Elucidations

Episode 138: Toby Buckle discusses Mill's liberty principle


Listen Later

This month, Toby Buckle, host of the Political Philosophy Podcast, returns to talk about John Stuart Mill’s liberty principle!


(Also sometimes called the ‘harm principle’.)


The occasion for the episode is the recent release of Toby’s cool new book, What is Freedom?, which is out now from Oxford University Press. Get it while it’s hot!


John Stuart Mill is probably one of the most influential intellectuals of the 19th century, having penned treatises on markets, logic, feminism, utilitarianism, and freedom of speech that people continue to pick up and read today. In this episode, we talk about how he had one foot in the free market-oriented tradition of liberalism and another in the more social justice-oriented type of liberalism, how he was raised under the world’s most ambitious parenting/education regime, and how he had a lifelong collaboration with Harriet Taylor. We also introduce what gets called his ‘liberty princple’.


The idea behind the liberty principle is that we want as much freedom for each person as possible: they should have the ability to set their own agenda and carry it out. But we also need to limit it somewhat, because if everyone was completely unconstrained in how they set their agenda and carried it out, they’d interfere with each other. We’d have one person’s freedom detracting from other people’s freedom. So in order to achieve the perfect equilibrium we want, the thing to do is aim for sort of a greatest lower bound: every person should be allowed to do whatever they want for whatever reason they want, only stopping shy once they reach the point where doing whatever they want would harm another person. It might seem like an obvious principle to us now, but arguably that’s because we’re all living in the shadow of Mill!


Part of the background context for this principle is a worry about paternalism. There’s a natural tendency for Person A to prevent Person B from doing what they want because Person A thinks it’s obvious that what Person B wants to do right now is harmful to them. The liberty principle tells us that that’s not a good reason to have laws prohibiting some course of action. We should only have a law prohibiting some course of action if allowing that course of action would interfere with other people’s freedom. That way, Mill argued, we keep the decision about whether to pass a law prohibiting something grounded in empirical facts about what would actually happen if it were passed. He also wanted to emphasize that each person has the right to be their own arbiter of what kinds of risk they will assume.


I hope you enjoy our discussion! It was a fun one.


Further Reading


If you’d like to hear more along the lines of what Toby and I discuss in this episode, you can do no better than to take a look at Mill’s exquisite On Liberty, which you can get for free here:

https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/34901


And if you missed the link up at the top, definitely check out Toby’s edited volume, which gathers together a number of the interviews from his own podcast. The overarching theme is what freedom is and what it can be.


What is Freedom?: Conversations with Historians, Philosophers, and Activists, Toby Buckle


Happy reading!

Matt Teichman

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

ElucidationsBy Matt Teichman

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

163 ratings


More shows like Elucidations

View all
In Our Time by BBC Radio 4

In Our Time

5,389 Listeners

University of Chicago Human Rights Program Distinguished Lecturer Series by The University of Chicago Human Rights Program

University of Chicago Human Rights Program Distinguished Lecturer Series

1 Listeners

The Latin American Briefing Series by The University of Chicago Center for Latin American Studies

The Latin American Briefing Series

6 Listeners

Philosopher's Zone by ABC listen

Philosopher's Zone

207 Listeners

CHIASMOS: The University of Chicago International and Area Studies Multimedia Outreach Source [video] by The Center for International Studies at the University of Chicago

CHIASMOS: The University of Chicago International and Area Studies Multimedia Outreach Source [video]

1 Listeners

CHIASMOS: The University of Chicago International and Area Studies Multimedia Outreach Source [audio] by The Center for International Studies at the University of Chicago

CHIASMOS: The University of Chicago International and Area Studies Multimedia Outreach Source [audio]

5 Listeners

The University of Chicago Law School Faculty Podcast by UChicagoLaw

The University of Chicago Law School Faculty Podcast

48 Listeners

Freakonomics Radio by Freakonomics Radio + Stitcher

Freakonomics Radio

32,283 Listeners

99% Invisible by Roman Mars

99% Invisible

26,162 Listeners

History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps by Peter Adamson

History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps

1,590 Listeners

Philosophize This! by Stephen West

Philosophize This!

15,093 Listeners

Conversations with Tyler by Mercatus Center at George Mason University

Conversations with Tyler

2,395 Listeners

University of Chicago Booth School of Business Podcast Series by The University of Chicago Booth School of Business

University of Chicago Booth School of Business Podcast Series

6 Listeners

Philosophy For Our Times by IAI

Philosophy For Our Times

304 Listeners

Capitalisn't by University of Chicago Podcast Network

Capitalisn't

526 Listeners

Sean Carroll's Mindscape: Science, Society, Philosophy, Culture, Arts, and Ideas by Sean Carroll | Wondery

Sean Carroll's Mindscape: Science, Society, Philosophy, Culture, Arts, and Ideas

4,142 Listeners

Within Reason by Alex J O'Connor

Within Reason

1,547 Listeners

Hard Fork by The New York Times

Hard Fork

5,462 Listeners

The Rest Is History by Goalhanger

The Rest Is History

13,053 Listeners

Misquoting Jesus with Bart Ehrman by Bart Ehrman

Misquoting Jesus with Bart Ehrman

605 Listeners

The Rest Is Politics: Leading by Goalhanger

The Rest Is Politics: Leading

989 Listeners