Erin shares the deeds of a dirty cop Gerard Schaefer that would offer rides to hitchhikers who would mysteriously go missing. Stacey tells of the terrible day when Rex Mays snapped, and in his misplaced rage, murdered his two young neighbors.Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/ISGDpodcast)

Support the show

Stacey shocks us with the apparent satanic ritualistic murder of 19-year-old Arlis Perry done in the sanctity of her own church. Erin retells the Keddie cabin murders in which a quadruple homicide takes place in a rural resort town in Northern California.Support the show

Support the show

Erin tells us of 17-year-old Mike Mansholt whose vacation turned tragic after a fatal bike ride through the Malta hills. At first his death was ruled an accident, but after further investigation his family believes foul play to be involved. Stacey shares the 1987 case of the Menendez brothers, Lyle and Erik, who brutally murdered their wealthy parents in their Beverly Hills home. Initially the brothers weren’t suspects, but their behavior shortly following the murders began to raise suspicions. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/ISGDpodcast)

Support the show

Stacey describes the brutal assault and eventual murder of Jill Cahill at the hands of her ex-husband Jeff Cahill. Erin shares the horrific murders committed by Leonarda Cianciulli who later turned her victims into soap and cakes.Support the show

Support the show

Erin tells the horrifying story of a Christmas party gone wrong, where Bruce Pardo massacres the Ortega family. Stacey recounts the gruesome details of the murder and beheading of Silvestre Diaz at the hands of his girlfriends nephew, Alexis Valdez.Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/ISGDpodcast)

Support the show

Stacey shares the missing persons case of Alissa Turney where her stepfathers suspicious actions leave you wondering if he didn't cause her disappearance. Erin recounts the crimes of Toronto's most prolific serial killer Bruce McArthur AKA "The Lawnmower Man" and how some seemingly standard planters lead to his demise.Missing Alissa Podcast: https://www.missingalissa.comPetition to convict Mike Turney:https://www.thepetitionsite.com/842/331/976/demand-michael-turney-go-to-trial-for-the-death-of-alissa-turney/Support the show

Support the show

Erin recounts the gruesome story of the cannibal couple Natalia and Dmitry Baksheev. Stacey horrifies us with the unsolved murder of Faith Hedgepeth, a member of the Haliwa-Saponi tribe.Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/ISGDpodcast)

Support the show

Buckle up everyone! This episode contains a lot of shit talk… and we mean that literally! Stacey tells the story of the murderous rampage of Douglas Comiskey against two beloved priests of a local Pueblo, Co church. Erin shares Diana Lovejoy and Weldon McDavid Jr’s hastily concocted plan to murder.  Death Invades the Rectory by Betty L. Alt & Sandra K. Wells:https://www.amazon.com/Death-Invades-Rectory-Betty-Alt/dp/1457546868Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/ISGDpodcast)

Support the show

Erin mixes things up a bit by sharing the morbidly uplifting story of the lynching of an Indian slum warlord, Akku Yadav, who was a known rapist and murderer. Stacey tells the frustrating story of the death of Cindy James in which the outcome of the investigation is controversial.Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/ISGDpodcast)

Support the show

Stacey regales us with an account of the mysterious death of a beloved VA nurse, Deborah Ann Wolfe, and infuriating investigation which follows. Erin treats us all to another dramatic reading while recounting the tragic murder/suicide of Zach Bowen and Addie Hall which took place above a Voodoo Spiritual Temple Support the show

Support the show