Amy came into Big Brother 27 as the Mastermind’s Apprentice and then became, in her words, Rachel’s apprentice. She seems to throw all the blame for her own loss on Rachel. As she told Julie, “They wanted to cut me and Rachel.” But is that really the reason she was voted out? Even if it was, who is to blame? David Bloomberg and Ovi Kabir look at everything we saw on TV and live feeds to figure out why, as the Mastermind said, Amy was better at pushing secret buttons than playing the game. Because at RHAP, we know Big Brother, and we know Why Amy Lost.

Never miss a minute of RHAP’s extensive Big Brother coverage!