Daily Halacha Podcast - Daily Halacha By Rabbi Eli J. Mansour

Boat Travel and a Double Doubt in Rabbinic Law


Listen Later

In general, the Halacha permits traveling by boat on Shabbat, provided that one boarded the specified time before Shabbat. However, the Shulhan Aruch (248:2), based on a responsa of the Rambam, adds a caveat to this practice. He rules, that it is only permitted to travel over water on Shabbat, if it is not known for certain that the depth of the water is less than 10 tefachim (handbreadths). If it is known that the water is so shallow, travelling presents a problem of Tehumin (Leaving the boundaries of Shabbat.) Accordingly, even if one is in doubt as to the depth of the water, it is permitted to travel. Since the prohibition of Tehumin is M'drabanan (Rabbinic Law), the principle of Safek D'raban L'Kula, ("A doubt in a rabbinic matter is resolved leniently") is applied. Rabbi Akiva Eger (1761-1837) extrapolates a fundamental Halachic principle from this precedent. He points out that even travel above 10 tefachim is subject to question. The Talmud already defined such a case as a Halachic doubt. Therefore, one could have argued that travel over water whose depth is unknown, should be prohibited because of a "Safek Sefeka" (Double Doubt) of stringency: If the water is less than 10 Tefahim, it is certainly prohibited; if the water is deeper than 10 Tefahim, it still presents a problem, because of the side that is stringent even in such a case. From the fact that the Shulhan Aruch did not take this approach and maintained a lenient position, it can be concluded that the aforementioned argument is faulty. Rabbi Akiva Eger, based on the Shaar HaMelech, thereby deduces a general principle that in a doubt with regard to Rabbinic law, even a double doubt to be stringent is resolved leniently. This principle is adopted by Hacham Ovadia in Yabia Omer, as well as in Hazon Ovadia (Hilchot Shabbat, Vol. 1). He defends this leniency as a general rule in all areas of Halacha, against those opinions that view it as a special ruling in the case of Tehumin. SUMMARY A Halachic doubt in a Rabbinic Law is resolved leniently, even if there are two doubts towards stringency.
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Daily Halacha Podcast - Daily Halacha By Rabbi Eli J. MansourBy Rabbi Eli J. Mansour

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

70 ratings


More shows like Daily Halacha Podcast - Daily Halacha By Rabbi Eli J. Mansour

View all
Daily Gemara Podcast - Daf Yomi By Rabbi Eli J. Mansour by Rabbi Eli J. Mansour

Daily Gemara Podcast - Daf Yomi By Rabbi Eli J. Mansour

77 Listeners

The Office of Rabbi Sacks by Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks

The Office of Rabbi Sacks

530 Listeners

Halacha Headlines by Halacha Headlines

Halacha Headlines

483 Listeners

Orthodox Conundrum by Scott Kahn

Orthodox Conundrum

208 Listeners

Jewish History Soundbites by Yehuda Geberer

Jewish History Soundbites

452 Listeners

Daily Halacha with Rabbi Raymond Haber by Rabbi Raymond Haber

Daily Halacha with Rabbi Raymond Haber

4 Listeners

The Q & A with Rabbi Breitowitz Podcast by Rabbi Dr Yitzchak Breitowitz

The Q & A with Rabbi Breitowitz Podcast

223 Listeners

Meaningful People by Meaningful Minute

Meaningful People

1,929 Listeners

From the Inside Out: With Rivkah Krinsky and Eda Schottenstein by Rivkah and Eda

From the Inside Out: With Rivkah Krinsky and Eda Schottenstein

245 Listeners

18Forty Podcast by 18Forty

18Forty Podcast

644 Listeners

Call Me Back - with Dan Senor by Ark Media

Call Me Back - with Dan Senor

2,852 Listeners

Kosher Money by Living Lchaim

Kosher Money

794 Listeners

AND HERE’S MODI by Modi

AND HERE’S MODI

226 Listeners

Gedale Fenster - Podcast by Gedale Fenster - Podcast

Gedale Fenster - Podcast

337 Listeners

Inspiration for the Nation with Yaakov Langer by Living Lchaim

Inspiration for the Nation with Yaakov Langer

1,023 Listeners