Send a text

Yall are getting a two-fer in this episode. First, Casey and Husband Derek discuss the case of Pamela Carnahan from Louisiana, then Sarah and Casey are going to discuss the case of Carmen Montelongo from California.

Sources: 

Southern Gothic
Season 1, Episodes 5 (Bloodshed in the Bayou)
Can be Streamed on: Hulu

Snapped
Season 16, Episodes 4 (Bloodshed in the Bayou)
Can be Streamed on: Hulu (Carmen Montelongo)

Support the show

Send a text

Join us as we discuss our lives and laugh away our woes!

Support the show

Send a text

In March, 1998, the Bradley stepped aboard a cruise ship. Four family members sailed away, but only three would return home. 23-year-old Amy seemed to vanish in thin air. Join Casey and Sarah as they dive down numerous rabbit holes to see it they can find Alice in Wonderland.

Source: Amy Bradley is Missing

Episodes 1, 2, 3 (Vanished at Sea; I Saw Her; Message in a Bottle)

Can be Streamed on: Netflix

www.foxnews.com “Brother of woman who vanished from cruise 27 years ago reveals critical third witness,” by Peter D’Abrosca

www.pajiba.com “Netflix’s ‘Amy Bradley is Missing’ Leaves Out a Damning Revelation,” by Dustin Rowles

Support the show

Send a text

Join Casey, Sarah, Husband Derek, and Captain Ron (Casey's Dad and Sarah's Uncle) as they interview Fire Chief Ronnie Carrier during his time of Hurricane Katrina.

August 29, 2025 marks the 20th anniversary of Hurricane Katrina.

Support the show

Send a text

Join Casey and Sarah as they conclude the harrowing story that was Hurricane Katrina in this second part podcast. If you haven't listened to last week's episode, go back and listen to that one first.

The source for this episode is Hulu's Hurricane Katrine: Race Against Time

Support the show

Send a text

Join Casey and Sarah as they discuss everything from the book Casey desperately needs Beta readers for to Husband Derek's theory about Karen Read.

Support the show

Send a text

It helps to hit publish, so, because I (Casey) forgot to check, you're getting a two-fer today. Join us as we discuss life.

Support the show

Send a text

This is Part 1 of 2. Tune in next week for Part 2!

Join Sarah and Casey as they discuss the mishaps of 2005's Hurricane Katrina. Only an hour and a half away from where they live, Hurricane Katrina struck like a thief in the night and when all seemed clear, the worst happened: the levees that acted as barriers gave way.  In a matter of hours, citizens desperately mounted their roofs, praying for aid. 

The source for this episode is Hulu's Hurricane Katrina: Race Against Time, episodes 1-: The Coming Storm and Worst-Case Scenario

Support the show

Send a text

What happened to John O'Keefe? In this episode, we conclude the case of Karen Read. Was he killed by Karen? Or the people in the house party they were at? What more could possibly come out in trial.

Tune in for the conclusion that just took place in June of this year.

If you want to watch our source, you can check out "A Body in the Snow, The Trial of Karen Read," on HBO Max.

If you like this episode or the podcast in general, please give us a rating anywhere you listen to your podcasts!

Support the show

Send a text

What have we been up to over the last year? Tune in and find out! This is a mini episode where we discuss our personal lives.

Support the show