This week on Wickedly Judged, we’re taking a brief pause from our regular case coverage for the Thanksgiving holiday.

In this short, heartfelt message, Rebecca shares:

• Why there is no new case episode this week
• How holidays can be especially painful for families living with wrongful convictions
• Her own experience of facing an empty chair at the table while her husband remains wrongfully incarcerated
• A message of solidarity for every family who feels that same ache this season
• A reminder that grief and gratitude can exist together—you can be thankful and still deeply miss the person who should be home

Rebecca also takes a moment to thank the incredible sponsors who help make Wickedly Judged possible:

• Veteran Alliance
• Yarntherapy4me
• Just an Apron
• Liberty First Radio
• JP Verse of Versefire Records – and a special thank you for creating our intro and outro music

Even though we’re not releasing a new case this week, our mission of Reform through Advocacy continues. We’ll be back next week with more stories, more truth-seeking, and more fight for justice.

In the meantime, we invite you to:

• Revisit past episodes you may have missed
• Share Wickedly Judged with someone who cares about justice reform
• Hold space in your heart for the families with empty chairs this holiday

From all of us at Wickedly Judged: Happy Thanksgiving. You’re not alone.

In this special full-length episode, Wickedly Judged unpacks the complete story of Joshua Lee Mosher—a man whose life was shattered by a wrongful conviction fueled by revenge, police tunnel vision, and a justice system obsessed with conviction rates over truth.

Host Rebecca guides listeners through the timeline of Josh’s case, revealing how a toxic relationship with his ex, Jackie, spiraled into a calculated plot for revenge. When Jackie vowed to “make him pay for crossing the wrong woman,” the justice system became her weapon. With Detective Tamminga at the helm—an investigator who secured convictions in every sexual assault case he touched—Josh never stood a chance. Instead of seeking truth, the investigation zeroed in on guilt from the start, ignoring alternative leads and motives.

Listeners will hear the emotional voices of Amanda (Josh’s sister) and Bethany (his partner and advocate), who share the heartbreak, hope, and relentless fight for justice that have defined this journey. Their advocacy uncovers evidence of a social media revenge plot, exposes the dangers of unchecked police power, and highlights the devastating impact of a system where a 100% conviction rate is rewarded with a promotion to Sheriff.

Key Moments

• The revenge plot: Jackie’s vow and the weaponization of the justice system
• Detective Tamminga’s tunnel vision and 100% conviction rate
• The legal rollercoaster: trial, conviction, and years of denied appeals
• Amanda and Bethany’s fight—new evidence and hope for Josh
• Reflections on systemic failure and the urgent need for reform

Sponsors

Special thanks to our sponsors: Veteran Alliance | Yarntherapy4me | Just an Apron | Liberty First Radio And to JP Verse of Versefire Records for our intro/outro music.

Take Action

• Share this episode to raise awareness
• Visit: wickedlyjudged.com for Josh’s full story and ways to help
• Contact your representatives and demand wrongful conviction review
• Support our sponsors and advocacy efforts

Thank you for listening and being part of the movement for justice.

In this follow-up episode, Wickedly Judged continues the powerful exploration of the wrongful conviction of Joshua Lee Mosher. Host Rebecca recaps the crucial details of Josh’s case—a story marked by a toxic home environment, a controversial investigation, and years of denied appeals. Picking up with the second half of a moving interview, listeners hear directly from Amanda (Josh’s sister) and Bethany (his girlfriend and advocate) as they share the emotional toll of Josh’s conviction and their ongoing fight for justice.

This episode is a testament to the resilience of families and the importance of advocacy in the face of injustice. With renewed hope from new evidence and relentless support, Amanda and Bethany’s voices remind us why exposing wrongful convictions matters now more than ever.

Key Moments

• Standardized Introduction: Rebecca reiterates the mission to expose wrongful convictions and thanks all sponsors.
• Recap: A concise summary of Josh’s case timeline and the previous episode’s highlights.
• Interview (Part 2): The conclusion of the heartfelt conversation with Amanda and Bethany, revealing new insights and personal reflections.
• Host Reflections: Rebecca shares takeaways on the human cost of wrongful convictions.
• Expanded Call to Action: Clear, actionable steps for listeners to support Josh and justice reform.

Sponsors

A heartfelt thank you to our sponsors for making this episode possible:

• Veteran Alliance: Supporting those who have served and their families.
• Yarntherapy4me: Crocheting beautiful, handmade bags with heart.
• Just an Apron: Creating sweet treats that bring a little joy to every day.
• Liberty First Radio: A veteran-owned online radio station giving a platform to voices that need to be heard.
• JP Verse of Versefire Records: Providing our powerful intro and outro music.

Resources & Links

• Learn More About Josh’s Case: wickedlyjudged.com
• Support Our Advocacy: Donate or shop merchandise to help us keep fighting for the innocent.
• Contact Your Representatives: Urge them to support wrongful conviction review and justice reform.
• Got Information? Reach out via our website if you have tips or resources that could help Josh or others.

Connect with Us

• Website: wickedlyjudged.com
• Facebook: facebook.com/wickedlyjudged
• Instagram: instagram.com/wickedlyjudged
• Twitter/X: twitter.com/wickedlyjudged

Call to Action

If you were moved by Josh’s story, please share this episode, leave a review, and subscribe to Wickedly Judged. Every listen, share, and donation helps us keep fighting for the innocent and pushing for real justice reform.

Thank you for listening and for being a part of the movement for justice.

Episode Summary

In this powerful episode of Wickedly Judged, Rebecca takes listeners through the harrowing journey of Joshua Lee Mosher—a man convicted of crimes he has always denied, and whose case raises urgent questions about the American justice system. Through a detailed timeline, Rebecca unpacks the events that led to Josh’s conviction, the relentless legal battles that followed, and the new hope sparked by the advocacy of his loved ones.

Listeners will hear from Josh’s sister, Amanda, and his girlfriend, Bethany, whose tireless efforts have uncovered new evidence and kept Josh’s fight for justice alive. Their voices bring a deeply personal perspective to a story that’s as much about family and resilience as it is about the flaws in our legal system.

Key Moments

• Introduction: Rebecca sets the stage for Josh’s story and the broader mission of Wickedly Judged.
• Timeline Deep Dive: A chronological walkthrough of Josh’s case, from the initial accusations to the most recent legal filings.
• Interview Segment: Emotional and insightful conversation with Amanda and Bethany, offering firsthand accounts of the impact of wrongful conviction.
• Revelations: How Bethany’s independent investigation uncovered evidence of a possible social media revenge plot.
• Advocacy in Action: The steps taken to bring Josh’s case to the Michigan Integrity Unit.
• Call to Action: How listeners can get involved, support advocacy efforts, and help fight for justice reform.

Resources & Links

• Learn More About Josh’s Case: wickedlyjudged.com
• Support Our Advocacy: Donate or shop our merchandise to fund investigative work and awareness campaigns.
• Contact Your Representatives: Urge them to support wrongful conviction review and justice reform.
• Have Information? Reach out to us via [email protected] or through our website if you have tips or resources that could help Josh or others in similar situations.

Episode Summary

In this powerful three-hour special, host Rebecca takes you deep inside the concept of due process—what it means, why it’s enshrined in the U.S. Constitution, and how its violation leads to wrongful convictions and shattered lives. You’ll hear the historical roots of due process, real-world case studies, emotional stories of injustice, and a bold vision for reform. This episode is a must-listen for anyone who cares about fairness, accountability, and justice in America’s criminal legal system.

Episode Breakdown

Hour 1: Understanding Due Process

• What is due process?
• The history and constitutional basis (Fifth & Fourteenth Amendments)
• Landmark Supreme Court cases: Gideon v. Wainwright, Miranda v. Arizona, Brady v. Maryland
• What due process looks like in a real criminal case

Hour 2: When Due Process Fails

• Common due process violations: withheld evidence, coerced confessions, denied counsel, biased juries
• The true cost of these failures—statistics and real-life exonerations
• Case studies: Anthony Ray Hinton, Michael Morton
• The lack of accountability for prosecutors and judges
• The human toll: families and communities devastated by wrongful convictions

Hour 3: Reform and the Path Forward

• Why it’s so hard for innocent people to get back into court
• Barriers: procedural rules, new evidence standards, judicial reluctance
• What needs to change: open-file discovery, independent review boards, transparency, lower barriers for new trials
• Mobilizing for reform: how you can make a difference

Key Takeaways

• Due process is the foundation of a fair criminal justice system, protecting every person from arbitrary or unjust punishment.
• Violations of due process are a leading cause of wrongful convictions in the United States.
• Prosecutorial and judicial accountability is rare—but essential for real justice.
• Reform is possible, but it requires policy change, community education, and grassroots action.
• Everyone has a role to play in demanding a just and accountable system.

Call to Action

Ready to make a difference? Here’s how you can help:

• Visit wickedlyjudged.com: Purchase exclusive Wickedly Judged merchandise to support investigations, advocacy, and the production of this podcast.
• Donate: Every dollar helps us fight for justice and support families affected by wrongful convictions.
• Share: Spread the word! Share this episode and our mission on your social media channels.
• Advocate: Contact your elected officials and demand real reform. Vote for transparency and accountability.
• Volunteer: If you have relevant skills or want to get involved, reach out through our website.

In this extended, in-depth finale, Rebecca unpacks the entire story of Scott Barmore—a man sentenced to 60 years to life on charges he insists he did not commit. This episode explores every facet of Scott’s case, from his decision to turn himself in without legal counsel, to the denial of a basic evidentiary hearing, to the State’s false narrative about his high school graduation. Rebecca examines why due process is not a technicality but the foundation of real justice, and how ignoring it leads to devastating consequences—not just for Scott, but for all of us.

Key Topics

• The full timeline of Scott Barmore’s legal journey
• The critical importance of due process and evidentiary hearings
• Why academic records have no bearing on guilt or innocence
• How false narratives and ignored evidence can derail justice
• The ripple effects of wrongful convictions on families and communities
• The urgent need for justice reform and accountability

Why This Matters Scott’s story is a powerful reminder that justice is more than a verdict—it’s a process. When due process is denied, and when authorities distort even basic facts, the entire system is called into question. This episode challenges listeners to demand better—from our courts, our prosecutors, and ourselves.

How You Can Help

• Share this episode to bring Scott’s story—and the need for justice reform—to a wider audience.
• Legal professionals: If you have experience in post-conviction or appellate work, your insight could be crucial for Scott’s case.
• Support our cause: Donate to help us secure records, expert analysis, and resources for cases like Scott’s.
• Purchase merchandise: Visit wickedlyjudged.com to buy apparel and support our advocacy.
• Stay connected: Follow Wickedly Judged on your favorite podcast platform, visit wickedlyjudged.com, and sign up for our newsletter.
• Keep the facts in focus: Scott was convicted on new charges without an evidentiary hearing, and his high school graduation—a fact easily proven—was misrepresented by the State. If the system can get that wrong, what else was missed?

Credits

• Host: Rebecca
• Sponsor: Veteran Alliance
• Music: JP Verse of Versefire Records (intro and outro)

Resources and Links

• Show page, donations, and merchandise: wickedlyjudged.com
• Contact and case submissions: via website or email

Episode Structure

• Introduction and full case recap
• Deep-dive analysis of due process and legal failures
• The human impact of wrongful conviction
• Systemic reform and what needs to change
• Final reflections and a powerful call to action

Content Advisory This episode discusses incarceration, legal appeals, and contested criminal proceedings.

Closing Sign-off “Stay vigilant, stay informed, and stay hopeful—because nobody deserves to be wickedly judged.”

In the second half of our powerful conversation, Rebecca continues the story of Scott Barmore—a man who maintains his innocence after being sentenced to 60 years to life on new charges he says he did not commit. Picking up where the first half left off, Scott shares what life is like after sentencing, the emotional and legal challenges of pursuing appeals, and how he finds hope behind bars. This episode highlights the urgent need for due process, accurate records, and justice reform.

First Half Recap Previously, Scott described the circumstances that led to his arrest: accepting responsibility for his original charges, facing new robbery allegations while on parole, turning himself in without legal counsel, and ultimately being convicted without an evidentiary hearing. We also discussed the State’s disputed claim about his high school completion—despite documentation showing he had already graduated.

Key Topics

• The human impact of long sentences and incarceration
• Navigating the appeals process from prison
• Maintaining hope and dignity after conviction
• Ongoing questions about due process and evidentiary hearings
• The importance of accurate records and legal advocacy

Why This Matters Scott’s story is a stark reminder that justice is more than a verdict—it’s a process. When due process is denied or records are misrepresented, the consequences ripple far beyond a single case.

Call to Action

• Share this episode to help bring Scott’s story—and the need for justice reform—to a wider audience.
• Legal professionals: If you have experience in post-conviction or appellate work, your insight could be crucial for Scott’s case. Please reach out.
• Support our advocacy: Donate to help us secure court records, expert analysis, and resources for cases like Scott’s.
• Stay connected: Follow Wickedly Judged on your favorite podcast platform, visit wickedlyjudged.com for updates, and sign up for our newsletter.
• Keep the facts in focus: Remind others—Scott was convicted without an evidentiary hearing, and his high school graduation is a matter of record.

Credits

• Host: Rebecca
• Guest: Scott Barmore
• Sponsor: Veteran Alliance
• Music: JP Verse of Versefire Records (intro and outro)

Resources and Links

• Show page: wickedlyjudged.com
• Contact and case submissions: via website or email
• Support: [Add donation link if available]

Episode Structure

• Brief recap and introduction
• Full, uninterrupted interview with Scott Barmore (second half)
• Expanded call to action and closing

Content Advisory This episode discusses incarceration, legal appeals, and contested criminal proceedings.

Closing Sign-off “Stay vigilant, stay informed, and stay hopeful—because nobody deserves to be wickedly judged.”

In this episode of Wickedly Judged, Rebecca speaks with Scott Barmore, who maintains his innocence regarding new robbery allegations that resulted in a 60-to-life sentence. Scott turned himself in without legal counsel and argues he was convicted without an evidentiary hearing. We also address the State’s disputed claim about his high school completion—despite documentation that he had graduated at the time of the original offense. This conversation centers due process, factual accuracy, and the human impact of lengthy sentences.

Key Topics

• Self-surrender without counsel and early rights protection
• Allegations of three additional robberies contested by Scott
• Absence of an evidentiary hearing on the new charges
• Disputed probation narrative vs. documented high school graduation
• Why due process and factual accuracy are essential for legitimacy

Why This Matters Evidentiary hearings test credibility and evidence in open court. When that process is skipped or curtailed, outcomes risk resting on untested claims—undermining justice and public trust.

Call to Action

• Share this episode to raise awareness about Scott Barmore’s case.
• Legal professionals with appellate or post-conviction experience: contact us if you can provide pro bono review or expert insight.
• Support our advocacy so we can secure records, transcripts, and expert analysis necessary for a fair review.
• Amplify verified facts: the lack of an evidentiary hearing and documentation of graduation deserve scrutiny.

Notable Quotes

• “Justice isn’t a feeling—it’s a process.”
• “Self-surrender should be accountability—not vulnerability.”
• “If the process is flawed, the outcome is suspect.”

Credits

• Host: Rebecca
• Sponsor: Veteran Alliance
• Music: JP Verse of Versefire Records (intro and outro)

Resources and Links

• Show page: wickedlyjudged.com
• Follow Wickedly Judged on your preferred podcast platform
• Contact/Case submissions: via website or email Note: Add case documents, docket references, or court links here when ready.

Episode Structure (for listeners)

• Intro and concise case background
• Full, uninterrupted interview with Scott Barmore
• Call to action and closing

Content Advisory This episode discusses criminal allegations, incarceration, and contested legal proceedings.

Closing Sign-off “Stay vigilant, stay informed, and stay hopeful—because nobody deserves to be wickedly judged.”

Political violence and wrongful convictions aren’t separate crises—they grow from the same root: dehumanization, contempt for due process, and incentives that reward “wins” over truth. Rebecca reflects on the assassination of Charlie Kirk—whose convictions were anchored in the Founders, the Constitution, and faith in God—and connects it to courtroom failures that steal years from the innocent while rewarding careers built on tainted prosecutions. This is a sober, faith-informed call to restore first principles: innocence until proven guilty, transparent accountability, and human dignity.

What You’ll Learn

• How political violence and wrongful convictions mirror the same cultural decay
• How promotions and prestige can ride on bad prosecutions
• The mechanics behind wrongful convictions (coerced pleas, junk science, suggestive IDs, Brady violations, underfunded defense)
• Concrete reforms to realign incentives and protect due process
• How faith and constitutional guardrails can rehumanize public life

Key Takeaways

• Ends never justify means; a republic survives on restraint.
• Conviction counts are not justice. Tie promotions to integrity and disclosure compliance.
• Presumption of innocence is a moral and constitutional safeguard.
• Independent review units, defense parity, eyewitness reform, and forensic standards save lives.

Chapters

• 00:00 Intro: A nation at a moral breaking point
• 02:30 Framing: Charlie Kirk and our civic immune system
• 07:00 Incentives and promotions for injustice
• 13:00 Founders, Constitution, and faith
• 17:00 How wrongful convictions are manufactured
• 26:00 Human cost: empty chairs, stolen years
• 29:00 Bridging crises: violence, ambition, due process
• 33:00 Restoration agenda: policy, culture, personal action
• 41:00 Reflection and dedication
• 43:00 Call to conscience and action

Action Steps

• Demand promotion metrics that include disclosure compliance and post-conviction integrity.
• Advocate defense parity: caseload caps, investigators, expert budgets.
• Push eyewitness and forensic reforms: double-blind lineups, recorded procedures, independent lab accreditation, blind proficiency testing.
• Support independent Conviction Integrity Units with transparency and authority.
• Vote informed on DA, sheriff, and judicial races.
• De-escalate locally; reject dehumanizing language.

Quotables

• “One uses a weapon; the other uses a courtroom. Both say the ends justify the means.”
• “A scoreboard of convictions isn’t justice—it’s power.”
• “Promotions should be earned by integrity, not by numbers pinned to other people’s pain.”

Content Note This episode discusses violence and wrongful convictions.

Connect

• Website: wickedlyjudged.com
• Email: [email protected]
• New episodes: Thursdays at 5pm Eastern
• Please follow, rate, and share.

In this comprehensive episode, Rebecca delivers the full story of Donald Rogan Simpson Jr.—a man who has spent more than 33 years in a Missouri prison for a crime he has always insisted he did not commit. This episode leaves no detail unexplored: from Donald’s early life and the events that led him to Joplin, to the flawed investigation, coerced witnesses, lost and ignored evidence, and a trial that lasted mere minutes before sealing his fate.

Rebecca guides listeners through every twist and turn: the shifting stories of John Katura, the ignored confession of another suspect, a prosecution built on unreliable testimony, and Donald’s decades-long fight for exoneration. This is a story not just of one man’s struggle, but of a justice system in desperate need of reform.

What You’ll Hear in This Episode:

• Donald’s background and how he ended up in Joplin, Missouri
• The murder of J.D. Masters and the investigation’s immediate focus on Donald
• John Katura’s changing statements and the plea bargain that changed everything
• The missing and mishandled evidence, including lost fingerprints and ignored confessions
• The trial: coerced witnesses, broken promises, and a 13-minute jury deliberation
• Donald’s appeals, new evidence, and the ongoing fight for justice
• The impact of wrongful conviction on Donald’s life and his message to listeners
• How you can get involved and support Donald’s fight for exoneration

Key Resources & Links:

• Review the evidence and case files: wrongfullyconvicted-seekingexoneration.com
• Learn more about justice reform and wrongful convictions: wickedlyjudged.com
• Contact Wickedly Judged: [email protected] | (513) 393-7452

How You Can Help:

• Share this episode and Donald’s story—awareness is the first step to change
• Visit Donald’s website to review the evidence and support his fight for exoneration
• Contact Missouri officials and demand a review of Donald’s case
• Support justice reform and follow Wickedly Judged for more stories, updates, and ways to join the movement

Special Thanks: Thank you to our sponsor, Veteran Alliance, and to JP Verse of Versefire Records for providing the music for this episode.

Remember: Stay vigilant, stay informed, and stay hopeful. Because nobody deserves to be wickedly judged.