Mediawatch

Media shift blame for misleading tax policy headlines


Listen Later

This week political reporters seized on fresh figures showing the National Party overstated the benefits of its tax cut policy - and accused its leaders of misleading the public. Yet some of them had repeated the party's spin in their own reports when it was unveiled a month ago - and even praised the 'political marketing.

This week political reporters seized on fresh figures showing the National Party overstated the benefits of its tax cut policy - and accused its leaders of misleading the public. Yet some of them had repeated the party's spin in their own reports when it was unveiled a month ago - and even praised the 'political marketing.'

"The National Party has admitted that its much-feted tax cut of $250 a fortnight will only go to 3000 families. Despite knowing that number all along the party is denying it's mislead the public," Newshub at 6 told viewers on Thursday.

The revelation followed research from the Labour Party-aligned Council of Trade Unions, and Newshub political reporters spent a full frustrating day trying to pin down National for a response.

But when National's policy was first announced back in early September to ease what the party dubbed "the squeezed middle" it included claims an "average income family" with children would benefit.

But Newshub didn't mention its own reporters were among those who feted the policy in the first place.

And they weren't the only ones to give National's maximum fortnightly benefit headline billing when the policy was unveiled.

Families in line for $250 a fortnight under National tax cut, said The Press.

National promises $250 more a fortnight for average households, said Interest.co.nz.

Election 2023: National's tax plan offers average household with kids $250 and Kiwi worker $50 a fortnight, said The New Zealand Herald.

Under that Herald headline the paper's deputy political editor Thomas Coughlan pointed out "all the savings are expressed as fortnightly figures rather than weekly figures, making them look larger."

On Mediawatch, Hayden Donnell pointed out many reports also adopted the National Party's preferred unit of measurement for people as well - 'households' rather than individuals.

Also, most reports neglected to mention the $250-a-fortnight saving for a qualifying family also included $150 from the already announced Family Boost tax credit scheme. That could also replace the 20 hours of free childcare for two year-olds announced in the Budget this year. …

Go to this episode on rnz.co.nz for more details

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

MediawatchBy RNZ

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

4 ratings


More shows like Mediawatch

View all
Saturday Morning by RNZ

Saturday Morning

35 Listeners

Nine To Noon by RNZ

Nine To Noon

17 Listeners

Sunday Morning by RNZ

Sunday Morning

12 Listeners

Focus on Politics by RNZ

Focus on Politics

11 Listeners

Nine To Noon Politics by RNZ

Nine To Noon Politics

1 Listeners

FROM ZERO by RNZ

FROM ZERO

1 Listeners

Go Ahead Caller by RNZ

Go Ahead Caller

1 Listeners

Gone By Lunchtime by The Spinoff

Gone By Lunchtime

22 Listeners

Here Now by RNZ

Here Now

1 Listeners

Slice of Heaven by RNZ

Slice of Heaven

1 Listeners

The Lost by RNZ

The Lost

42 Listeners

Pants on Fire by RNZ

Pants on Fire

102 Listeners

The Science Of… by RNZ

The Science Of…

1 Listeners

The Front Page by NZ Herald

The Front Page

17 Listeners

The Worst Sitcom Ever Made by RNZ

The Worst Sitcom Ever Made

7 Listeners

The Detail by RNZ

The Detail

34 Listeners

Best of Storytime by RNZ

Best of Storytime

2 Listeners

The Fold by The Spinoff

The Fold

3 Listeners

The Citizen's Handbook by RNZ

The Citizen's Handbook

3 Listeners

After the Virus by RNZ

After the Virus

0 Listeners

The Service by RNZ

The Service

31 Listeners

MATA with Mihingarangi Forbes by RNZ

MATA with Mihingarangi Forbes

0 Listeners

Short Story Stack by RNZ

Short Story Stack

0 Listeners

Fight for the Wild by RNZ

Fight for the Wild

4 Listeners

The News Agents by Global

The News Agents

1,006 Listeners

Deer Wars by RNZ

Deer Wars

3 Listeners

30 with Guyon Espiner by RNZ

30 with Guyon Espiner

16 Listeners

Juggernaut 2: The Story of the Fourth National Government by The Spinoff

Juggernaut 2: The Story of the Fourth National Government

7 Listeners

Voice of Tangaroa by RNZ

Voice of Tangaroa

2 Listeners

Hair and Loathing by TAHI

Hair and Loathing

0 Listeners

Sci Fi / Sci Fact by RNZ

Sci Fi / Sci Fact

3 Listeners

Making Cents by Frances Cook

Making Cents

13 Listeners

The Stolen Children of Aotearoa by RNZ

The Stolen Children of Aotearoa

2 Listeners

No Stupid Questions with Susan Edmunds by RNZ

No Stupid Questions with Susan Edmunds

0 Listeners

Search & Rescue NZ by RNZ

Search & Rescue NZ

4 Listeners