Financial Planning For Canadian Business Owners

Employee Ownership Trusts with Jon Shell | E108


Listen Later

Jason talks to Jon Shell, the managing director and partner at Social Capital Partners. Jon is an advocate for employee ownership trusts in Canada. The episode discusses what employee ownership trusts are, the benefits they provide to employees, and the challenges faced in implementing them in Canada. The conversation highlights the changes in tax laws related to employee ownership trusts and Canada's first attempt at implementing them. 


Episode Highlights

  • 03:16: Jon Shell explains that the objective of the employee ownership trust structure was to provide access to ownership for those who lacked it in the economy.
  • 05:12: In the UK, the concept of an Employee Ownership Trust (EOT) was established in 2014, allowing companies to allocate profit sharing to all employees and sell the company to employees at no cost. Jon highlights the success of EOTs in the UK, with numerous companies adopting this structure. 
  • 06:20: Jon discusses the comparison between employee ownership trusts and employee share ownership plans or stock option plans.
  • 08:11: Employee cooperatives, or co-ops, are another option in Canada. They involve democratic ownership, where all employees have the right to vote on decision-making processes. 
  • 09:37: There is a well-known example of a massive Spanish company called Mondragon, which operates with a structure similar to Athenian democracy. 
  • 10:49 Jon talks about the incentive for the owner who wants to sell their business to an employee ownership plan.
  • 11:11: In the UK, there was a structure that allowed people to use a leveraged buyout on behalf of employees. 
  • 15:23: For the vast majority of businesses, the concern about gaming the system or preventing certain types of businesses from benefiting doesn't hold true. Most businesses do not fall into the category of high-end consulting firms where only the wealthy benefit. 


3 Key Points

  1. Jon shares the success story of the employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) in the US, which has grown to include 6,500 companies and 14 million American workers.
  2. Jon explains how co-ops can be effective forms of employee ownership, but they are typically applied to smaller firms.
  3. The lack of tax incentives beyond deferral is a significant drawback. It creates a situation where there is no real incentive for owners to consider employee ownership beyond personal benevolence.


Tweetable Quotes

  • "Employees get access to shares at a certain price and can exercise them later to participate in the company's growth." - Jon
  • "For larger companies with hierarchical structures, owners may be concerned about the risks associated with selling to a co-op, especially if the company has not operated in that manner before. Co-ops can be effective forms of employee ownership, but they are typically applied to smaller firms." - Jon
  • "Setting up a worker co-op with more traditional governance and committees can be burdensome and costly. In larger companies, it may be challenging for employees to afford the shares necessary to buy the company." – Jon


Resources Mentioned

  • Facebook – Jason Pereira's Facebook
  • LinkedIn – Jason Pereira's LinkedIn


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Financial Planning For Canadian Business OwnersBy Jason Pereira


More shows like Financial Planning For Canadian Business Owners

View all
Motley Fool Money by The Motley Fool

Motley Fool Money

3,198 Listeners

Build Wealth Canada Podcast by Kornel Szrejber: Investor

Build Wealth Canada Podcast

17 Listeners

Animal Spirits Podcast by The Compound

Animal Spirits Podcast

1,993 Listeners

The Rational Reminder Podcast by Benjamin Felix, Cameron Passmore, Mark McGrath, and Dan Bortolotti

The Rational Reminder Podcast

419 Listeners

The Compound and Friends by The Compound

The Compound and Friends

2,033 Listeners

The Long View by Morningstar

The Long View

848 Listeners

Kitces and Carl - Real Talk for Real Financial Advisors by Michael Kitces, MSFS, MTAX, CFP and Carl Richards, CFP

Kitces and Carl - Real Talk for Real Financial Advisors

230 Listeners

The Canadian Investor by Braden Dennis & Simon Belanger

The Canadian Investor

84 Listeners

Ask The Compound by The Compound

Ask The Compound

297 Listeners

The Loonie Hour by Steve Saretsky

The Loonie Hour

10 Listeners

The Canadian Real Estate Investor by Daniel Foch & Nick Hill

The Canadian Real Estate Investor

7 Listeners

Angry Mortgage by Ron Butler

Angry Mortgage

4 Listeners

The Morgan Housel Podcast by Morgan Housel

The Morgan Housel Podcast

944 Listeners

Prof G Markets by Vox Media Podcast Network

Prof G Markets

803 Listeners

The Wealthy Barber Podcast by The Wealthy Barber Inc.

The Wealthy Barber Podcast

36 Listeners