Mediawatch

Citizenship celebration turns sour in record time


Listen Later

For 22 years, media stories regularly bemoaned Kiwis treated as second class citizens across the ditch. This week, the problem finally got resolved, only for coverage to turn to fears of a 'Great Exodus' within hours.

For 22 years, media stories regularly bemoaned Kiwis treated as second class citizens across the ditch. This week, the problem finally got resolved, only for coverage to turn to fears of a 'Great Exodus' within hours.​

In November last year 1News correspondent Andrew MacFarlane asked Australian home affairs minister Clare O'Neill why her government was treating New Zealanders as "second-class citizens".

"That's a really good question and that's something that's been bothering me for a long time," she said.

Her frank concession came after years of reports about the perilous legal status of New Zealanders living long-term across the ditch.

They have been denied disability payments, jobseeker support and student loan services in Australia since the introduction of a 2001 law limiting their pathways to citizenship.

That has resulted in hardship and complaints about unequal treatment.

Back in 2011, Kiwis living in Australia were denied government assistance after being caught up in the Queensland floods.

A Stuff story at the time picked up on the plight of Jayde Fuli, who was facing financial ruin due to a lack of assistance from the Australian government.

In 2014, Stuff reported on a sick toddler who was denied healthcare in Australia because his parents were Kiwis, despite him having never set foot in New Zealand.

It also published an investigation on what it called discrimination across the ditch in 2018, highlighting the case of a woman who fell into depression and drug addiction after being unable to access support following the death of her child.

This coverage has been matched in other media, which have consistently called out the Australian government for collecting New Zealanders' taxes but failing to offer them the same rights as other citizens.

Given that, prime minister Chris Hipkins was probably expecting a glowing reception and a run of good press when he stepped up to a media scrum last weekend to announce a new citizenship pathway for Kiwis living in the lucky country.

"It is a very significant day for the trans-Tasman relationship, a very positive day for the relationship between New Zealand and Australia," he said.

There was some positive coverage for the move on the front pages of the Weekend Herald, The Press and The Dominion Post.

But as it turns out, putting an end to a 22-year problem only wins you about six hours of good headlines…

Go to this episode on rnz.co.nz for more details

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

MediawatchBy RNZ

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

4 ratings


More shows like Mediawatch

View all
Saturday Morning by RNZ

Saturday Morning

40 Listeners

Nine To Noon by RNZ

Nine To Noon

20 Listeners

Sunday Morning by RNZ

Sunday Morning

14 Listeners

Focus on Politics by RNZ

Focus on Politics

11 Listeners

Nine To Noon Politics by RNZ

Nine To Noon Politics

1 Listeners

FROM ZERO by RNZ

FROM ZERO

1 Listeners

Go Ahead Caller by RNZ

Go Ahead Caller

1 Listeners

Gone By Lunchtime by The Spinoff

Gone By Lunchtime

23 Listeners

Here Now by RNZ

Here Now

1 Listeners

Slice of Heaven by RNZ

Slice of Heaven

1 Listeners

The Lost by RNZ

The Lost

42 Listeners

Pants on Fire by RNZ

Pants on Fire

102 Listeners

The Science Of… by RNZ

The Science Of…

1 Listeners

The Front Page by NZ Herald

The Front Page

17 Listeners

The Worst Sitcom Ever Made by RNZ

The Worst Sitcom Ever Made

7 Listeners

The Detail by RNZ

The Detail

36 Listeners

Best of Storytime by RNZ

Best of Storytime

2 Listeners

The Fold by The Spinoff

The Fold

3 Listeners

The Citizen's Handbook by RNZ

The Citizen's Handbook

3 Listeners

After the Virus by RNZ

After the Virus

0 Listeners

The Service by RNZ

The Service

31 Listeners

MATA with Mihingarangi Forbes by RNZ

MATA with Mihingarangi Forbes

0 Listeners

Short Story Stack by RNZ

Short Story Stack

0 Listeners

Fight for the Wild by RNZ

Fight for the Wild

4 Listeners

The News Agents by Global

The News Agents

994 Listeners

Deer Wars by RNZ

Deer Wars

3 Listeners

30 with Guyon Espiner by RNZ

30 with Guyon Espiner

16 Listeners

Juggernaut 2: The Story of the Fourth National Government by The Spinoff

Juggernaut 2: The Story of the Fourth National Government

8 Listeners

Voice of Tangaroa by RNZ

Voice of Tangaroa

2 Listeners

Hair and Loathing by TAHI

Hair and Loathing

0 Listeners

Sci Fi / Sci Fact by RNZ

Sci Fi / Sci Fact

3 Listeners

Making Cents by Frances Cook

Making Cents

15 Listeners

The Stolen Children of Aotearoa by RNZ

The Stolen Children of Aotearoa

2 Listeners

No Stupid Questions with Susan Edmunds by RNZ

No Stupid Questions with Susan Edmunds

0 Listeners

Search & Rescue NZ by RNZ

Search & Rescue NZ

2 Listeners