Which four athletes would make up your Mount Rushmore? More importantly, why did they make the list? Following up on their Mount Rushmore: Coaches conversation, Drs Cory Shaffer and Katie Nichols share their all-time athlete lists and the criteria for how they made the cut. This is a great exercise that you can do with your group or team to learn more about each other and engage in some healthy debate over who is most deserving to be carved in stone.