
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


In this episode of Hot Takes on the Classics, Tim McIntosh and Emily Maeda explore Nikolai Gogol’s “The Nose,” a fantastical satire in which a barber discovers a nose in his breakfast bread and an ambitious St. Petersburg official awakens to find his own nose missing. Worse still, the missing nose has acquired a higher government rank than its owner. Tim and Emily consider Gogol’s Ukrainian roots and literary legacy, the story’s eccentric narrator and its tradition of skaz, and the comedy of a society obsessed with appearances, titles, and advancement. Along the way, they consider why such an improbable tale can feel unsettlingly familiar—and why its absurd humor still divides readers.
Episode Outline
Key Topics & Takeaways
Questions & Discussion
Suggested Reading & Resources
In this episode of Hot Takes on the Classics, Tim McIntosh and Emily Maeda explore Raymond Carver’s “A Small, Good Thing,” a story of parental grief that moves from isolation and rage toward an unexpected moment of forgiveness. After eight year old Scotty is struck by a car and later dies in the hospital, his parents are repeatedly disturbed by calls from a baker who knows only that they failed to collect his birthday cake. Their furious confrontation with him changes when he learns what has happened, confesses his own loneliness and cruelty, and offers them fresh bread in the middle of the night. Tim and Emily connect this ending to communion, Carver’s later gentleness after sobriety, his spare and repetitive prose, and the small flashes of transcendence that make hope shine so brightly against the bleakness of his world.
Episode Outline
Key Topics & Takeaways
Questions & Discussion
Suggested Reading & Resources
In this episode of Hot Takes on the Classics, Tim McIntosh and Emily Maeda explore Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll’s House, the 1879 play whose ending shocked European audiences and helped redefine modern drama. They trace the legal and social pressures behind Nora Helmer’s secret loan, her forged signature, and the blackmail that threatens to expose her, while paying close attention to Ibsen’s use of dialogue, stage space, furniture, and compressed time to build a mounting sense of confinement. When Torvald’s response reveals that his concern for reputation outweighs his understanding of Nora’s sacrifice, the apparent melodrama becomes a radical argument about marriage, personhood, education, and freedom. Tim and Emily close by wrestling with the most difficult part of Nora’s departure, her decision to leave her children, and whether the famous final door slam was the only path toward a real marriage.
Episode Outline
Key Topics & Takeaways
Questions & Discussion
Suggested Reading & Resources
In this episode of Hot Takes on the Classics, Tim McIntosh and Emily Maeda explore Isak Dinesen’s “Babette’s Feast,” a story about beauty, sacrifice, holiness, and the demanding vocation of the artist. In a quiet Norwegian religious community shaped by austerity, Babette arrives as a refugee and spends twelve years serving two aging sisters before using her entire lottery fortune to prepare one magnificent French feast. Tim and Emily consider how the meal restores memory, fellowship, delight, and spiritual vision to the community, and how Babette brings material beauty and spiritual devotion together rather than setting them against one another. The episode closes by considering the artist as a formidable figure whose devotion to a vision can require radical sacrifice.
Episode Outline
Key Topics & Takeaways
Questions & Discussion
Suggested Reading & Resources
In this special spouses episode of Hot Takes on the Classics, Tim McIntosh and Emily Maeda are joined by Gaelyn Hurd and Mark Maeda to ask two deceptively simple questions: What is classical education, and what convinced each of them that it was worth pursuing? Their answers range across the great conversation, the classical canon, grammar, dialectic, rhetoric, Latin, history, virtue, wonder, and the relationship between curriculum and method. Along the way, they reflect on their own schooling, homeschooling and hybrid school experiences, memorable encounters with poetry and great books, and the importance of helping students see knowledge as an interconnected whole. The episode closes by surveying the rapid growth of the classical education movement and asking whether the renewal is moving from a pioneering phase into a new institutional era.
Episode Outline
Key Topics & Takeaways
Questions & Discussion
Suggested Reading & Resources
In this episode of Hot Takes on the Classics, Tim McIntosh and Emily Maeda explore James Baldwin’s “Sonny’s Blues,” a story about two brothers trying to understand one another across the distance created by responsibility, suffering, addiction, and art. They discuss Baldwin’s lyrical prose, his Harlem upbringing and life in Paris, the tension between the older brother’s dutiful path and Sonny’s vocation as a jazz musician, and the way music gives form to experiences that ordinary speech cannot contain. The episode culminates in the jazz-club scene, where listening becomes an act of recognition and the narrator finally begins to understand why music is necessary to Sonny’s life.
Episode Outline
Key Topics & Takeaways
Questions & Discussion
Suggested Reading & Resources
In this episode of Hot Takes on the Classics, Tim McIntosh and Emily Maeda explore Ernest Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants,” a story in which the most important subject is never named. At a Spanish train station, an American man and a young woman called Jig wait for a train to Madrid while circling around a “simple operation” that will determine the future of their relationship. Tim and Emily discuss Hemingway’s iceberg theory, the story’s compressed setting and dialogue, the unequal pressure between the couple, and the way Jig sees possibility where the man sees a threat to freedom. They close with Tim’s Hot Take and a discussion of what the story reveals about the difficult passage from adolescence into adulthood.
Episode Outline
Key Topics & Takeaways
Questions & Discussion
Suggested Reading & Resources
In this episode of Hot Takes on the Classics, Tim McIntosh and Emily Maeda explore Flannery O’Connor’s “Everything That Rises Must Converge,” a story of young adulthood, race, pride, dependence, and painful moral awakening. Set largely on a city bus, the story brings Julian, a self-consciously progressive college graduate, into collision with his cheerful but deeply prejudiced mother as the changing South forces people who would rather remain separate into uncomfortable proximity. Along the way, Tim and Emily consider O’Connor’s grotesque humor, her idea of dark grace, the story’s title from Pierre Teilhard de Chardin, and the devastating moment when Julian’s superiority gives way to guilt and sorrow.
Episode Outline
Key Topics & Takeaways
Questions & Discussion
Suggested Reading & Resources
In this episode of Hot Takes on the Classics, Tim McIntosh and Emily Maeda explore T. S. Eliot’s “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock,” a poem that captures the uncertainty and self-consciousness of adolescence and early adulthood. They consider Prufrock’s anxious journey through the modern city, his inability to act or speak decisively, and Eliot’s use of jarring images, near rhymes, and the dramatic monologue to make interior experience visible. Along the way, Tim and Emily discuss why modernist writers broke with inherited forms, how Eliot remained deeply engaged with the tradition he challenged, and why Prufrock’s fear of embarrassment, wasted possibility, and an ordinary adult life remains so recognizable.
Episode Outline
Key Topics & Takeaways
Questions & Discussion
Suggested Reading & Resources
In this episode of Hot Takes on the Classics, Tim McIntosh and Emily Maeda explore Jon Fosse’s Trilogy, the work of a Norwegian novelist and playwright whose spare, musical prose gives voice to experiences that resist ordinary explanation. Focusing primarily on “Wakefulness,” they follow the young lovers Asle and Alida as they wander through cold and rain searching for shelter before the birth of their child, while memories of music, love, rejection, and the past flow through the present. Along the way, Tim and Emily consider Fosse’s use of repetition and stream of consciousness, the story’s echoes of the Nativity, the self-giving character of young love, and the way his writing holds together harsh physical realities with a sense of mystery and transcendence.
Episode Outline
Key Topics & Takeaways
Questions & Discussion
Suggested Reading & Resources
From the publisher's feed

8,876 Listeners

20,277 Listeners

1,119 Listeners

4,431 Listeners

7,109 Listeners

876 Listeners

726 Listeners

21,163 Listeners

869 Listeners

741 Listeners

1,256 Listeners

1,281 Listeners

120 Listeners

219 Listeners

563 Listeners