Questioning Medicine

Episode 389: 400. CRP, Lipoprotein A, LDL for cardiac risk assessment


Listen Later

https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2405182?query=recirc_Semantic

 

 

Key Takeaways

  1. Extended Predictive Value of Biomarkers:
    • High-sensitivity C-reactive protein (CRP), LDL cholesterol, and lipoprotein(a) levels were found to be predictive of cardiovascular events over a 30-year period.
    • These markers contribute independently to long-term cardiovascular risk beyond traditional 10-year risk estimates.
    • Study Design and Population:
      • The study enrolled 27,939 initially healthy U.S. women who were followed for 30 years.
      • The primary endpoint was the occurrence of a first major adverse cardiovascular event, including myocardial infarction, coronary revascularization, stroke, or death from cardiovascular causes.
      • Predictive Strength of Biomarkers:
        • Among the biomarkers, high-sensitivity CRP showed the strongest association with future cardiovascular events (hazard ratio for top quintile: 1.70).
        • LDL cholesterol and lipoprotein(a) also significantly predicted risk, albeit to a slightly lower degree (hazard ratios: 1.36 and 1.33, respectively).  NOT STATIN WITH CRP
        • Implications for Clinical Practice:
          • Combining all three biomarkers may offer the best method for identifying high-risk individuals who might benefit from early intervention.   YOU HAVE TO PROSPECTIVELY VALIDATE THIS
          • The study supports extending cardiovascular prevention strategies beyond traditional risk assessments.
          • Lifestyle and pharmacologic interventions should target multiple pathways, including lipid levels and inflammation.

          • Key Limitations

            1. Study Population:
              • The study cohort predominantly consisted of female health professionals who are mostly White (94%), which may limit generalizability.
              • The results may not extend to males or more diverse populations without further studies.
              • Absence of Repeated Measures:
                • Biomarkers were measured only at baseline without repeated measures over time.
                • This limits the ability to observe changes in biomarker levels and their association with risk over time.
                • Statin Use Data:
                  • Increasing use of statins over the study period was not thoroughly considered in initial analyses, and detailed data on adherence and duration are lacking.
                  • Sensitivity analyses attempted to account for this by censoring data at the time of first statin prescription, but residual confounding may be present.
                  • Concerns with Study Design

                    1. Cohort Composition:
                      • The study's focus on health professionals might have led to better access to healthcare and healthier lifestyle choices, potentially skewing outcomes.
                      • Non-White participants were underrepresented, raising concerns about the applicability of findings to more diverse groups.
                      • Single Time Point Measurement:
                        • Only baseline biomarker levels were used for long-term prediction, which may not account for variability and changes in risk factors over time.


                        ...more
                        View all episodesView all episodes
                        Download on the App Store

                        Questioning MedicineBy Questioning Medicine

                        • 4.9
                        • 4.9
                        • 4.9
                        • 4.9
                        • 4.9

                        4.9

                        73 ratings


                        More shows like Questioning Medicine

                        View all
                        This American Life by This American Life

                        This American Life

                        90,396 Listeners

                        The Foreign Desk by Monocle

                        The Foreign Desk

                        117 Listeners

                        JAMA Clinical Reviews by JAMA Network

                        JAMA Clinical Reviews

                        502 Listeners

                        AFP: American Family Physician Podcast by American Academy of Family Physicians

                        AFP: American Family Physician Podcast

                        694 Listeners

                        The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast by Dr. Jordan B. Peterson

                        The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast

                        33,947 Listeners

                        White Coat Investor Podcast by Dr. Jim Dahle of the White Coat Investor

                        White Coat Investor Podcast

                        2,427 Listeners

                        The Curbsiders Internal Medicine Podcast by The Curbsiders Internal Medicine Podcast

                        The Curbsiders Internal Medicine Podcast

                        3,333 Listeners

                        The Daily by The New York Times

                        The Daily

                        111,088 Listeners

                        Up First from NPR by NPR

                        Up First from NPR

                        56,011 Listeners

                        Consider This from NPR by NPR

                        Consider This from NPR

                        6,005 Listeners

                        Huberman Lab by Scicomm Media

                        Huberman Lab

                        28,636 Listeners

                        The Ezra Klein Show by New York Times Opinion

                        The Ezra Klein Show

                        15,503 Listeners

                        The Money with Katie Show by Morning Brew

                        The Money with Katie Show

                        1,490 Listeners

                        The Retrievals by Serial Productions & The New York Times

                        The Retrievals

                        10,767 Listeners

                        The Rest Is Politics: US by Goalhanger

                        The Rest Is Politics: US

                        2,210 Listeners