By Maryanne Demasi at Brownstone dot org.
Last Thursday, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr entered, the Senate Finance Committee hearing knowing what to expect. Democrats had declared war before he'd even sat down.
On the eve of his testimony, they issued a "report card" cataloguing every alleged misstep during his 203 days as Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS).
From his shake-up at the CDC to the fact that he once wore jeans on a hike in the blazing Arizona sun - supposedly defying CDC advice to "wear loose, lightweight clothing" in extreme heat - nothing was too trivial to mention.
And, if that wasn't enough, more than a thousand current and former HHS employees had signed a petition demanding his resignation.
For just under three hours, Senators from both parties shouted, interrupted, hurled insults and staged "gotcha" moments…it was an ambush.
The Opening Trap
Operation Warp Speed dominated the early exchanges. Senators pressed Kennedy on whether Donald Trump deserved a Nobel Prize for pushing vaccines out at record speed.
"Absolutely," Kennedy said. "It was an unprecedented achievement."
Then, hoping to catch Kennedy in a contradiction, they challenged him on whether the vaccines saved "millions of lives."
Kennedy refused to put a number on it. "I don't think anybody knows that because of the data," he said, pointing out that the figures were based on modelling, not clinical trials.
The panel accused him of being evasive.
Demands without Data
Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) came out swinging, alleging Kennedy had broken his promise not to "take vaccines away from anyone" by narrowing Covid booster recommendations to high-risk groups.
Kennedy held firm. "It's not recommended for healthy people."
"You are effectively denying people vaccines," Warren snapped.
"I'm not taking them away from anybody," Kennedy shot back. "You want me to indicate a product for which there is no clinical data? Is that what you want?"
Warren lost her composure. "You clearly are taking away vaccines. You're putting America's babies' health at risk, America's seniors' health at risk, all Americans' health at risk, and you should resign."
The exchange exposed the mindset in the room…Senators spoke of vaccines with a kind of zealotry and religiosity that was deeply unnerving.
They were openly demanding that people be injected with a product lacking safety data, and calling it "science."
Further, framing it as a matter of "denying access" to Covid vaccines was not only misleading but conniving. The vaccines remain available off-label to anyone who wants them.
Kennedy refused to yield. Recommending products without evidence, he said, is politics, not science.
Across Europe and Australia, governments have already pulled back, limiting use of the shots in under-18s without controversy. In the US, unfortunately, alarmism continues to drown out reason.
The Insults Fly
As tempers escalated, so did the insults. Senator Michael Bennet (D-CO) flatly accused Kennedy of spreading "lies."
Senator Maria Cantwell (D-WA) sneered, calling him a "charlatan" after cancelling $500 million in mRNA contracts.
Senator Raphael Warnock (D-GA) branded Kennedy "a hazard to the health of the American people," demanding his resignation.
And Senator Ron Wyden (D-OR) warned that Kennedy was "dead set on making it harder for children to get vaccines and that kids are going to die because of it."
Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT) thundered that professional associations like the American Medical Association and the American Academy of Pediatrics, all agreed that vaccines were "safe and effective." How dare Kennedy doubt them.
Kennedy shot back, "There's a big difference, Senator, between established science and the scientific establishment, which has been co-opted by the pharmaceutical industry."
He reminded Sanders that his advisers included Marty Makary, Vinay Prasad, Jay Bhattacharya and Dr Oz - scientists willing to challenge orthodoxy.
But Sanders scoffed at his "few advisers," in...