The Catholic Man Show

Can Fire Really Burn a Soul? Aquinas Explains | The Catholic Man Show


Listen Later

Adam's about to be Coweta's biggest celebrity. Porter and Prairie Farm's SEO game has worked so well that a Tulsa news station called wanting an interview about egg prices and how they're crushing family farms. Problem is, Adam has no idea what egg prices are doing anywhere else. He just knows what he charges, and that they've lost 35 chickens in two weeks. Lady Haylee, in her prudence, said maybe skip the interview. Adam already said yes. The real debate of the week: overalls or no overalls for the camera. Overalls, obviously. Carhartt, not blue jean, collared shirt underneath. Now both guys want branded farm overalls, Niles Ranch and Fecundity Farm for Dave, Porter and Prairie Family Farm for Adam.

Sponsor: Amen app (from the Augustine Institute) The Amen app is the free Catholic prayer app the guys use to walk through the Sunday Gospel with their kids on the way to Mass, plus free access to classics like Divine Mercy in My Soul and True Devotion to Mary. No paywall, no subscription trap. Download the Amen app right now.

Sponsor: Select International Tours When Adam and Dave planned their first pilgrimage, Select International Tours is who everyone pointed them to, and having used them, the guys can vouch for it. Wherever you want to go, head to selectinternationaltours.com and see what they offer.

Dave's week wasn't any calmer. He harvested and shucked 500 to 700 ears of corn with the whole family, then blanched all of it late into the night while Lady Pamela held down a house full of unexpected company. His exact line on the way out the door: "I gotta go drink with my buddy for Jesus. It's a ministry, babe." Piglets are due any day, and this time he's praying they're born alive.

The pour is a revisit: Salterra 14-Year Single Malt Scotch, finished in an Oloroso barrel, 48% ABV. Warm, not hot. Worth going back to.

The prayer request is Mary. She's got an eye procedure Thursday, lasers, to make sure her retina stays attached so she doesn't go blind. She needs to put on weight first. Some days she gains 70 grams, some days she loses it. Thank you for praying. Keep it up.

Then the real topic: what actually happens to your soul between the moment you die and the resurrection of your body. Can fire really burn something with no body to burn? Pulling from Aquinas's Summa, the guys walk through it. Your body dies, your soul doesn't, and it faces judgment immediately, heaven, hell, or purgatory on the way to heaven. The senses go dark since they run through bodily organs, but the intellect and the will, the parts that never needed a body to operate, stay fully awake. Aquinas's answer to the fire question: it doesn't burn the soul like a stove burns wood. It binds it. In sin, you subjected your higher self to a lower appetite, so in justice, a lower thing, fire, now holds your higher self captive. It's God's instrument, not chemistry.

Then the bonus round: limbo. The limbo of the fathers, emptied by Christ at the Harrowing of Hell. The limbo of infants, never defined as dogma, still debated, and Dave's new coinage for where he thinks it actually belongs: limburgatory. A place with no suffering doesn't belong bolted onto hell.

Protect what you love. Provide the truth even when it costs you something. Establish your kids in what's actually at stake. Raise your glass.

TOPICS COVERED
  • Porter and Prairie Farm's SEO play working so well a Tulsa news station wants an egg price interview
  • Losing 35 chickens in two weeks and having zero idea what egg prices are doing anywhere else
  • The overalls debate: Carhartt over blue jean, collared shirt, and the case for branded farm overalls
  • The economics of homesteading: it only "pays for itself" if you value your own labor at zero
  • Dave shucking and blanching 500 to 700 ears of corn with the whole family in one night
  • "I gotta go drink with my buddy for Jesus, it's a ministry, babe"
  • Piglets due any day and praying for a better outcome than last time
  • Bourbon of the week: revisiting Salterra 14-Year Single Malt Scotch, Oloroso barrel finish, 48% ABV
  • Prayer update on baby Mary: a Thursday laser eye procedure to protect her retina, and the fight to gain weight
  • What actually happens to the soul between death and the resurrection of the body
  • Matthew 25:41 and what "everlasting fire" could mean for a devil who has no body to burn
  • The difference between your particular judgment at death and the general judgment at the end of time
  • Why death is genuinely abhorrent: the violent separation of body and soul, not just leaving earth
  • Aquinas on why the intellect and will stay fully awake after death even though the senses go dark
  • St. Gregory versus Aquinas on whether merely seeing hellfire is itself the punishment
  • Aquinas's actual argument: fire doesn't cook the soul, it binds it, as an instrument of divine justice
  • Why the fires of hell and purgatory are, per Aquinas, the very same fire
  • The three conditions required for mortal sin, and why hell is always a freely chosen destination
  • The limbo of the fathers, the bosom of Abraham, and Christ emptying it at the Harrowing of Hell
  • The limbo of infants, the 2007 theological commission document, and why it was never defined as dogma
  • Baptism of desire and the "intent of an intent" question for unbaptized infants
  • Dave's case for "limburgatory" against Dante's placement of limbo as an annex of hell
  • Why presuming on God's mercy is itself a sin, and how that shapes the whole limbo debate

REFERENCED IN THIS EPISODE

Books & Writings:

  • Summa Theologiae, Supplement, Questions 69 and 70, by St. Thomas Aquinas (compiled by his students after his death)
  • The Divine Comedy by Dante Alighieri (limbo placed as an annex of hell)
  • Diary: Divine Mercy in My Soul by St. Maria Faustina Kowalska (free on the Amen app)
  • True Devotion to Mary by St. Louis de Montfort (free on the Amen app)
  • Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 1261 (hope for children who die without baptism)
  • The Hope of Salvation for Infants Who Die Without Being Baptized, International Theological Commission, 2007 (approved by Pope Benedict XVI)

Saints & Church Figures:

  • St. Thomas Aquinas
  • St. Gregory (the Great)
  • St. Augustine
  • St. Francis de Sales
  • St. Maria Faustina Kowalska
  • St. Louis de Montfort
  • Pope Benedict XVI
  • Dr. Peter Kreeft (referenced via the Matt Fradd interview clip, and the recent death of his wife of 63 years)

People:

  • Adam Minihan (host; Porter and Prairie Family Farm, Lady Haylee, baby Mary's NICU and eye procedure update, M6 Marketing, The Grounded Builder on Substack)
  • Dave Niles (host; Fecundity Farm, Niles Ranch, Lady Pamela, the corn harvest, coiner of "limburgatory")
  • Lady Haylee (Adam's wife)
  • Lady Pamela (Dave's wife)
  • Matt Fradd (interviewer in the referenced Peter Kreeft clip)

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Catholic Man ShowBy The Catholic Man Show

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

753 ratings


More shows like The Catholic Man Show

View all
Catholic Stuff You Should Know by J. 10 Initiative

Catholic Stuff You Should Know

3,833 Listeners

The Word on Fire Show - Catholic Faith and Culture by Bishop Robert Barron

The Word on Fire Show - Catholic Faith and Culture

5,705 Listeners

Dr Taylor Marshall Podcast by Dr. Taylor Marshall

Dr Taylor Marshall Podcast

4,039 Listeners

The Thomistic Institute by The Thomistic Institute

The Thomistic Institute

809 Listeners

Pints With Aquinas by Matt Fradd

Pints With Aquinas

6,790 Listeners

The Counsel of Trent by Catholic Answers

The Counsel of Trent

2,619 Listeners

Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World by Jimmy Akin

Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World

2,950 Listeners

The Catholic Talk Show by Ryan Scheel, Ryan DellaCrosse, & Fr. Michael Nixon

The Catholic Talk Show

1,516 Listeners

Every Knee Shall Bow (Your Catholic Evangelization Podcast) by Ascension

Every Knee Shall Bow (Your Catholic Evangelization Podcast)

843 Listeners

The Road to Emmaus with Scott Hahn by Scott Hahn

The Road to Emmaus with Scott Hahn

31 Listeners

American Catholic History by Noelle & Tom Crowe

American Catholic History

933 Listeners

Godsplaining by Dominican Friars Province of St. Joseph

Godsplaining

1,287 Listeners

The Catholic Gentleman by John Heinen, Devin Schadt

The Catholic Gentleman

446 Listeners

Catholic Saints by Augustine Institute

Catholic Saints

1,216 Listeners

Chris Stefanick Catholic Show by Chris Stefanick | Real Life Catholic

Chris Stefanick Catholic Show

443 Listeners