Black Sheep

Baby Farmer: the story of Minnie Dean


Listen Later

Minnie Dean is the only woman to be judicially executed in New Zealand history. For years she was portrayed as a cold-blooded killer who murdered babies for cash. More recently, attitudes towards Minnie have shifted, but she's still a controversial and complex figure. Black Sheep dives into the story of the baby farmer of Winton.

Minnie Dean must rank as one of New Zealand's most infamous figures. The first and only woman to be judicially executed in our history.

For years she was portrayed as a cold-blooded killer who murdered babies for cash. More recently, attitudes towards Minnie have shifted, but she's still a controversial and complex figure.

Minnie arrived in Invercargill on a ship from Tasmania in the early 1860s. We don't know exactly which year or her age but she would have been in her late teens or early 20s.

She told people she was the widow of an Australian doctor and the daughter of a Presbyterian minister back home in Scotland. That story wasn't true.

But as historian Barbara Brookes explained, it was pretty common for new migrants to lie about their backgrounds. "That's one of the big attractions of migration. People could reinvent themselves."

And Minnie had more reasons than most to want to reinvent herself. She arrived in Invercargill with a young daughter and was pregnant with a second.

Lynley Hood, author of Minnie Dean: Her Life and Crimes, found Tasmanian birth records for Minnie's eldest daughter signed with her maiden name - Williamina McCulloch.

That suggests both Minnie's daughters, Ellen and Isabelle, were illegitimate.

"She was only 16 years old and she'd gone to Tasmania by herself," Lynley Hood said. "Maybe she was pregnant and had been sent off to the colonies because she was bringing the family to shame?"

Of course, illegitimacy wasn't uncommon in the 19th century, but it came with a heavy social sanction. Unwed mothers struggled to find jobs, or husbands or any kind of normal social life. Minnie's white lie about a dead husband let her dodge a lot of social baggage.

She probably had some help in pulling off this story. Minnie had a famous aunt in New Zealand. She's best known as Granny Kelly, a founding settler of Invercargill.

"Her aunt would have known the truth," said Lynley Hood. "It must have been who really put her arms around , and supported her, and helped spread the story that she was the widow of a doctor and the daughter of a clergyman."

So Minnie had a tricky start to life, but she spent the next eight years making the most of her second chance. …

Go to this episode on rnz.co.nz for more details

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Black SheepBy RNZ

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

61 ratings


More shows like Black Sheep

View all
Nine To Noon by RNZ

Nine To Noon

23 Listeners

Saturday Morning by RNZ

Saturday Morning

50 Listeners

Sunday Morning by RNZ

Sunday Morning

10 Listeners

Mediawatch by RNZ

Mediawatch

14 Listeners

Enzology by RNZ

Enzology

11 Listeners

Here Now by RNZ

Here Now

1 Listeners

Gone By Lunchtime by The Spinoff

Gone By Lunchtime

25 Listeners

FROM ZERO by RNZ

FROM ZERO

1 Listeners

The Science Of… by RNZ

The Science Of…

1 Listeners

Go Ahead Caller by RNZ

Go Ahead Caller

3 Listeners

Voice of the Iceberg by RNZ

Voice of the Iceberg

27 Listeners

Slice of Heaven by RNZ

Slice of Heaven

1 Listeners

The Lost by RNZ

The Lost

40 Listeners

Pants on Fire by RNZ

Pants on Fire

102 Listeners

The Front Page by NZ Herald

The Front Page

19 Listeners

Forgotten Australia by Forgotten Australia

Forgotten Australia

155 Listeners

The Worst Sitcom Ever Made by RNZ

The Worst Sitcom Ever Made

7 Listeners

The Detail by RNZ

The Detail

58 Listeners

A Moment In Crime by NZME

A Moment In Crime

72 Listeners

Between Two Beers Podcast by Steven Holloway & Seamus Marten

Between Two Beers Podcast

85 Listeners

Best of Storytime by RNZ

Best of Storytime

2 Listeners

The Citizen's Handbook by RNZ

The Citizen's Handbook

3 Listeners

After the Virus by RNZ

After the Virus

0 Listeners

The Service by RNZ

The Service

30 Listeners

When the Facts Change by The Spinoff

When the Facts Change

16 Listeners

Short Story Stack by RNZ

Short Story Stack

0 Listeners

Fight for the Wild by RNZ

Fight for the Wild

3 Listeners

Sci Fi / Sci Fact by RNZ

Sci Fi / Sci Fact

0 Listeners

Hair and Loathing by TAHI

Hair and Loathing

0 Listeners

The Trial by Stuff Audio

The Trial

67 Listeners

DELVE by newsroom.co.nz

DELVE

155 Listeners

Deer Wars by RNZ

Deer Wars

2 Listeners

A Forgotten History by NZ Herald

A Forgotten History

26 Listeners

Voice of Tangaroa by RNZ

Voice of Tangaroa

0 Listeners

Kim Hill Wants To Know by RNZ

Kim Hill Wants To Know

32 Listeners