Mediawatch

Horse race journalism as National takes aim at squeezed middle


Listen Later

As National announced its long-awaited tax plan, some journalists took a hard look at its numbers, while others focused more on political strategy and impact.

As National announced its long-awaited tax plan, some journalists took a hard look at its numbers, while others focused more on political strategy and perception.

National leader Christopher Luxon started the day of his party's long-awaited tax policy announcement assuring Newstalk ZB's Mike Hosking his numbers were "rock solid".

After several elections batting off accusations of fiscal holes and other budgetary misadventures, National had commissioned the consultancy Castalia Advisors to check its plan and it found them to be, in the words of the party's deputy leader Nicola Willis, "possible and plausible".

Luxon wasn't giving Hosking all the details of his possible and plausible schemes, but he was saying who they would benefit, setting a record for use of the phrase "squeezed middle" in a five-minute timeframe.

The party's effort to relieve the squeeze was unveiled a few hours later and that prompted a tide of headlines trumpeting the tax plan offering the average household $250 a fortnight.

That was something of a coup for National's PR team.

Not only did they get news organisations to highlight the biggest figure from their press release; they got them to use their preferred unit of measurement for people (households rather than individuals) and time (fortnightly rather than weekly).

As Thomas Coughlan noted in the New Zealand Herald, that made the figures look larger - and presumably made the party's political sales job a little easier.

$250 a fortnight - or $125 a week as it's sometimes known - would still be a pretty good tension remover for the tightly compressed middle.

But as it turns out, National may be unclenching with one hand and squeezing with the other.

Its $250-a-fortnight saving for an average family with kids includes $150 from its Family Boost tax credit.

But that credit would also replace the 20 hours of free childcare for two-year-olds that Labour offered in this year's Budget. That could be worth around $133 a week for families - or $266 a fortnight.

That - according to a robust, consultant cross-checked Mediawatch statistical analysis - is more than $150. Or even $250 (though it is obviously more targeted and comes with less flexibility than a cash handout).

Other fishhooks were highlighted in the media as the day wore on.

TVNZ Breakfast producer Tom Day flicked through National's tax plan to find a single line noting it would scrap Labour's Community Connect scheme.

https://twitter.com/tomdaynz/status/1696687537929281716…

Go to this episode on rnz.co.nz for more details

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

MediawatchBy RNZ

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

4 ratings


More shows like Mediawatch

View all
Saturday Morning by RNZ

Saturday Morning

38 Listeners

Nine To Noon by RNZ

Nine To Noon

20 Listeners

Sunday Morning by RNZ

Sunday Morning

13 Listeners

Focus on Politics by RNZ

Focus on Politics

11 Listeners

Nine To Noon Politics by RNZ

Nine To Noon Politics

3 Listeners

FROM ZERO by RNZ

FROM ZERO

1 Listeners

Go Ahead Caller by RNZ

Go Ahead Caller

1 Listeners

Gone By Lunchtime by The Spinoff

Gone By Lunchtime

22 Listeners

Here Now by RNZ

Here Now

1 Listeners

Slice of Heaven by RNZ

Slice of Heaven

1 Listeners

The Lost by RNZ

The Lost

43 Listeners

Pants on Fire by RNZ

Pants on Fire

103 Listeners

The Science Of… by RNZ

The Science Of…

1 Listeners

The Front Page by NZ Herald

The Front Page

15 Listeners

The Worst Sitcom Ever Made by RNZ

The Worst Sitcom Ever Made

7 Listeners

The Detail by RNZ

The Detail

55 Listeners

Best of Storytime by RNZ

Best of Storytime

3 Listeners

The Fold by The Spinoff

The Fold

4 Listeners

The Citizen's Handbook by RNZ

The Citizen's Handbook

3 Listeners

After the Virus by RNZ

After the Virus

0 Listeners

The Service by RNZ

The Service

31 Listeners

MATA with Mihingarangi Forbes by RNZ

MATA with Mihingarangi Forbes

1 Listeners

Short Story Stack by RNZ

Short Story Stack

0 Listeners

Fight for the Wild by RNZ

Fight for the Wild

4 Listeners

The News Agents by Global

The News Agents

1,314 Listeners

Deer Wars by RNZ

Deer Wars

5 Listeners

30 with Guyon Espiner by RNZ

30 with Guyon Espiner

5 Listeners

Juggernaut 2: The Story of the Fourth National Government by The Spinoff

Juggernaut 2: The Story of the Fourth National Government

6 Listeners

Voice of Tangaroa by RNZ

Voice of Tangaroa

2 Listeners

Hair and Loathing by TAHI

Hair and Loathing

0 Listeners

Sci Fi / Sci Fact by RNZ

Sci Fi / Sci Fact

4 Listeners

Making Cents by Frances Cook

Making Cents

16 Listeners

The Stolen Children of Aotearoa by RNZ

The Stolen Children of Aotearoa

2 Listeners

No Stupid Questions with Susan Edmunds by RNZ

No Stupid Questions with Susan Edmunds

0 Listeners

Search & Rescue NZ by RNZ

Search & Rescue NZ

4 Listeners