Truth, Lies and Work

237. Is hybrid the worst of all worlds? With Professors Ina Purvanova and Alanah Mitchell, authors of The New Workplace"


Listen Later

Welcome back to Truth, Lies & Work, the award-winning podcast where behavioral science meets workplace culture.

Hosted by Chartered Occupational Psychologist Leanne Elliott and business owner Al Elliott, this episode features Professors Ina Purvanova and Alanah Mitchell, authors of "The New Workplace" and experts who've spent years studying remote, hybrid, and in-office work arrangements.


Episode Summary

What if hybrid working isn't the best of both worlds, but actually the worst? Professors Ina Purvanova and Alanah Mitchell have mapped nine different work personas - from "officers" who never want to leave the office, to "avatars" who live entirely online, to "integrators" trying to bridge both worlds. Their research reveals that 65% of workers are now aligned with their company's workplace strategy, but that still leaves 35% struggling with misalignment that affects engagement, commitment, and ultimately performance.

This conversation explores what happens when work personas collide, why hybrid can create more conflict than clarity, and how leaders can move their teams from misaligned to at least half-aligned without losing their best people. You'll hear heartbreaking stories of young workers describing themselves as "soulless husks" when forced to work remotely, and female executives who prefer office work for unexpected reasons.


What We Cover


The Nine Work Personas

  • How people fall into categories like "officers," "avatars," and "integrators" based on their workplace preferences
  • Why Hybrid Creates Conflict

    • How hybrid workplaces can become battlegrounds between opposing preferences, with officers and avatars both wanting companies to go fully their way
    • The Alignment Problem

      • Why 65% alignment isn't enough and what happens to the misaligned 35% who stay in jobs that don't suit them
      • Task-Location Fit

        • Moving from "dress for your day" to "locate for your day" based on what tasks you need to accomplish
        • Who Decides the Strategy

          • Whether leaders should set workplace policies or listen to what teams actually want
          • Personas Change Over Time

            • How life stages, from early career to parenthood to late career, can shift your workplace preferences
            • Recruitment Reality

              • Why honest job previews about work arrangements are crucial for avoiding misalignment from day one
              • The Future of Work

                • Predictions for 2050 and why hybrid might win by default

                • Resources

                  The New Workplace book website: https://thenewworkplacebook.com/

                  • Connect with Ina Purvanova on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ina-purvanova/
                  • Connect with Alanah Mitchell on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/alanah-mitchell/

                  • Mental Health Support

                    The episode discusses some difficult workplace experiences, including feelings of isolation, loneliness, and depression. If you or someone you know is struggling with mental health:


                    UK:

                    • Samaritans: 116 123 (24/7 helpline) - https://www.samaritans.org/
                    • Mind: 0300 123 3393 or text 86463 - https://www.mind.org.uk/
                    • US:

                      • 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: Call or text 988 (24/7) - https://988lifeline.org/
                      • NAMI Helpline: 1-800-950-NAMI (6264) - https://www.nami.org/
                      • International:

                        • Befrienders Worldwide: https://www.befrienders.org/ (directory of crisis helplines worldwide)
                        • International Association for Suicide Prevention: https://www.iasp.info/resources/Crisis_Centres/ (global crisis center directory)

                        • Connect with Your Hosts

                          • Connect with Al on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/thisisalelliott/
                          • Connect with Leanne on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/meetleanne
                          • Join the discussion about this episode on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/truthlieswork/
                          • Follow us on Instagram: @truthlieswork
                          • Chat with us on X: @truthlieswork
                          • YouTube channel: @TruthLiesWork
                          • Check us out on TikTok: @truthlieswork


                          • ...more
                            View all episodesView all episodes
                            Download on the App Store

                            Truth, Lies and WorkBy HubSpot Podcast Network

                            • 5
                            • 5
                            • 5
                            • 5
                            • 5

                            5

                            33 ratings


                            More shows like Truth, Lies and Work

                            View all
                            The Martin Lewis Podcast by BBC Radio 5 Live

                            The Martin Lewis Podcast

                            83 Listeners

                            The Infinite Monkey Cage by BBC Radio 4

                            The Infinite Monkey Cage

                            2,088 Listeners

                            The Food Chain by BBC World Service

                            The Food Chain

                            348 Listeners

                            Eat Sleep Work Repeat - better workplace culture by brucedaisley.com

                            Eat Sleep Work Repeat - better workplace culture

                            286 Listeners

                            The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett by DOAC

                            The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett

                            8,547 Listeners

                            Feel Better, Live More with Dr Rangan Chatterjee by Dr Rangan Chatterjee: GP & Author

                            Feel Better, Live More with Dr Rangan Chatterjee

                            3,843 Listeners

                            Happy Place by Fearne Cotton

                            Happy Place

                            1,113 Listeners

                            How To Fail With Elizabeth Day by Elizabeth Day and Sony Music Entertainment

                            How To Fail With Elizabeth Day

                            1,250 Listeners

                            Sliced Bread by BBC Radio 4

                            Sliced Bread

                            139 Listeners

                            Success Story with Scott D. Clary by Success Story Media

                            Success Story with Scott D. Clary

                            317 Listeners

                            Parenting Hell with Rob Beckett and Josh Widdicombe by Keep It Light Media / Spotify Studios

                            Parenting Hell with Rob Beckett and Josh Widdicombe

                            960 Listeners

                            The Green Insider Powered by eRENEWABLE by The Green Insider Powered by eRENEWABLE

                            The Green Insider Powered by eRENEWABLE

                            54 Listeners

                            Russell Howard’s Five Brilliant Things by Avalon Television

                            Russell Howard’s Five Brilliant Things

                            130 Listeners

                            The Romesh Ranganathan Show by Ranga Bee / Listen

                            The Romesh Ranganathan Show

                            78 Listeners