Financial Autonomy

Financial Autonomy

By Guidance Financial Services: Investing & Retirement Planning ExpertsBusinessEducationSelf-ImprovementInvesting
Download on the App Store
  • Favorites

    39

    Followers

  • Typical duration

    12 min

    per episode

Based on Podcast App listening data

Financial Autonomy episodes

  • Mike Lewis - When to Jump - Episode 60

    Episode 60 – Mike Lewis - When to Jump

    Today in the episode, we interview the author of When To Jump, Mike Lewis. The book is about career change or starting your own business.

    In this interview we cover:

    • Mike's jump to being a professional sportsman
    • His job and career before he became a sportsman
    • Events that unfolded and didn't go to plan when he left his career
    • Framework: Jump Curves - 4 phases of taking a jump
    • What made him decide to keep going
    • Mike's 2nd jump of writing the book When to Jump and how it unfolded
    • How he strategized and made it happen
    • When he started this idea
    • Learnings from his jumps
    • Details and overview about the book and its contents, including a sample case study
    • Mike's sense of things from the people he talks to
    • The importance of planning in making a career change
    • Mike's plans for the next year or two.

    Links mentioned in the show

    When to Jump Podcast

    When to Jump Instagram

    When to Jump Facebook

    When to Jump Twitter

    Mike Lewis LinkedIn

    27 min
  • The Beauty of the Worst Case - Episode 59

    Episode 59 – The Beauty of the Worst Case

    Do you remember those Worst Case Scenario Survival Handbooks that were around everywhere about a decade ago? How to land a light aircraft if the pilot has a heart attack, or how to survive a bear attack. I don't know if they extended to surviving a zombie apocalypse, but I wouldn't be surprised if they did. They were good fun reads and made a great Christmas present.

    In today's episode we're going to explore how planning for the worst case can be liberating. How it can melt the ice that has you trapped in your current state.

    And the best bit? It's not hard – just two easy steps.

    Planning for the worst case is a key tool in enabling you to gain the choices in life that you deserve. So let's dive into today's Financial Autonomy episode – The Beauty of the Worst Case.

    When investing, we know from history that the best investment returns come from growth assets – shares and property.

    Why then don't investors have all their money, 100%, in shares and property? Why diversify and hold things like bonds?

    The answer is that whilst we always hope for the best, a wise person plans for the worst.

    Planning for the worst case is something that's common across government agencies and businesses. The Emergency Services for instance will plan out their response to a large bush fire or flood. A bank might develop a plan to handle a significant global disruption to financial markets. Or a pharmaceutical company might have a plan for dealing with an extortionist tampering with their products.

    So how can you use this proven process to help you achieve your Financial Autonomy goals?

    Step 1 is to acknowledge your fears and define them. If your Financial Autonomy dream it to make a career change, like we heard from Tim in episode 55, then perhaps your worst case scenario is that you quit your current job and can't break into the new career that you dream of. That's a totally reasonable fear. And for many of us, that fear is enough to stop us moving forward. It's paralysing.

    Now one solution to overcoming this paralysis would be to just try and push it out of your mind – the "be positive, it'll never happen to me" approach. Having a positive mindset is certainly important in leading a happy and fulfilling life. But to achieve big changes, we need more.

    So on a piece of paper, or my preferred method, a white board, write down your worst case. What's your greatest fear in embarking on your Financial Autonomy goal? Perhaps there's more than one.

    There's some relief in achieving this step alone, in acknowledging your fears.

    But of course we're only half done. Now that you've defined your worst case, in step 2 we need solutions. So it's brain storming time! If you feel comfortable, perhaps you could invite others in to join you to get some fresh ideas.

    Imagine what you would do if your worst case actually happened. Write down your solutions. Now this is not your preferred outcome, and it's also not the most likely outcome either. So therefore your response are likely to be things you'd prefer not to have to do. But the point is they are things you could do if you had to.

    If the career change didn't work out, could you go back to your old career? If the new business you started just wasn't delivering what you needed it to, could you get your old job back? What if you took a year off to travel with your partner, and half way through the trip decided you couldn't stand one another and went your separate ways. Would you fly home, or continue the journey solo?

    When I made my big jump from employee to self-employed in 2006, I had 8 months of income saved up. That was my runway. If it didn't work out, I had to go and find another job. That was how I dealt with my worst case scenario. And with that in mind, I ensured that before I left I did what I could to strengthen my professional networks, and I made sure I finished up on good terms, so that if I needed a reference or a simple connection in the future, people would answer my call.

    I also considered where I was at professionally and how employable I'd be. I felt that given my experience at that point, and some of the successes that I'd had, I would be able to secure another employee role if it came to that.

    Now fortunately it never did come to that. But acknowledging my greatest fear – what if this just doesn't work out – and having a solution to that, was enormously powerful in providing me with the confidence to make the leap.

    If you take nothing else away from this post, take this – planning for your worst case is enormously empowering.

    I've found it so useful that I'm implementing it into more and more of what I do. When I develop my yearly business goals, I now also list some worst case scenarios and how I'd deal with them.

    We'll be introducing an affordable financial modelling solution in the near future so that you can get a robust answer to the "am I crazy to do this?" question. As part of that we typically explore two worst case scenarios – both involving adverse investment market outcomes, to see what impact that would have on your plans. Adding these worst case scenarios magnifies the usefulness of the work enormously.

    Imagine your Financial Autonomy goal is to retire at 50. We build a financial model to show you how that looks over the long term, and the findings are that your goal is possible. Now we could stop there. But how much more powerful does the modelling exercise become if we also add in how it looks if you were unlucky enough to suffer a share market crash in the first year of your retirement? (Refer Ep 38 – Will my money run out? To see why this is a particularly bad outcome).

    If the modelling shows that your goals remain viable – awesome! But if instead it highlights a potential problem, you can start planning solutions. Perhaps you change your asset allocation in those initial years so you don't have too much share market exposure. Or you figure in picking up some part time work so you can give your savings time to re-build.

    Whatever the solution, planning for the worst case enables you to move forward with greater confidence.

    There will always be uncertainty in life. And for many of us, it's this uncertainty that prevents us from taking the big steps that we'd like to make. Planning for the worst case could be the way for you leap over your uncertainty barrier.

    9 min
  • Investment basics - Active vs Passive investment – what's it about and, our approach - Episode 58

    When I started my career in investment markets almost 20 years ago all the investment options were what we'd now call Active. We didn't call them that at the time, it was just the standard way that money was managed.

    Passive investment had been around for some time, pushed primarily by John Boggle of Vanguard which first launched a passive index fund in 1975. But it took quite a while for enough data to come in, for investors to begin to appreciate why some hard questions needed to be asked about the focus on Active investment management.

    In more recent times the trend has swung in favour of the passive approach, and variations of that process, with ETF's (Exchange Traded Funds) driving broad adoption.

    The increased acceptance and utilisation of passive investment strategies is almost certainly the biggest shift in investment strategy thinking since managed funds kicked off in Australia in 1955.

    So in today's episode I'll be sharing with you the difference between these two approaches, and how we apply these alternatives when helping our financial planning clients.

    As mentioned, Vanguard is the best known proponent of passive, or index investing, though interestingly Blackrock is bigger.

    The idea of passive investment is that instead of trying to do research on different companies and identify winners, you simply buy the whole market. The thinking is that if you do this, you should get the average return of all investors. So let's say you're buying an index fund over the ASX200 – the index of Australia's 200 largest companies. If the ASX200 grew by 5% one year, then that tells you that across all of the investors in that market, half did better and half did worse, and the average came in at 5%.

    So if you invest in a passive index fund over the ASX200, you will get the average return, 5% in this example, less whatever fees the fund manager charges.

    Now compare this to the Active manager. Their entire rationale is to beat the market. If the average is 5%, their entire rationale for existence is that by doing all sorts of research and analysis, they can identify insights others have missed, and so deliver superior performance compared to the rest of the market.

    Now the astute Financial Autonomy audience will immediately identify that given the mathematical foundation of an average is that half of all results will be below, and half will be above, then clearly, not all active fund managers can be successful. Now it is fair to say that not all participants in investment markets are fund managers, there are of course mum and dad investors too, but by far the bulk of trade is conducted by the funds.

    And so we arrive at the number one challenge when working with active fund managers – what if you choose one that under-performs?

    But in actual fact, it gets even harder, because not only does the successful active fund manager need to beat the index, but they need to do it after their fees, or at least the difference in their fees versus a passive index alternative. And active fund managers tend to like to pay themselves a lot. So beating the average by say half a percent, won't cut it if the fund charges 1% to manage the money in the first place.

    So what do the numbers tell us? In data to the end of 2017 (SPIVA Statistics and Reports), when measured over 5 years, only 37% of active funds outperformed the benchmark, and in the US it was even worse with only 16% achieving what they'd set out to do.

    To put it another way, if you have some money to invest and you're trying to pick an active fund manager in Australia, there's a 63% likelihood that you'll pick the wrong fund and get under-performance. And in fact that number might be generous due to something called survivorship bias – funds that perform really badly close, and so they don't register in the data.

    Now to be fair, index managers underperform the benchmark too because of their fees. But because they don't need to employ overpaid fund managers, their fees are really low. You can buy an index fund over the Australian share market for a cost of about 0.14%, and over the US market for an incredibly low 0.04%!

    I thought this quote from Brian Portnoy author of The Geometry of Wealth summed things up well: "Beating the market. That's a silly and fruitless game. It's not tied to your real needs. It's attached to your ego."

    Tying your investment decisions back to your needs, or goals is really important. You've got a goal, let's say that's to buy 5 acres out of town and grow your own food. To make that a reality you determine a dollar amount that you need to save up to enable the purchase. Now of course you could just chip away putting your savings in a bank account until it builds to the necessary amount, but it's likely to be smarter to invest your savings and let compounding of returns do some of the work for you.

    A lot of what we do for clients is financial modelling to ascertain how their goals can be met. So for instance we might find that, given your existing financial position and capacity to save, you could achieve your goal in 6 years, assuming your investment earn an average of 7%.

    If you then embark on that journey, you want to have a high level of confidence that your investments will indeed earn 7%. A portfolio would be constructed to gain you adequate diversification and minimise risk. Now you could choose as part of the portfolio to employ active managers, in the hope they will do better than the market, and so, deliver to you higher returns than you'd assumed so that you reach your goal sooner. It's certainly tempting.

    But let's revisit the data. 63% of Australian active funds and 84% of US active funds fail to beat the benchmark after fees. So is that a bet worth taking?

    My preference would be to do whatever we possibly can ensure your goal is met, and that means having the highest confidence possible as to what the investment outcome will be. All investments involve risk, and returns are never guaranteed. But I know that if I invest in a passive index fund, I'll get pretty close to the market return. And I know what on average that return will be, so that over a 6 year time frame, as is the case in this example, I can embark on the strategy with a high degree of confidence that in 6 years' time I'll have the funds needed to buy my little farmlet.

    Now I should just pause here a moment and flag that I'm not totally of the view that all active management is a waste of money. We have many clients who've chosen to incorporate ethical considerations into their portfolio, and specialist fund managers, particularly with a focus on sustainability have delivered some great results that have indeed exceeded benchmarks on a consistent basis.

    There has also been some evidence to indicate that in the Australian small company space, active management might add value. Here many of the participants are day traders and simple punters, and so there does seem to be profits available to investors by employing fund managers to go out and research less well known business, and then sifting the wheat from the chaff.

    As the weight of money has moved from active management to passive over the years, active managers have responded, producing strategies to improve portfolio diversification and complement other passive holdings.

    There's another interesting wrinkle in this discussion of passive vs active investing, and that is investor behaviour.

    There's great data out of the US produced by Dalbar which compares the market return, which is what a passive index investment will deliver, to the return that the average investor actually experienced.

    Over 20 years to the end of 2016 (the most recent data I could find). The S&P500 index returned 7.7%. However the average fund investor achieved returns of 4.8%, a difference of almost 3%. Over 20 years that is huge! To put some dollars around that, $100,000 invested at 7.7% grows to $440,000 in 20 years, whereas if you earn the lower 4.8%, your $100,000 gets to a much lower $255,000.

    So what's going on? The main answer is that investors jump in and out at the wrong time. They tend to get in after markets have had a few good years, and then they tend to get out when markets drop. To get the average market return therefore they needed to do 2 important things:

    1. Invest so that your money tracks the index, which is most easily done with an index fund
    2. Leave your investment alone – all the evidence suggests that investors who try and time the market fail, and as shown in the numbers just mentioned, the impact is not minor.

    So armed with this knowledge, how do we tackle things at Guidance, my financial planning practice? We don't have a one size fits all approach, however our starting point is to use index solutions such as ETF's, and then add in active management only where there is a specific strategy requirement.

    A solution that we use a lot is model portfolios built using entirely index funds, but with an overlay as to the allocation across the sectors, eg. Australian vs International shares vs Property. Once a year the model manager, a large US based global institution, conducts a detailed review of market and economic conditions, and rebalances the asset allocations within certain band limits to reflect what they see. They'll never be all in Australian shares, or hold none at all, but depending on their assessment, they might tilt allocations 3 or 4% in one way or the other. They've been running models this way for over 30 years and their performance has been enough to cover fees and deliver a slight out-performance against the market benchmarks. Given our job is to help our clients achieve their goals, this is the outcome we want delivered. The more certain the outcome, the better.

    Important Information:

    This information is of a general nature only and has been prepared without taking into account your particular financial needs, circumstances and objectives. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information, it is not guaranteed. You should obtain professional advice before acting on the information contained in this publication.

    13 min
  • 4 Hour Work Week – still relevant today? - Episode 57

    Episode 57 – 4 Hour Work Week – still relevant today?

    Originally published in 2007, The 4 Hour Work Week by Tim Ferriss, made some huge waves upon its release. It also laid foundations for its author that continue to this day. Indeed anyone who's ever browsed the iTunes podcast charts will have come across Tim Ferriss, whose self-named show is regularly towards the top.

    As regular readers and listeners know, the reason Financial Autonomy exists is to explore how we can all gain choice in our lives. Without doubt The 4 Hour Work Week aims to deliver the same, albeit with a quite specific formula for success.

    Now I have to confess that I didn't pick up the book when it came out. I can't recall exactly when I became aware of it, but it was a bit like a movie everyone was talking about – I kind of felt I knew all the best bits, and with all the hype, I just couldn't find the enthusiasm.

    11 years on and with the hype having faded, I thought it was time to right that wrong.

    The first thing you need to know is that - despite the title, this book really isn't about only working 4 hours per week. In fact nowhere in it does Tim say that's all he does, and indeed I've read interviews with him where he fully acknowledges that he works more hours than that.

    So don't read this book if that is your sole goal.

    The sub-title – Escape the 9-5, Live Anywhere, and Join the New Rich, is actually much more what The 4 Hour Work Week is all about.

    The other thing, which is where I got the wrong impression when it was released, is that it's not all about outsourcing everything to India. Sure, that's an important element, but it's not the whole book

    I was really pleased to find that The 4 Hour Work Week is a really well written and engaging book. An extremely common frustration I find with many thought-leader type books is that the Big Idea could have been summarised in a 5 page essay, but since you can't make money with a 5 page essay, they've padded it out into a book.

    That is certainly not the case here - the book is well structured, and the ideas are consistent throughout. I didn't feel like there was any padding. There were elements in the middle where I felt he wasn't talking my language, but I continued anyway and found value in latter chapters.

    It's probably worth explaining the basic structure of the book. There are 4 key elements, broken up into steps:

    Definition

    Elimination

    Automation

    Liberation

    The first, Definition is where he explains his New Rich concept and challenges some common assumptions.

    Elimination is essentially about productivity – getting more done in less time.

    Automation explores how you might generate income with minimal personal effort – unquestionably the section I had the most difficulty with.

    And finally Liberation – mini-retirement, travel, and flexibility – very much in our Financial Autonomy wheelhouse.

    If you think in terms of a Venn diagram, you know, where there are the two circles that overlap in the middle, and one circle is the things Tim espouses in this book, and the other circle contains the ideas and dreams of the Financial Autonomy community, there is definitely significant overlap.

    The idea of "wealth" not being defined purely by your balance sheet, but rather with reference to the life you can lead, certainly aligned.

    Where 4 Hour Work Week didn't resonate for me though was in 2 primary elements:

    1. It seemed a recipe for a single person. Success in the approach espoused equalled lots of living abroad, nomadic style. Now I love to travel and am a keen learner, but as someone with kids, first I have an obligation to ensure they get a good education and upbringing. And whilst travel can be an important element of that, professional teachers laying solid foundations are irreplaceable. I also take the view that there's 15-20 years in my life where I get to enjoy their growing up, and hopefully provide a positive influence in their lives. Traveling to Buenos Aires to learn Latin dancing doesn't fit into this picture. My kids want to catch-up with friends, play sport and engage in their other interests. The definition of success in 4 Hour Work Week didn't really seem to allow for that.
    2. The other element that jarred for me was that the suggested enabler was building a business that largely runs on auto-pilot with the use of outsourcing staff from India and the likes. If only building a successful business was that easy! I know from the emails that I receive from you guys, that many of you are entrepreneurially inclined. I also know that finding that viable business idea and making it work is really hard. To then overlay on that the ability to outsource its operation, is something that I would think few could pull off successfully. It's possible, no doubt about it, but as a template for others to follow, I'm just not convinced. Indeed the very fact this concept has been around for so long, and yet so few people do it successfully, would seem to prove this point. I also think it fails to recognise that many of us enjoy the income producing work that we do. Whether it's working as part of a team, developing creative solutions, helping people live better lives, or the challenge of beating a competitor – our work provides purpose, satisfaction, and yes, enjoyment. Who hasn't had a glass of wine or a beer at the end of big week and felt, "yeah, I kicked some goals this week"? This idea that all paid work is horrible is a falsehood.

    So that's the issues I had with 4 Hour Work Week. But did that mean reading this book was a waste of my time? Not at all.

    Was it life changing? No.

    But have I taken action as a result of reading it (since after all, if no action is taken, what's the point)? Yes.

    The immediate action I've taken is to better manage my emails which have been consuming a lot of my day, and getting unjustified priority at times. I've automated a lot of what happens with my incoming emails, and set-up a few templates to speed up some responses. I'm also experimenting with only actioning emails at certain times of day. I haven't perfected things, but Tim's book certainly caused me to pause, reflect, and make changes.

    The version I bought was the expanded and updated edition published in 2009. The elements that I gather have been added are certainly good, and if you have the choice, I'd certainly encourage you to get this version over the original.

    There's a section towards the end titled "Living the 4 hour work week" - case studies, tips, and hacks which I thought was great. You may even want to read that first, then decide if you want to invest the time into consuming the whole book.

    I also thought the blog post section contained some really useful thoughts.

    I'm no fan-boy of Tim Ferriss, so I have no idea if he's living a happy and fulfilled life. But the little I do know suggests he's succeeded in gaining choice in his life, and so for that I admire him, and I thank him for writing The 4 Hour Work Week – I certainly think this book makes a positive contribution to the potential that exists for all of us in the 21st century.

    I'm sure many in the Financial Autonomy community have read 4 Hour Work Week – what did you think? Let me know on the Financial Autonomy Facebook page, or via email from our web site.

    Also, if you're a Twitter user, my Twitter handle is @Paul_Benson11 so feel free to connect their.

    Click here for the Mini Retirement Planning Checklist

    10 min
  • Are you playing offence or defence? - Episode 56

    Episode 56 – Are you playing offence or defence?

    Today in the episode, we talk to Tim Lavrey's career change story from being a bank manager to a preschool teacher.

    All sports have elements of offensive and defensive play. And whether you play Netball, soccer, cricket or basketball, your team must constantly strike a balance between the two.

    In pursuing your Financial Autonomy goal, you too must find a balance that will see your goals achieved in an acceptable time frame, whilst also enabling you to sleep at night, and not put you and your family at risk of living on the street.

    But whilst in sport the distinction between offence and defence if fairly clear, in the financial world, it may be less so. So in today's episode where going to explore your options, so that as you develop your Financial Autonomy strategy, you're considering both offence and defence, and finding a balance that makes sense for you.

    Offensive moves are typically attacking type moves. They're trying to make something happen in your favour. They're pro-active decisions or tactics that you are employing to make progress towards your goal.

    Defensive moves are concerned with protecting what you've got, not going backwards or giving up ground.

    Playing offence is often more glamorous, and for sporting spectators, more spectacular. But any coach will know that a solid defence is essential if your team is to experience sustained success.

    Your strategy to achieve Financial Autonomy will require both offensive and defensive tactics. You need to take pro-active steps – offence – if your goals are to be met. But that doesn't mean it's wise to ignore the important defensive measures to protect on the downside. Without defence, all that you gain in offence could be given up.

    Let's start by considering what playing offence might look like in a financial sense.

    A good starting point would be to have an emergency fund set-up to cover unexpected expenses like the fridge deciding it's had enough, or unplanned medical expenses. For most people, having something like $5,000 stashed away would tick this box. The alternative, that leads all too many people towards financial peril, is that when these type of events crop up, they hit the credit card, with no plan on how this will be quickly cleared.

    Your next offensive play is to educate yourself on investment and money. Now given you're consuming this post right now, I appreciate I'm preaching to the converted here. You don't need to become an expert, but having a basic understanding of investment options, from term deposits to shares, property and funds, and a sense of the risk in each, will arm you well when developing your strategy.

    It sounds obvious and is perhaps a bit of a cliché, but a foundational offensive play in a financial autonomy context is to spend less than you earn. This requires management of your cash flow and knowledge of what is affordable. I've come across several instances in recent years where people have signed up to rent a home, without appreciating that once they pay that rent, they simply won't have enough money left to live off. They just don't seem to have done the numbers and realised that the rent is perhaps 50% of their take home pay, a level that would be unsustainable for pretty much anybody.

    Let's start to stretch the legs a bit now – it's time to start building some wealth. We all need a roof over our head and food to eat. And since the days of living in a cave and hunting for your dinner are well behind us, you're going to need money.

    You're currently earning money through your skills and knowledge, and whilst your ability to generate income is unquestionably of enormous value, it has its vulnerabilities and limitations – for one you have to get the work done in order to earn the income, but also there is the risk of your skills becoming obsolete or just less valued, you suffer an injury, or simply old age slowing you down to the point where income generation is no longer possible.

    Owning a home and/or owning income generating assets is essential for you to achieve financial autonomy and gain the sort of life choices that you seek. And the starting point to building wealth is to save. You don't wake up one morning and have $100,000 in your investment portfolio – it starts with that first $100 saved and invested. So play offence with your money and invest. It needn't be huge amounts to being with, but make a start.

    Improving your income generating skills is also a great offensive play. Deeping or widening your professional knowledge can see your income rise, enabling a higher rate of saving and investment to build wealth. Improved skills also make you more employable, enhancing your overall financial resiliency.

    So think about what sort of training or experiences you could undertake that would increase your value to an employer, or if self-employed, enable you to increase your hourly rate.

    And my final financial offensive move is to make an active choice as to how your superannuation is invested. I'm not talking about which super fund so much, but more which investment option. There will be a default, and that may well be the right option for you. But don't just assume that it is. Look into it, consider your time frame to retirement, and your comfort with volatility. (A hint here, if retirement is a long way off, volatility is your friend).

    Make an active choice that fits with your plans.

    Now I do like the theory that the best form of defence is a good offence. But that doesn't mean there's not room for a couple of sound financial defensive tactics.

    The first is to pay down debt. Debt is not a bad thing when used to buy assets that grow in value, but there's no question that debt makes you vulnerable. Compare the scenario of two people who are made redundant. The first has a $500,000 mortgage over their home, whilst the other has paid off their home and owns it outright. Neither person is likely to be pleased about being made redundant, but it's a fair bet that the person with the mortgage is a lot more stressed than the person who owns their home.

    Start with your most expensive debt and work your way down. Tax deductable debt, such as that used to buy an investment, may be the final debt that you tackle, but of course you'd need to run the numbers there.

    When it comes to defensive moves, the other fundamental element is insurance.

    Now I fully appreciate that it's hard to get excited about paying an insurance premium for a benefit that you hope you'll never need. But having your house destroyed in a fire, or generating no income for 12 months whilst you recover from chemo, are going to set you back a long way financially.

    Insurance premiums are known and can be planned for. Having insurance in place ensures that the hard work that got you to where you are today, is not undone by one instance of bad luck.

    Important Information:

    This information is of a general nature only and has been prepared without taking into account your particular financial needs, circumstances and objectives. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information, it is not guaranteed. You should obtain professional advice before acting on the information contained in this publication.

    9 min
  • Tim's big jump - from bank manager to primary school teacher - Episode 55

    Episode 50 – Tim's big jump - from bank manager to primary school teacher

    Today in the episode, we talk to Tim Lavrey's career change story from being a bank manager to a preschool teacher

    In this interview we cover:

    • Tim's love for football
    • The story of Tim's career change and how he made his move and decision to leave the bank and teach
    • His redundancy and how it contributed to his career change
    • Going through self-doubt during the process
    • Their 6-month period of planning for his career shift, finances, income and budget and their 3-month trial period before the big change
    • How Tim prepared for university and teaching and the struggles he went through
    • Examples of how he created opportunities for himself while studying and after graduation
    • His feelings about his new profession as a teacher
    • His thoughts about the things he'd do differently
    • How good planning, structure, and discipline can help with your financial stability
    • The story of how Tim's wife, Mary Anne, made a big change in her career recently
    • How teamwork contributed to successfully making the changes in their lives

    Links mentioned in the show

    Mini Retirement Planning Checklist

    39 min
  • Pay off the mortgage or invest? - Episode 54

    Episode 54 – Pay off the mortgage or invest?

    A shout out here to Christine Calnan who emailed me about this dilemma – whether it is best to put your savings towards extra mortgage repayments, or should you instead be investing?

    This is one that does come up a lot when I'm working with clients, and it's certainly not a question with a simple one size fits all answer. So let's take a look at the factors you should consider to find the answer that's right for you.

    Christine observed that whilst the question of whether savings should be put to extra mortgage repayments or investment is something faced by plenty of people, there's not a lot written about it when you do a bit of Googling. And there's a good reason for that – the real answer is "it depends", and no one likes to give, or receive that answer.

    Arriving at the answer that's right for you is very dependent on 2 key assumptions – what will future home loan interest rates be, and what will the return be on your investment.

    Boil it down and the question is really, "will I earn more on an investment than I'll pay on the mortgage?"

    Mortgage rates are at historical lows at the moment, typically around 4.5%.

    Both the US and Australian share markets have averaged returns of a little under 10% over the long term.

    Now there is tax to pay on your share investment, and this is one key reason why there is no one size fits all answer – we live in a marginal tax world where different people pay different rates of tax.

    To further complicate matters, Australian shares throw off franking credits, which offset some and potentially all of your tax liability on these holdings.

    To lean on the conservative side, let's assume that a third of your investment return goes to the tax man. Your 10% total return becomes 6.6%, still comfortably ahead of the mortgage rate.

    So on this simple analysis, the preferred strategy would seem to be to priorities investment in shares over additional mortgage repayments.

    The tricky bit though is considering whether current mortgage interest rates will continue into the future. If you send your savings to an investment, what happens if in 5 years' time mortgage rates rise to 8%? At this sort of level it would be very tough for an investment to provide an after tax return that would exceed this.

    Then there's the question of share market returns and a topic I've raised before – sequencing risk.

    It's all very well to say the average share market return is 9 point something percent, but it varies a lot year to year. Will you actually experience the average return? So with the investment option, you have uncertainty as to the result you will get, whereas under the extra mortgage repayments scenario, you have certainty, you have definitely saved the home loan interest rate. The value of that certainty should not be under estimated. Paying off your home loan is effectively a guaranteed outcome.

    To help address the uncertainty of your investment return, you should ensure that when planning your strategy, you're thinking of a minimum time frame of 5 years, and ideally 10 years plus. The longer you invest for, the more likely it is that your outcome will come in at around the long term average

    Perhaps it's worth considering whether this mortgage vs invest question need be so binary. Could you do both?

    At its simplest, if you can save $400 per month you could quite easily put half off that to your mortgage and invest the other half. Hedge your bets.

    You could spice things up though. Maybe you direct your savings to investments, but then have all the income those investments produce paid off your home loan. Or maybe you even use some equity in your home to buy investments, potentially creating a negative gearing scenario. You're savings go towards servicing this new investment loan, and once again the investment income is used to make extra mortgage repayments. Because you've borrowed to kick things off, your investment portfolio will be bigger, meaning your investment income will be larger, which means more money to pay off your home loan.

    Another way you could go is to focus initially on paying down the home loan with all of your savings, and then once this is done, using the equity in your home to borrow and buy an investment portfolio. So a sequential, rather than parallel approach. The attraction of this is that you've achieved the certain saving of having paid off your mortgage, and then once you re-borrow to invest, the interest expense will be tax deductable given the investments will produce taxable income. And because you're borrowing against your home, the interest rate will be low compared to the alternatives, which will help make the strategy profitable.

    The only downside with this approach is the opportunity cost of having no market exposure during the loan repayment phase.

    It's worth addressing the fact that I've talked here about share market investments and not property investments. There's a couple of reasons for this, but it mainly boils down to risk. A well-diversified portfolio of Australian and International shares is far less risky than a single residential investment property, relying on one tenant to pay on time and look after the place. There are also a lot more transaction costs associated with property – stamp duty, agent's fees, maintenance costs, council rates, and on it goes. Plus, an investment property is a big chunky investment. You can't do it for $200 a month, and you can't quickly liquidate it if your circumstances change.

    To answer Christine's question, on balance, whilst interest rates remain at historic lows, it is likely that investment is a better option than additional mortgage repayments. But you would want a well diversified investment portfolio of 100% growth assets, and keep a close eye on the interest rate on your home loan. If it started to creep up, the answer might flip, at which point you could sell your shares and pay the proceeds off your mortgage in one lump sum. It's also essential that you appreciate that there is some risk and a positive outcome cannot be guaranteed.

    This is very general advice, and I'd strongly urge you to sit down with someone and run the numbers that are specific to you. Your tax circumstances, time frame, job security, and broader financial position are all relevant factors in determining what is right for you.

    A reminder that there's a free toolkit for you to download that provides a simple checklist of the things you should consider when evaluating whether you should be focused on paying down the mortgage or investing. So visit the financialautonomy.com.au web site to grab your copy.

    I hope you've found today's post interesting. If you've got a question that you think others in the Financial Autonomy community might also face, drop me an email, I'd love to hear from you.

    My name's Paul Benson and thanks for listening to the Financial Autonomy podcast, where we help you gain the choices that you seek. Until next week, bye for now.

    Important Information:

    This information is of a general nature only and has been prepared without taking into account your particular financial needs, circumstances and objectives. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information, it is not guaranteed. You should obtain professional advice before acting on the information contained in this publication.

    9 min
  • Investment Power-Ups - Episode 53

    Episode 53 – Investment Power-Ups

    I was binge watching a fictional Netflix series last week about a group of 4 guys who had made an app that had become a huge hit, Angry Birds style.

    Each of the 4 guys had particular skills, and there was a scene where one of the guys was feeling pretty lost. He bemoaned to his friend how such and such was great at art, another coding, and the 3rd guy, the one he was speaking to, was great at game design. But he asked, what was he in the group for?

    His friend considered this for a moment and said, "you know what you are in the team for? You're the power-ups. When we were just about to run out of money, you went out and found more. When Johnny went off the rails, you brought him back. You hired some key people without whom, none of this success would have happened. And you made us all rich when you found a buyer willing buy our business. So, yeah, you're the power-ups".

    It was a great scene and it really stuck with me. It also made me think about what the power-ups are in the investment world. What are those things that really accelerate your investment plans? Well, I believe there are 3, and that's what we'll be exploring in today's episode.

    A great way you can keep up with what's happening here at Financial Autonomy is to sign up to our monthly email update "Gaining Choice". You can do that by clicking on the Updates tab, which, depending on the device your using will be either at the bottom or right hand side of the page. As well as sharing the episodes released in the previous month, I share a Financial Autonomy experience or observation that've I've come across, news about what we've got coming up, and a podcast tip of the month. Importantly, it is only monthly, so we won't be filling your in-box with more content than you could ever consume – as you will hopefully have noticed with these fairly short podcast episodes – quality over quantity is our mantra.

    Wikipedia describes power-ups as "objects that instantly benefit or add extra abilities to the game character as a game mechanic."

    If you're old enough to remember Pac-Man, the power-up of eating the power dots in the corners let you chase the ghosts, or in Sonic the Hedgehog, the most common power-up made you go much faster. From Super Mario Bros to modern day Clash of Clans, power-ups are an integral part of most video games.

    Whilst all of these games can be played without the power-ups, the core objective of the game is either impossible or at least extremely difficult to achieve without using them.

    And so when thinking about the achievement of your Financial Autonomy goal, whether that be a 6 month mini retirement at age 40, a career change next year, or a move to a regional town, what are the investment equivalents of a power-up, that can bring your goals within reach.

    I have identified 3 investment power-ups. They are:

    1. Regular savings and dollar cost averaging
    2. Gearing
    3. Dividend reinvestment and compounding

    Let's take a look at each in some detail.

    Regular savings and dollar cost averaging

    If you want to build up wealth to gain the choices in life that you deserve, then you need to save. And there is no better way to save than to commit to a regular savings plan. By this, I mean you have an automated process whereby a certain amount of money is transferred out of your normal living bank account and into investments.

    There are two reasons why this strategy brings success. For one, it bakes in discipline. The investment just happens. No chance for you to spend the money on some other non-essential item, or use the cash to book a flight to Hawaii. Part of the discipline benefit is also that it ensures you live to your budget – the money just comes straight out of your account, so you can only live off what remains. Savings discipline is far from an easy thing, so don't under-estimate this benefit.

    The second reason an automated regular savings plan works is because of dollar cost averaging. Now I realise this is a bit of jargon, which is something I usually try to avoid, but in this case it's not a tough concept to get your head around.

    Dollar cost averaging deals with the fact that there is never a perfect time to invest. It reminds me of something a keen fishing friend of mine once told me – "the best time to go fishing is whenever you can".

    So rather than picking one moment in time and hoping that it proves to be a great entry point for your investment, you invest regularly, typically monthly. The price that you pay for your investment will vary month to month. Some months you pay a little more, some a little less. But over time what you get is the average price. Sure you don't get the lowest price, but you also don't get the highest either.

    A great example of how effective this process can be was seen during the 2008 period where share markets declined considerably. Many people who invest discretionarily, put things on hold during that period and sat on their cash. But for those with automated regular savings plans, they bought every month, and when markets recovered from 2009 onwards, the prices they paid for their investments during that period looked really attractive. There was no way to know during 2008 when the market would reach the bottom. So holding off and trying to pick that point is a mugs game. But through the discipline of investing regularly, you continue to buy during the dips, and you get the dollar cost average benefits of averaging out your purchase price.

    In fact assuming you are an employee, you are already engaged in an automated savings plan that utilises dollar cost averaging – it's your superannuation contributions.

    Gearing

    The second investment power-up is Gearing, and this is probably the most impactful.

    Gearing means borrowing for investment purposes, and like gears in an engine, the purpose is to magnify outcomes. As a simple illustration, if you have $10,000 invested and it grew by 8%, at the end of the year you would have $10,800. But had you matched that $10,000 with another $10,000 or borrowed money, your total investment would have grown to $21,600. Once you paid back the $10,000 that you borrowed, you'd be left with $11,600, so double the gain, or growth of $1,600, compared to the original $800.

    Now of course no-one will lend you the money for free, so you will need to pay some interest on the money that you borrowed, and that will reduce your gain. Indeed if the cost of borrowing were high enough you would reach a point where it would wipe out all of the gain. But the point is that for the same investment return, your gain is greater as a consequence of having geared.

    Now of course when thinking about gearing it is always important to remember that gearing magnifies both positive and negative outcomes. So in the earlier example, had the original investment lost 8%, then under the geared scenario the outcome would have been even worse.

    So gearing isn't a free hit. It needs to be considered thoroughly. In particular your investment time frame is important. You need to be able to wait out an investment market downturn. In my work with clients I wouldn't consider a gearing strategy unless the investor had a time frame of at least 5 years.

    Property investment is perhaps the best known form of geared investment. There aren't many people who pay cash for a property. Back in episode 25 I highlighted the significant impact that gearing had on my first property purchase, so if you haven't already consumed that one, check it out Episode 25 – My 68% return. The power of gearing – how smart borrowing can accelerate your journey to financial autonomy.

    Dividend reinvestment and compounding

    I've written and spoken a lot about the power of compounding, most recently in the Settlers of Catan / Early Retirement episode, number 43. Sometimes described as the 8th wonder of the world, the idea of earning interest on your interest is compelling, and certainly qualifies as an investment power-up.

    The best use of compounding is reinvesting dividends on share and ETF investments. I've had several clients over the years who bought Commonwealth Bank shares back when they floated all those years ago. They bought a few thousand dollars' worth, and ticked the box to have the dividends reinvested. That means that each 6 months when a dividend is paid, instead of the investor receiving the cash, the money is used to buy more shares.

    Roll forward 20+ years, they're retired and are thinking about a new car or a big European holiday. Those CBA shares that they haven't given much thought to are now worth $80,000, and they've got some great options. Sure, the share price has gone up, but that alone would have only gotten them to about $25,000. The rest of the growth is the power of compounding. And let's face it, if they had have taken the cash with each dividend payment, it would have just got absorbed into the normal spending. A new pair of shoes, or the electricity bill. There'd be nothing to show for it now.

    Again, your super fund will be doing a form of this. All the earnings go back into the fund to fuel further growth. It explains why, early on in your working life your balance doesn't seem to grow a lot, but 20 years into your career you tend to see more rapid gains – this is your past earnings generating new earnings.

    So there you have it, my 3 investment power-ups – Regular Savings and Dollar Cost Averaging, Gearing, and Dividend Reinvestment and Compounding.

    Hopefully you can use some or all of these to power-up your journey to Financial Autonomy.

    Until next week, bye for now.

    Important Information:

    This information is of a general nature only and has been prepared without taking into account your particular financial needs, circumstances and objectives. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information, it is not guaranteed. You should obtain professional advice before acting on the information contained in this publication.

    13 min

About Financial Autonomy

From the publisher's feed

What would it take to retire earlier, build a reliable income from your investments or simply have more freedom to live life on your terms?

More shows like Financial Autonomy

Motley Fool Money by LiSTNR

Motley Fool Money

83 Listeners

The Money Puzzle by The Australian

The Money Puzzle

49 Listeners

Investopoly by Stuart Wemyss & Campbell Wallace

Investopoly

14 Listeners

money money money by Glen James

money money money

45 Listeners

The Rules of Investing by Livewire Markets

The Rules of Investing

12 Listeners

Equity Mates Investing Podcast by Equity Mates Media

Equity Mates Investing Podcast

68 Listeners

Australian Investors Podcast by Rask

Australian Investors Podcast

11 Listeners

Australian Finance Podcast by Rask

Australian Finance Podcast

16 Listeners

this is property by John Pidgeon & Rachelle Kroon

this is property

4 Listeners

Get Started Investing by Equity Mates Media

Get Started Investing

29 Listeners

The Money Café with Alan Kohler by Intelligent Investor

The Money Café with Alan Kohler

42 Listeners

Retire Right by Glen James

Retire Right

27 Listeners

Australian Property Podcast by Rask

Australian Property Podcast

4 Listeners

Aussie FIRE | Financial Independence Retire Early by Hayden Smith & Dave Gow

Aussie FIRE | Financial Independence Retire Early

6 Listeners

Australian Retirement Podcast by Rask

Australian Retirement Podcast

9 Listeners