Sal and BT dissect the Yankees' ability to hit elite pitching, arguing that their "all or nothing" approach, which is heavily reliant on home runs, is a recipe for disaster in the postseason. They point out that while the Yankees may have a formidable lineup on paper and can bludgeon mediocre pitchers during the regular season, their historical struggles against top-tier pitching in the playoffs are a major concern. The conversation centers on the idea that the team's offense lacks consistency and the ability to manufacture runs when home runs aren't happening, leaving them vulnerable when facing quality starting pitchers and bullpens.