Walden Pod

78 - Ghosts? Yeah, why not. Ghosts.


Listen Later

Today we discuss three skeptical arguments from Wang Chong, a first-century Chinese philosopher who railed against the belief in ghosts. Although the skeptics who initially presented these arguments to me seemed to think they were decisive, I was unimpressed and wanted to explain why I think they miss the center of the spectral target. 

As summarized on Wang’s IEP entry: 

(1) Argument from physical shape:  The death of a person is the result of the body losing the animating qi (vital essence), and once the qi is separated from the body, the body decays.  All will admit to this.  If this is so, however, and the person’s qi is still existent, how can this qi itself manifest in the form of a physical shape?  It is not a body, it is qi.  But when one sees a ghost, one sees a body.  But if the person has died, they no longer have a body, so where could they get another one?  They cannot take over another living body, which will already possess its own qi.  Thus, the view that people when they die become ghosts is nonsensical. 

(2) Argument from population:  If people become ghosts when they die, there should be more ghost sightings than living people, as the number of people who have lived in the past and died is far greater than the number of people now living.  This is not true — ghost “sightings” are rare.  Thus it cannot be that people when they die become ghosts.

(3) Argument from ghostly efficacy:  If a living person is harmed, this person will immediately go to a magistrate and bring a case against the party who harmed them.  If it were the case that people become ghosts when they die and can interact with living humans, every ghostly murder victim would be seen going to a magistrate, telling him the name of the killer and the means of murder, leading him to the body, and so forth.  This is never witnessed (ever). 

Wang Chong - IEP 

Philosophy on the Fringes - Ghosts and Hauntings 

Dale Allison Interview - Encountering Mystery 

Greenbrier Ghost - Jimmy Akin’s Mysterious World 

Twitter thread where I first encountered Wang Chong

Music for this episode was performed by yours truly (except the drums).
Linktree 

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Walden PodBy Emerson Green

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

34 ratings


More shows like Walden Pod

View all
Philosophy Bites by Edmonds and Warburton

Philosophy Bites

1,529 Listeners

Unbelievable? by Premier Unbelievable?

Unbelievable?

2,037 Listeners

TheThinkingAtheist by The Thinking Atheist

TheThinkingAtheist

2,854 Listeners

The Glenn Show by Glenn Loury

The Glenn Show

2,279 Listeners

Very Bad Wizards by Tamler Sommers & David Pizarro

Very Bad Wizards

2,667 Listeners

Philosophize This! by Stephen West

Philosophize This!

15,179 Listeners

Making Sense with Sam Harris by Sam Harris

Making Sense with Sam Harris

26,356 Listeners

The Michael Shermer Show by Michael Shermer

The Michael Shermer Show

926 Listeners

Sean Carroll's Mindscape: Science, Society, Philosophy, Culture, Arts, and Ideas by Sean Carroll | Wondery

Sean Carroll's Mindscape: Science, Society, Philosophy, Culture, Arts, and Ideas

4,133 Listeners

Within Reason by Alex J O'Connor

Within Reason

1,584 Listeners

The Origins Podcast with Lawrence Krauss by Lawrence M. Krauss

The Origins Podcast with Lawrence Krauss

499 Listeners

Theories of Everything with Curt Jaimungal by Theories of Everything

Theories of Everything with Curt Jaimungal

469 Listeners

Decoding the Gurus by Christopher Kavanagh and Matthew Browne

Decoding the Gurus

950 Listeners

Conversations with Peter Boghossian by Peter Boghossian

Conversations with Peter Boghossian

215 Listeners

The Know Rogan Experience by Cross Pond Productions

The Know Rogan Experience

748 Listeners