On Saturday, March 1st, 2008, the Caffey family home in Emory, Texas was engulfed in flames. Terry Caffey, the father, had been shot five times and had amazingly escaped the burning home and crawled 500 yards to his neighbors’ house, where 911 was called. Firefighters found the burned remains of 38-year-old Penny Caffey, 13-year-old Matthew, and 8-year-old Tyler. Still missing was 16-year-old Erin. Terry was immediately rushed to the hospital and into surgery. Once Terry was in recovery, a Rains County Sheriff told him that his only daughter was alive and well. Unfortunately, Terry’s relief that Erin was safe was short-lived. The Sheriff also told Terry that she was in custody for being involved in the murders. He was stunned. There was no way that his daughter had anything to do with this. However, Terry, and the rest of the community, were shocked to find that the evidence against Erin was overwhelming.

Did you know that we release an update all about us and what we’re up to each week on our Patreon? It’s called T to the 4th Power Y (time to talk to you, a little nod to Not Another Teen Movie), and it’s where we just gal pal with you about life, what we’re watching, our love for Cracker Barrel italian dressing… the sky is the limit really.

If you want to catch an episode without being a patron, you’re in luck! Just head to: https://killerqueens.link/tttty and you’ll get to hear a full episode for free! 

© 2023 Killer Queens Podcast. All Rights Reserved

Audio Production by Wayfare Recording

Music provided by Steven Tobi

Logo designed by Sloane Williams of The Sophisticated Crayon

YouTube Editing by Jennifer Da Silva