Are JD's Hot Topic friends going to still be his friends when they find out what he thought of The Nightmare Before Christmas upon seeing it for the very first time at forty-three years old? Let's all find out together!

What happens when Michelle and JD genuinely find a movie about which neither of them genuinely have much to say but they still manage to record for half an hour anyway? Let's all find out together!

Did the film that caused some of Michelle's earliest cinematic trauma come back to haunt her thirty years later? Let's all find out together!

Michelle and JD had very different experiences with this film the first time they saw it. Did they have similar results this time around? Let's all find out together!

So how did JD feel upon finally seeing, for the first time, this much lauded classic that has helped define so many peoples' love of the season, including Michelle's? Let's all find out together!

How many murders could a murder party party if a murder party could party murders? Let's all find out together!

I can't be pithy for this one, guys. I had a real rough time during this episode that had (almost) nothing to do with this episode, but Michelle kept me together. It really is okay to not be okay. You don't have to hide.

What about Spooky the Tuff Little Ghost? Or Hot Stuff the Little Devil? Or Wendy the Good Little Witch? Or even Nightmare the Galloping Ghost, for that matter? Let's all find out together!

How did Michelle and JD feel about the highest grossing film in America, and soon to easily become the highest grossing unrated film of all time? Let's all find out together!

You're out trick-or-treating but your friends all disappear and when you turn down an alley you see what appears to be a little kid in orange pajamas with a bag on its head. What do you do? Let's all find out together!