Moral Maze

A world without Down's syndrome?


Listen Later

Do we want to live in a world without Down's syndrome? This isn't just a theoretical question. It could soon become a reality. A new technique called non-invasive prenatal testing (NIPT), detects Down's syndrome with 99% accuracy and it should soon be available on the NHS. It's already being used in Iceland where 100% of Down's syndrome pregnancies are terminated. The Danish health system declared the objective of being Down's-free and introduced the test in 2006. The termination rate there today is 98%. In Britain the termination rate for positive tests is 90 per cent and around 775 babies with Down's syndrome are born every year in England and Wales. A lot of effort has been made to increase people's knowledge of the condition which has a wide range of symptoms. Many children with it will grow in to adulthood and lead very integrated lives, but some will never walk or talk, or may have severe heart defects, glaucoma, deafness and a risk of early dementia. Would it be a sign of human progress if we reduced the number of people born with Down's syndrome to zero? Many people would agree that reducing suffering is an unequivocal moral good, yet when Richard Dawkins told a woman on Twitter that if she was carrying a child with Down's she should "abort it and try again" and "It would be immoral to bring it into the world if you have a choice" there was an outcry. NIPT could soon be available for other single gene disorders such as cystic fibrosis and we've done our best to eradicate many other disabling conditions, so why not make the most of what technology can offer? Or is this a kind of nightmare eugenicist council of perfection - a triumph of cold hearted utilitarianism over our moral duty to embrace difference and care for our fellow man? Chaired by Michael Buerk with Anne McElvoy, Claire Fox, Giles Fraser and Melanie Phillips. Witnesses are Sally Phillips, Jane Fisher, Prof Dominic Wilkinson and Simone Aspis.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Moral MazeBy BBC Radio 4

  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6

4.6

51 ratings


More shows like Moral Maze

View all
In Our Time by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time

5,454 Listeners

From Our Own Correspondent by BBC Radio 4

From Our Own Correspondent

368 Listeners

The Documentary Podcast by BBC World Service

The Documentary Podcast

1,802 Listeners

Start the Week by BBC Radio 4

Start the Week

159 Listeners

Global News Podcast by BBC World Service

Global News Podcast

7,686 Listeners

Thinking Allowed by BBC Radio 4

Thinking Allowed

299 Listeners

6 Minute English by BBC Radio

6 Minute English

1,807 Listeners

Learning English Conversations by BBC Radio

Learning English Conversations

1,094 Listeners

The Bottom Line by BBC Radio 4

The Bottom Line

34 Listeners

The Week in Westminster by BBC Radio 4

The Week in Westminster

27 Listeners

Friday Night Comedy from BBC Radio 4 by BBC Radio 4

Friday Night Comedy from BBC Radio 4

2,115 Listeners

More or Less: Behind the Stats by BBC Radio 4

More or Less: Behind the Stats

899 Listeners

The Infinite Monkey Cage by BBC Radio 4

The Infinite Monkey Cage

1,933 Listeners

Newshour by BBC World Service

Newshour

1,053 Listeners

Any Questions? and Any Answers? by BBC Radio 4

Any Questions? and Any Answers?

40 Listeners

The New Statesman: politics and culture by The New Statesman

The New Statesman: politics and culture

145 Listeners

The Briefing Room by BBC Radio 4

The Briefing Room

63 Listeners

Political Thinking with Nick Robinson by BBC Radio 4

Political Thinking with Nick Robinson

107 Listeners

13 Minutes Presents: The Space Shuttle by BBC World Service

13 Minutes Presents: The Space Shuttle

4,191 Listeners

You're Dead to Me by BBC Radio 4

You're Dead to Me

3,197 Listeners

The Great Post Office Trial by BBC Radio 4

The Great Post Office Trial

36 Listeners

The Rest Is Politics by Goalhanger

The Rest Is Politics

3,243 Listeners

The News Agents by Global

The News Agents

1,001 Listeners

The Rest Is Politics: Leading by Goalhanger

The Rest Is Politics: Leading

880 Listeners

Radical with Amol Rajan by BBC Radio 4

Radical with Amol Rajan

31 Listeners