The Highers Brothers: Twenty-Five Years Stolen

In 1987, a Detroit drug dealer was murdered. Within months, two brothers—Tommy and Raymond Highers—were convicted of the crime and sentenced to life in prison without parole. They maintained their innocence from the beginning. More than twenty years later, their convictions would be overturned in a case that exposed serious flaws in eyewitness testimony and the criminal justice system.

This week on Criminal Mischief, Carolyn Ossorio examines one of Michigan’s most extraordinary wrongful conviction cases. The Highers brothers entered prison as teenagers and emerged decades later as middle-aged men, having spent more than 25 years incarcerated for a crime they say they never committed.

Their road to freedom began in an unexpected place: social media. A Facebook conversation led investigators to witnesses whose accounts challenged the prosecution’s original case, setting in motion a legal battle that would ultimately unravel the convictions.

Carolyn explores how eyewitness misidentification, investigative tunnel vision, and the slow pace of justice can alter lives forever. She traces the brothers’ journey from arrest to conviction, through years of appeals, and finally to exoneration—raising difficult questions about accountability, memory, and the cost of wrongful imprisonment.

The Highers case has become a landmark example of how modern technology can aid old investigations and how justice, though delayed, can still prevail. But after decades behind bars, one question remains impossible to answer: How do you compensate someone for twenty-five lost years?

Join Carolyn as she unpacks a story of resilience, redemption, and a justice system forced to confront its own mistakes.

Have thoughts on this case? Email us at [email protected].

Follow Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts, and if you enjoy the show, please leave a rating and review—it helps others discover stories that still demand answers.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices