Send us a text message !

This episode dives into the chaotic, unsettling, and downright bizarre case of Carnigie, a man whose unraveling mental state and explosive behavior turned a once‑ordinary life into a spiraling true‑crime spectacle. What starts as a portrait of a troubled individual quickly escalates into a series of unpredictable, dangerous events that left a community stunned and scrambling for answers.

With their signature blend of dark humor, empathy, and Michigan‑rooted storytelling, the hosts guide listeners through Carnigie’s escalating instability, the warning signs that went unheeded, and the shocking incident that cemented his place in Michigan’s strangest criminal lore. They keep the tone grounded and respectful, balancing the absurdity of Carnigie’s antics with the very real human cost of untreated mental health struggles and unchecked volatility.

After the wild and unnerving true‑crime deep dive, the episode shifts into its musical spotlight, featuring Orson’s Well. Their rich, atmospheric sound delivers the show’s trademark “good note,” giving listeners a cathartic, melodic exhale after a story filled with tension, unpredictability, and small‑town chaos.

Orson's Well
Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/orsonswellband?mibextid=ZbWKwL
Bandcamp
 https://orsonswell.bandcamp.com/track/worth-this-song-radio-edit
Youtube
https://youtube.com/@orsonswell8373

Michigan Murders & Music
Website
https://michiganmurdersmusic.com
Merch
https://partner.spreadshirt.com/shop-area/101145818/shop
Feeling Tipsy?
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Written by Your Highness 
Hosted by Ron and Mary Boot
Hosted  by the Boot Productions

Support the show

Support the Show:https://www.buzzsprout.com/1387693/supporters/new

Feeling Tipsy???
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Merch:
https://michigan-murders-music.myspreadshop.com/

Send us a text message !

This episode plunges into one of Michigan’s most disturbing and surreal true‑crime cases — the story of Brady Oestrike, a man whose double life spiraled into violence, deception, and a horrifying crime that stunned the state. Known online for his bizarre “medieval” fantasies and dark obsessions, Oestrike crafted a persona that blurred the line between role‑play and reality, ultimately leading to a deadly encounter arranged through Craigslist.

With their signature blend of empathy, dark humor, and Michigan‑rooted storytelling, the hosts guide listeners through the chilling buildup to the crime, the red flags hidden in plain sight, and the shocking discovery that revealed just how far Oestrike’s fantasies had gone. They keep the tone grounded and respectful, focusing on the victims, the investigation, and the unsettling psychology behind a case that still haunts true‑crime circles.

After the intense and deeply unsettling deep dive, the episode shifts into its musical spotlight, featuring Jacob Hoekwater. His soulful, emotionally rich sound delivers the show’s trademark “good note,” offering listeners a moment of reflection and grounding after one of the series’ darkest and most unforgettable cases.

Jacob Hoekwater
Website
https://jacobhoekwatermusic.weebly.com
Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100010788301818
Bandcamp
https://jacobhoekwater.bandcamp.com/
Youtube
https://youtube.com/@jacobhoekwater1504

Michigan Murders  & Music
Website
https://michiganmurdersmusic.com
Merch
https://partner.spreadshirt.com/shop-area/101145818/shop
Feeling Tipsy????
https://youtube.com/@jacobhoekwater1504

The Chase: 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WcNiX5gwN0U
Brady's CCTV: 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylOsTw9FcvA

Michigan Murders & Music
Website
https://michiganmurdersmusic.com
Merch
https://partner.spreadshirt.com/shop-area/101145818/shop
Feeling Tipsy?
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Written by Your Highness 
Hosted by Ron and Mary Boot
Hosted  by the Boot Productions

Support the show

Support the Show:https://www.buzzsprout.com/1387693/supporters/new

Feeling Tipsy???
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Merch:
https://michigan-murders-music.myspreadshop.com/

Send us a text message !

This episode unravels the tragic and deeply perplexing disappearance of Cullen Finnerty, the beloved Grand Valley State quarterback whose larger‑than‑life presence on the field made his sudden vanishing all the more shocking. What begins as a missing‑person search in the Michigan wilderness quickly turns into a case clouded by confusion, conflicting theories, and a heartbreaking truth that challenges early assumptions.

With their signature blend of empathy, clarity, and Michigan‑rooted storytelling, the hosts guide listeners through Finnerty’s final hours, the frantic search efforts, and the medical and environmental factors that ultimately shaped the real explanation behind his death. They cut through years of speculation to focus on the human story — a gifted athlete battling unseen struggles, a family desperate for answers, and a community grappling with the loss of a hometown hero. The tone remains grounded and respectful, emphasizing understanding over sensationalism.

After the emotional deep dive, the episode shifts into its musical spotlight, featuring Don Mastro

Don Mastro
Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/THEDONMASTRO
Website
http://donmastro.com/
Bandcamp
https://donmastro.bandcamp.com/
Youtube
https://youtube.com/@DONMASTRO

Michigan Murders & Music
Website
https://michiganmurdersmusic.com
Merch
https://partner.spreadshirt.com/shop-area/101145818/shop
Feeling Tipsy??
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Written by Your Highness 
Hosted by Ron and Mary Boot
Hosted  by the Boot Productions

Support the show

Support the Show:https://www.buzzsprout.com/1387693/supporters/new

Feeling Tipsy???
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Merch:
https://michigan-murders-music.myspreadshop.com/

Send us a text message !

Please enjoy our idea of comedy. 
Remember, we are eternally 12! 
In no way shape or form is this item real, nor intended to be real.
We DO NOT CONDONE anyone doing such a thing...
Do not sneak anything into anyone at a jail or prison.
Definitely do not insert such things into the anal cavity.

Michigan Murders & Music
Website
https://michiganmurdersmusic.com
Merch
https://partner.spreadshirt.com/shop-area/101145818/shop
Feeling Tipsy?
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Written by Your Highness 
Hosted by Ron and Mary Boot
Hosted  by the Boot Productions

Support the show

Support the Show:https://www.buzzsprout.com/1387693/supporters/new

Feeling Tipsy???
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Merch:
https://michigan-murders-music.myspreadshop.com/

Send us a text message !

In this gripping continuation of the John McRae saga, the hosts return to one of Michigan’s most disturbing and far‑reaching criminal histories. “Nae Nae Pt. 2” digs deeper into McRae’s life after his first conviction — a story marked by manipulation, secrecy, and a chilling ability to hide in plain sight. What emerges is a portrait of a man who managed to evade suspicion for decades, even as disappearances and tragedies continued to follow him.

With their signature blend of empathy, dark humor, and Michigan‑rooted storytelling, the hosts unravel the second chapter of McRae’s twisted path. They explore the failures that allowed him to reinvent himself, the communities unknowingly placed in danger, and the heartbreaking cases that resurfaced long after the fact. The tone remains grounded and respectful, keeping the focus on the victims and the long shadow McRae cast over multiple generations.

After the heavy true‑crime deep dive, the episode shifts into its musical spotlight, featuring Al & The Black Cats

Al and the Black Cats
Youtube
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCnjlip84Sdus3uu-4P0c2rw
Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/alandtheblackcats

Michigan Murders  & Music
Website
https://michiganmurdersmusic.com
Merch
https://partner.spreadshirt.com/shop-area/101145818/shop
Feeling Tipsy??
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Written by Your Highness 
Hosted by Ron and Mary Boot
Hosted  by the Boot Productions

Support the show

Support the Show:https://www.buzzsprout.com/1387693/supporters/new

Feeling Tipsy???
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Merch:
https://michigan-murders-music.myspreadshop.com/

Send us a text message !

This episode marks the beginning of one of the most disturbing multi‑part stories in Michigan’s criminal history — the early years of John McRae, a boy whose violent impulses and chilling lack of remorse set the stage for decades of tragedy. “Nae Nae Pt. 1” traces McRae’s childhood, the warning signs that were ignored, and the shocking crime that first brought his name into the public eye.

With their signature blend of empathy, dark humor, and Michigan‑rooted storytelling, the hosts guide listeners through McRae’s troubled upbringing, the community’s stunned reaction, and the legal aftermath that would shape the rest of his life. They keep the tone grounded and respectful, focusing on the victim, the ripple effects of the crime, and the unsettling realization that this was only the beginning of a much darker story.

After the heavy true‑crime deep dive, the episode shifts into its musical spotlight, featuring Al & The Black Cats. Their high‑energy, punk‑driven sound delivers the show’s trademark “good note,” giving listeners a cathartic release after the first chapter of one of Michigan’s most haunting cases.

Al and the Black Cats.
Youtube
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCnjlip84Sdus3uu-4P0c2rw
Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/alandtheblackcats

Michigan Murders & Music
Website
https://michiganmurdersmusic.com
Merch
https://partner.spreadshirt.com/shop-area/101145818/shop
Feeling Tipsy?
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Written by Your Highness 
Hosted by Ron and Mary Boot
Hosted  by the Boot Productions

Support the show

Support the Show:https://www.buzzsprout.com/1387693/supporters/new

Feeling Tipsy???
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Merch:
https://michigan-murders-music.myspreadshop.com/

Send us a text message !

This episode unpacks the violent and chaotic case of Jason Klemp, a night that began with casual drinks at The Attic and spiraled into one of the most shocking assaults in the area’s recent memory. What starts as a typical night out quickly devolves into confusion, rage, and brutality — a sequence of events that left investigators piecing together a timeline clouded by alcohol, adrenaline, and conflicting accounts.

With their signature blend of empathy, dark humor, and Michigan‑rooted storytelling, the hosts guide listeners through the hours leading up to the attack, the explosive confrontation that followed, and the aftermath that stunned the community. They explore the dynamics of the relationships involved, the red flags that went unnoticed, and the devastating consequences of a night that veered wildly off course. The tone stays grounded and respectful, keeping the focus on the victim, the investigation, and the sobering reality of how quickly violence can erupt when tempers and substances collide.

After the intense true‑crime deep dive, the episode shifts into its musical spotlight, featuring Anonymous Phonecall. Their gritty, atmospheric sound delivers the show’s trademark “good note,” giving listeners a cathartic release after a story filled with tension, chaos, and the lingering question of how everything went so wrong so fast.

Anonymous Phonecall.
Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/AnonymousPhoneCall
Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCyelwUVjYvt3i0hj-XxNITg


Michigan Murders & Music
Website
https://michiganmurdersmusic.com
MERCH:   
https://partner.spreadshirt.com/shop-area/101145818/shop
Feeling Tipsy?
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Written by Your Highness 
Hosted by Ron and Mary Boot
Hosted  by the Boot Productions

Support the show

Support the Show:https://www.buzzsprout.com/1387693/supporters/new

Feeling Tipsy???
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Merch:
https://michigan-murders-music.myspreadshop.com/

Send us a text message !

This episode barrels through one of the most chaotic stretches of criminal mayhem Michigan has ever seen — a two‑week spree where seven different people managed to unleash a whirlwind of violence, stupidity, desperation, and pure bad decision‑making. It’s the kind of story that feels too wild to be real, yet every twist is pulled straight from police reports, court records, and the baffled memories of those who lived through it.

With their signature blend of dark humor, empathy, and Michigan‑rooted storytelling, the hosts break down how this ragtag cluster of criminals crossed paths, collided with the law, and left a trail of confusion in their wake. From impulsive acts to coordinated chaos, the episode explores how quickly things can spiral when the wrong people get the wrong ideas at exactly the wrong time. Despite the absurdity, the tone stays grounded and respectful, highlighting the victims, the community impact, and the ripple effects of a spree that felt like it would never end.

After the fast‑moving true‑crime ride, the episode shifts into its musical spotlight, featuring Jesse Ray and the Carolina Catfish. Their gritty, high‑octane rock‑and‑roll sound delivers the show’s trademark “good note,” giving listeners a cathartic blast of energy after a story packed with tension, madness, and Michigan‑flavored chaos.

 


Jesse Ray and the Carolina Catfish.
Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/jesserayandthecatfish
Bandcamp
https://jrcc.bandcamp.com/
Youtube
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCxzNG2VDOlfVauSU7m6KwcQ
Email
[email protected]

Michigan Murders & Music
Website
https://michiganmurdersmusic.com
MERCH:   
https://partner.spreadshirt.com/shop-area/101145818/shop

Written by Your Highness 
Hosted by Ron and Mary Boot
Hosted  by the Boot Productions

Support the show

Support the Show:https://www.buzzsprout.com/1387693/supporters/new

Feeling Tipsy???
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Merch:
https://michigan-murders-music.myspreadshop.com/

Send us a text message !

Would you enjoy just hearing the tunes from our featured bands???   Here's our first compilation out of many to come.    Please download and enjoy!!

Please check these bands out and let them know that The Boots sent you!   We love our local music scene.  You can find most of this music on bandcamp.com.  Thank you for supporting the podcast and local music....either ours or yours!

Thunder Chicken:  Gin & Etonics

Brother Adams w/Dead Eye Zack:  Street Rat Strut

Brother Adams:  Devil Came from Tucson

Fukashima Daisies

The VonWherewolves:  Death of You

The VonWherewolves:  Speedball

The Swineharts:  Like a Dog

The Setbacks:  One Kiss

The War Between:  All My Mind

The War Between:  Can’t Make You Go

All Night Tigers:  Proverbial

Dead Eye Zack:  Building Blocks

Black Bear Blonde:  I’m In Love with a Satanist

Lazy Hands:  Imaginary Western

The Moonrays

The Bitters

Gimmick:  Acid

Paper Lanterns:  Crash & Burn

North 131:  White Rushin

Slumlord Radio:  Bullwhip

Rent Strike:  Burn It All

The Concussions:  Put Your Head on my Shoulders

Michigan Murders & Music
Website
https://michiganmurdersmusic.com
MERCH:   
https://partner.spreadshirt.com/shop-area/101145818/shop
Feeling Tipsy?
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Written by Your Highness 
Hosted by Ron and Mary Boot
Hosted  by the Boot Productions

Support the show

Support the Show:https://www.buzzsprout.com/1387693/supporters/new

Feeling Tipsy???
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Merch:
https://michigan-murders-music.myspreadshop.com/

Send us a text message !

This episode turns its focus to one of Michigan’s most heartbreaking and enduring mysteries — the disappearance and death of Amanda Lankey, a bright 13‑year‑old girl who vanished from a friend’s home in June 2004 and was later found murdered. More than two decades later, the case remains unsolved, leaving a family without answers and a community still haunted by the questions that linger.

With their signature blend of empathy, clarity, and Michigan‑rooted storytelling, the hosts retrace Amanda’s final known steps, the confusing early hours of the investigation, and the troubling details that have kept this case alive in the minds of those who refuse to let her story fade. They highlight the inconsistencies, the missed opportunities, and the people who may hold pieces of the truth — all while keeping the focus firmly on Amanda, her loved ones, and the hope that renewed attention might finally spark movement.

As with all unsolved episodes, the tone remains grounded and respectful, emphasizing the victim and the urgent need for answers rather than speculation or sensationalism.

After the emotional deep dive, the episode shifts into its musical spotlight, featuring The Concussions

Bandcamp
https://theconcussions.bandcamp.com/releases
Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/theconcussions
Website
https://www.stormsurgeofreverb.com/content/top-100-surf-records-2010s-20-1?fbclid=IwAR3QUlG7ak1zFxrH3j_JealJm_JoCaSFw0o0LGH8n6bb1QxYaTIZp6-NZDU
Youtube
https://youtube.com/channel/UCPn-yFzfNOU59n6-Ykf405A


Michigan Murders & Music
Website
https://michiganmurdersmusic.com
MERCH:   
https://partner.spreadshirt.com/shop-area/101145818/shop
Feeling Tipsy??
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Written by Your Highness 
Hosted by Ron and Mary Boot
Hosted  by the Boot Productions

Support the show

Support the Show:https://www.buzzsprout.com/1387693/supporters/new

Feeling Tipsy???
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theboots

Merch:
https://michigan-murders-music.myspreadshop.com/