating incident.

Tara and McKenzie drop in for a quick pod update!

It's weird in here today! Tara and McKenzie answer your latest batch of questions, including what the knocking you're hearing is as you're falling asleep, what new-soul, old-soul, new/old souls are, and how to time-warp from 3D to 5D!

Tara knows too much this week- tune in to this episode of Cold Case Friday to hear what we have to say about the mysterious disappearance and subsequent purported sightings of Amy Lynn Bradley who boarded a Caribbean cruise 28 years ago, and never came home again.

Join us with guest ghost hunter Tony (A.C.) Bernardi for part two of Haunted Scranton! Tara and Tony have a paranormal recall of their investigations into the Scranton Cultural Center, Hotel Jermyn, and more landmarks.

Though not technically a cold case, this week's episode covers the strange death of 21-year-old Elisa Lam whose body was found inside a water tank atop the Cecil Hotel in LA. Listen along to hear what we learn about Elisa's mental state just before her death, and what happens when another guest who was murdered at The Cecil drops by in spirit.

Today's Cold Case Friday explores one of the most haunting missing‑person cases in modern true crime: the 2008 disappearance of 19‑year‑old Brandon Swanson in rural Minnesota. After accidentally driving his car into a ditch shortly after midnight, Brandon called his parents for help. What followed was a 47‑minute phone call filled with reassurance, confusion, and shifting landmarks—until Brandon suddenly exclaimed “Oh, shit” and the line went silent. He has never been seen again.

Listen now to hear what Tara feels happened the night he vanished, and the emotional imprints surrounding the case.

Sit down with us as we interview our guest and author of Haunted Scranton, ghost hunter, Tony (A.C.) Bernardi! Meet Zappi, a local ghost from the 30s, and discover what happens when a few paranormal investigators and a medium walk into a room.