Everything Hertz

76: Open peer review

Listen Later

Peer review is typically conducted behind closed doors. There's been a recent push to make open peer review standard, but what's often left out of these conversations are the potential downsides. To illustrate this, Dan and James discuss a recent instance of open peer review that led to considerable online debate.

Here's what they cover...

  • How should we navigate the open review of preprints?
  • Gate keepers gonna gate keep, but is this better out in the open?
  • Weaponising openness
  • Some people don't realise that some data can’t be shared
  • Should the reviewers of rejected papers follow them to the next journal?
  • When bad papers that you reject pop up in another journal, unchanged
  • Does the venue and timing of the open peer review matter?
  • Signing your reviews
  • Using publons to track your reviews

    • Links

    • Brad Love’s blog post: http://bradlove.org/blog/open-review
    • Niko’s blog post: https://nikokriegeskorte.org/2019/01/09/whats-the-best-measure-of-representational-dissimilarity/
    • Publons: https://publons.com
    • Dan on twitter: https://www.twitter.com/dsquintana
    • James on twitter: https://www.twitter.com/jamesheathers
    • Everything Hertz on twitter: https://www.twitter.com/hertzpodcast
    • Everything Hertz on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/everythinghertzpodcast/

      • Music credits: Lee Rosevere freemusicarchive.org/music/Lee_Rosevere/

      Support us on Patreon and get bonus stuff!

      • $1 a month or more: Monthly newsletter + Access to behind-the-scenes photos & video via the Patreon app + the the warm feeling you're supporting the show
      • $5 a month or more: All the stuff you get in the $1 tier PLUS a bonus mini episode every month (extras + the bits we couldn't include in our regular episodes)

        • Support Everything Hertz

        ...more
        View all episodesView all episodes
        Download on the App Store
        Everything HertzBy Dan Quintana
        • 4.8
        • 4.8
        • 4.8
        • 4.8
        • 4.8

        4.8

        55 ratings

        More shows like Everything Hertz

        View all
        Philosophy Bites by Edmonds and Warburton

        Philosophy Bites

        1,538 Listeners

        Very Bad Wizards by Tamler Sommers & David Pizarro

        Very Bad Wizards

        2,653 Listeners

        The Gist by Peach Fish Productions

        The Gist

        59 Listeners

        Barbell Medicine Podcast by Barbell Medicine

        Barbell Medicine Podcast

        1,161 Listeners

        Sean Carroll's Mindscape: Science, Society, Philosophy, Culture, Arts, and Ideas by Sean Carroll | Wondery

        Sean Carroll's Mindscape: Science, Society, Philosophy, Culture, Arts, and Ideas

        4,127 Listeners

        Iron Culture presented by MASS by Eric Helms & Eric Trexler

        Iron Culture presented by MASS

        722 Listeners

        Within Reason by Alex J O'Connor

        Within Reason

        1,556 Listeners

        Tech Won't Save Us by Paris Marx

        Tech Won't Save Us

        531 Listeners

        Deep Questions with Cal Newport by Cal Newport

        Deep Questions with Cal Newport

        1,301 Listeners

        Decoding the Gurus by Christopher Kavanagh and Matthew Browne

        Decoding the Gurus

        937 Listeners

        Clearer Thinking with Spencer Greenberg by Spencer Greenberg

        Clearer Thinking with Spencer Greenberg

        131 Listeners

        The Ezra Klein Show by New York Times Opinion

        The Ezra Klein Show

        15,371 Listeners

        The Joy of Why by Steven Strogatz, Janna Levin and Quanta Magazine

        The Joy of Why

        497 Listeners

        Nullius in Verba by Smriti Mehta and Daniël Lakens

        Nullius in Verba

        10 Listeners

        The 404 Media Podcast by 404 Media

        The 404 Media Podcast

        314 Listeners