For most of a decade, the performance marketing edge came from audience strategy. Which targeting, which lookalikes, which exclusions. Media buying was the skill, and creative was just the fuel you fed it. That advantage has quietly disappeared as Meta, Google and TikTok have absorbed the targeting levers into the platform.

Most brands are still organised around the old model: budget and attention pointed at audience strategy, with creative treated as execution. The brands pulling ahead have flipped it. They know the machine now finds the right person, so the only thing left to control is what you put in front of them. The question isn't whether an ad is good. It's whether the pipeline has enough creative in it to keep finding what works.

The brands getting this right do three things differently.

In this playbook, based on a conversation with Justin Babet, founder of Chief Nutrition, we cover three things ecommerce operators need to know about building a creative machine that finds winners:

• Creative does the targeting now, so the lever that matters has shifted from audience strategy to content production
• A content machine is a system before it's a creative problem, and the fix is finding the blocker that's stalling your output
• Volume only works if new creative gets a genuine test in its own campaign, away from your proven winners

Connect with Justin Babet Explore Chief Nutrition

Subscribe to the Add To Cart newsletter 
SMS us to Suggest a Guest
Connect with Nathan Bush
Join the Add To Cart Community