From a dream vacation aboard a Caribbean cruise to a disappearance that has spanned decades, Natalie and Paige unpack Amy Bradley Is Missing, examining the sightings, theories, and haunting questions that still surround her case. They explore the timelines, contradictions, and emotional toll on the Bradley family, and discuss how hope, uncertainty, and media attention have kept this mystery alive for years.

To join in on next week’s conversation, we’re watching The Man with 1,000 Kids on Netflix.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices