On this episode of Criminal Mischief, Carolyn Ossorio revisits some of the most high-profile and disturbing cases she’s covered—bringing listeners up to speed with major developments, fresh audio, and new perspective.

These aren’t rehashes.

These are updates that change the story.

The Gilgo Beach Murders — Rex Heuerman Sentenced

One of the most chilling cases in modern true crime reaches a major milestone.

Carolyn breaks down the sentencing of Rex Heuerman, the alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer, examining what we now know, what remains unanswered, and what this moment means for the victims and their families.

Featuring newly surfaced audio and commentary, this segment explores how a case that lingered for over a decade finally reached this stage—and what may still lie beneath the surface.

Karen Read — Acquitted Again… But Not Finished

After a second acquittal, Karen Read remains at the center of one of the most polarizing cases in recent memory.

But this story isn’t over.

With a civil lawsuit looming, Carolyn examines what comes next—legally, publicly, and personally.

Through new interviews and analysis, this segment explores the divide between courtroom outcomes and public perception, and how a case can evolve even after a verdict is delivered.

Brendan Banfield — Sentenced, But For How Long?

The case of Brendan Banfield takes another turn as sentencing is handed down—but the story is far from settled.

With an appeal already expected, Carolyn unpacks the legal strategy ahead, the potential vulnerabilities in the conviction, and what could come next.

Featuring fresh audio and investigative insight, this segment highlights how even after sentencing, the fight over truth—and outcome—can continue.

A New Layer to Familiar Stories

Each of these cases has been covered before.

But time changes things.

New evidence surfaces.

New voices emerge.

And the story you thought you understood begins to shift.

Listen & Follow

Follow Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts so you never miss an episode.

If you’re enjoying the show, take a moment to rate and review—it helps others discover these stories.

Watch & Subscribe

Full episodes and video content are available on the Evio Creative YouTube channel.Subscribe and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next.

Join the Conversation

Have thoughts on these cases?Tips? Stories we should cover?

📩 [email protected]

Closing

The story doesn’t end with a verdict.

Sometimes—that’s where it really begins.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices