Did Christopher actually go on a beach vacation with Gianni Versace's killer?! Is that why the FBI stormed Anne Rice's Garden District mansion in 1999? Eric won't stop until they've served up every detail of this way-too-close-to-home edition of True Crime TV Club. Only without the TV. Plus a whole lot of sarongs. And green Lexuses. (Lexi?) And, of course, gay dance parties. Together, Christopher and Eric feast on the Rice family's near brush with Andrew Cunanan's dark legacy, also tackling the question of what it means for gay people when notorious gay criminals get caught up in headlines around the world. Along the way, wealthy sugar daddies and 'American Crime Story' get served.