In August 1925, fourteen-year-old Mary Vickery vanished from the coal camp of Coxton in Harlan County, Kentucky. Her father, miner E.C. Vickery, stopped going underground and began searching above it, combing hollows and writing desperate letters for help. Months later, a decomposed body was discovered in an abandoned mine shaft between Harlan and Baxter.

A suspect was arrested. A courtroom filled to the rafters. A jury convicted 23-year-old taxi driver Conley Dabney of rape and murder, sentencing him to life in prison.

And then, nearly a year later, the “murdered” girl walked into a hotel in Williamsburg, Kentucky, very much alive.

• Mary Vickery – The missing girl who returned from the dead.

• E.C. Vickery – Her father, who identified a body that was not his daughter.

• Conley Dabney – Taxi driver convicted of Mary’s “murder,” later pardoned.

• Marie Jackson – The key witness whose testimony sent a man to prison.

• Leila Cole – A woman who may have been the true victim found in the mine.

• Roxie Baker – Another young woman killed in Harlan in 1925, whose death still cast a shadow over the county.

• The fragility of eyewitness testimony

• Moral panic in small towns

• How quickly public opinion can flip

• The role of newspapers in shaping guilt and innocence

• The complexity of teenage runaways in the 1920s

• Justice in coal country

This is a story where nearly every thread tangles into another: jealous lovers, missing women, contradictory confessions, misidentified clothing, and suspects who vanish just as grand juries convene.

And at the center of it all, a girl who heard that a man was in prison for killing her… and chose not to come home.

I uncovered photographs of Mary Vickery, Conley Dabney, Governor Fields signing the pardon, Marie Jackson, and even Mary’s courthouse wedding just days after her return. You will absolutely want to see these.

Follow Kentucky History & Haunts on Facebook and Instagram for all episode visuals.

If you’d like to support the research and storytelling that goes into Kentucky History & Haunts, you can buy me a birthday coffee for $5 via Venmo- https://account.venmo.com/u/kyhistoryhaunts

A rating or review on Spotify or Apple Podcasts also helps more than you know.

For feedback or story ideas: [email protected]

Mail:

Jessie Bartholomew

9115 Leesgate Rd, A

Louisville, KY 40222

**Transcripts are autogenerated and may contain errors